4 ms·
I don't think 3D printing is going to replace injection molding any time soon, even for relatively small runs. The cycle time is just so much longer - an inject
by TylerE 14y ago
I don't think 3D printing is going to replace injection molding any time soon, even for relatively small runs. The cycle time is just so much longer - an injection molding machine can make most parts, even quite large ones (think big plastic trashcans) in on the order of less than a minute, sometimes much less depending on the machine. That's also ignoring that the plastics you can injection mold have better mechanical properties and surface finishes, too.
Of course, true small run stuff isn't usually injection molded anyway, due to the amount of time and effort and high grade tool steel it takes to make the mold.
Where 3D printing really IS changing things is prototyping and the occasional one-off part, but we're quite far off production usage.
- tluyben2 14y agoYes, even for DYI's, 3D printing now (even with the rough ones) is a cheap tool to just try out prototypes. And try out A LOT of prototypes cheaply. Even though they are slow, it is cheap and you just can try out so many things before you go to production with CNC & injection molding. And you can give away limited prototypes so you can do market research with the printed models; even though they are rough, I have seen them work well enough for people to get this 'wow I want this' feeling.
- TylerE 14y agoIt's not event that cheap. Makerbot charges $45 per KG for their raw material, whereas steel (in bulk) is more like $1/kg, and even in small orders (like say small bar stock) is $10-$15/kg.
- tluyben2 14y agoThat's why I wouldn't use it for anything else but prototyping. But what would you consider for fast prototyping instead of a 3D printer? With the same flexibility; you basically input (not that simple, but you know) a 3D model and get your prototype as output (like said; that's oversimplified but that's how I use it)? But I am very new to this; it's only a hobby; i'm checking out 2nd hand CNC machines, but in my mind that's for the next step, after the prototyping.
- TylerE 14y agoWell, it depends on what you're doing. The problem with 3d printed stuff is that it isn't very strong - you can make crazy curved gears and stuff with it, but it's not going to hold load. Honestly, for prototyping for small amounts of money, your best bet is probably a bridgeport-type vertical mill. You can do turning/lathe operations on one of those too with the right accessories. Not automated, and not fast, but if you need to make one off parts it's about your only option for hobbyist-type money. You'd be buying used, obviously, and you'd need a garage/workroom (This isn't something you set up in your house)... There are some fairly economical small CNC machines now (We're talking $2k or so, price-wise), but they are intended primarily for model makers - any part over about 2"-3" and they literally can't cut it, where-as with a good manual milling machine and some time/sweat, you will typically have 24" x 24" x 10" travel available.
- tluyben2 14y agoThanks; that's interesting to know. I have a large workspace so i'll look into that. Sweat I don't care about :)
- ChuckMcM 14y agoOk I gave it 10 years as a minimum, is that soon? That number came from the transition in DIY computers to computers for business which I put between 1978 (all hobby) to 1988 where we've got the Mac, the PC, and some lesser known brands (Amiga and Atari) replacing the 'big iron' in companies for some tasks. As with computers, if a 3D printer is cheap enough you can run 200 in parallel to get production rates into the 'few thousand widgets per day' Today the surface finish and the materials are not up there (but a 2K byte Altair 8800 wasn't really a contender to do desktop publishing either :-) The thing you have to be careful of is this: "That's also ignoring that the plastics you can injection mold have better mechanical properties and surface finishes, too." because that thinking will bite you back. It just has to be 'good enough' and cheaper and it puts those characteristics into the 'nice to have' category. I agree that there will probably always be a market for some injection molding but I can see that it will be the 'specialized' stuff and not the 'general' stuff. Just a matter of time.
- TylerE 14y agoCommercial injection modeling is going to be at the rate of perhaps a thousand per hour, not per shift. Many parts will be set up so that a single "hit" of the mold can produce dozens of parts. In manufacturing, processes are used that have a minimum number of steps. Cycle time is critical. Even CNC doesn't have that much penetration outside of a very few select industries, namely aerospace and some automotive. Very little, if anything, on a consumer product will be CNC made, for much the same reasons 3D printing will have a very hard time catching on for production. One real niche for CNC is actually making molds for injection molding - that's one case where taking dozens of hours to cut a single part isn't a problem, as that one mold can stamp hundreds of thousands of parts. Source: I'm actually a manufacturing engineer by training. EDIT: And yes, I think 10 years is much too soon. Industry has a huge amount of money invested in existing factories. Much of that equipment is useable for decades to come. You would have to get quite a bit better than the existing standard for them to even think about replacing the existing lines.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoAwesome, I disagree of course but its a great discussion. My experience is with the integration of low cost compute into the flows rather than manufacturing. However I find it striking how similar your argument sounds to the ones that IBM made early on about how PCs would 'never' threaten mainframes because they didn't have the IO capabilities or the printing capability. And while certain markets still use them (credit card processing for example), a lot of things they were used for succumbed to a new way of doing things because it was cheap. I suspect that much of the challenge with CNC penetration is with the costs involved. But could easily be wrong. Current injection molding does make thousands per hour and that's certainly achievable with thousands of 3D printers running in parallel, but the place where I think you will first see disruption will be in the 'short run' segments, where people would make 100,000 parts (minimum run) and only sell 10,000 units. Their price per unit was effectively 10x in that case. But they have no other way to get to 10,000 at the moment. In the compute space that is how the market disrupted, lower performance of the unit offset by the savings of not having to over provision for the compute capacity. Will be interesting to watch.