3 ms·
> Do you have a proposal for how to get there without stepping over tens of thousands of broken lives? An innocent unless proven guilty law. Employers, et cete
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> Do you have a proposal for how to get there without stepping over tens of thousands of broken lives?
An innocent unless proven guilty law. Employers, et cetera, may not conclude adversely from criminal charges absent a guilty plea or conviction.
- RHSeeger 2y agoBut are they allowed to not hire someone if doing so would draw public outrage (and financial harm) against the company? What about if the person was arrested for something that would cause that, but never actually charged? In the US at least, being arrested (or even accused) of certain things can end your career. Because, even it it's proven you didn't do it, no company will touch you with a 10 foot pole, because people (who don't care/know that you were innocent) will avoid the company if they hire you. There is no known solution to this problem.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> are they allowed to not hire someone if doing so would draw public outrage (and financial harm) against the company? Yes, that's the point of such a law. The company gets to deflect blame to it.
- giantg2 2y ago"But are they allowed to not hire someone if doing so would draw public outrage (and financial harm) against the company?" Could you face the same because of gay/trans/etc hiring? That's the point of anti-discrimination laws - that nobody is allowed to discriminate and thus the public outrage is diluted if all are hiring the "undesireables".
- _heimdall 2y ago"Allowed to" pulls a lot of weight here, do you mean legally, socially, or something else? I do agree though, there's no good solution to the problem. That's one of the biggest indicators for me that state regulation, at least enforceable regulation, isn't the right answer. Companies, employees, industry organizations, etc can all come up with their own solutions that they're happy with though. A primary feature of federalism is allowing smaller groups to try different solutions, its pretty good at more quickly finding a solution that may actually work well enough universally
- _heimdall 2y agoThat's such a huge gray area though. One doesn't know why an employer or anyone else decides to fire, or not hire, someone unless the employer documents the reason. We already have discrimination laws on the books in the US that can't reliably be enforced for this exact reason. I have heard multiple accounts of very clear discrimination taking place in org hiring practices, but they are never documented and when discussed everyone is very careful with their words.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> One doesn't know why an employer or anyone else decides to fire, or not hire, someone unless the employer documents the reason It won't be entirely effective. But it gives companies plausible deniability. I've been the one who voiced up because a sealed marital-dispute arrest came up in an archival background check. Having such a law would have meant doing so was unremarkable, a routine comment.
- foogazi 2y ago> may not conclude Are you going to erase their memories Men-In-Black style ?