4 ms·
And when the next crazy guy brings in gallons of gas and lights people on fire? Edit: I don't particularly like guns, but non-representative, singular incident
by MichaelGG 14y ago
And when the next crazy guy brings in gallons of gas and lights people on fire?
Edit: I don't particularly like guns, but non-representative, singular incidents to change policy seems like a very poor way to start debates or come to proper conclusions.
- scott_s 14y agoAnd at what point do such things become a pattern? Unfortunately, mass shootings happen in the US at a rate of roughly one per year.
- gizmo686 14y agoSo about one shooting a year, this year's had 12 fatalities. Remember that heat wave/power outage combination we had on the east cost (USA); at least 46 fatalities [1] [1]http://usnews.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/07/06/12597271-dozens-of-deaths-tied-to-heat-wave-over-last-2-weeks?lite http://usnews.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/07/06/12597271-dozens...
- scott_s 14y agoAnd I hope that as a result of those outages, the power companies and state and local governments will evaluate if any policy or infrastructure changes could improve their ability to get the power back on.
- riffraff 14y agofirearms killings _are_ a pattern, if I recall correctly they are something between 5 and 10 times more frequent in US than other first wold countries. I personally believe that US citizens are unable to understand how dumb their attitude to weapons is, but + mass shootings wouldn't be much impacted by changes in the policy + mass shooting don't seem to have a strong correlation with firearm policy
- learc83 14y agoI agree with you on the mass shootings aspect. However... >firearms killings _are_ a pattern, if I recall correctly they are something between 5 and 10 times more frequent in US than other first wold countries. I personally believe that US citizens are unable to understand how dumb their attitude to weapons is, You can't compare crime rates without controlling for other differences. Most other first world countries are much more ethnically homogenous than the U.S. And they don't suffer from the cultural problems caused by the fairly recent institutional persecution of an entire class of people. It's not very PC to talk about, and I think that the high incidence of crime amongst black Americans is directly caused by the decades of persecution they suffered which causes them to occupy a lower socio-economic position on average than whites, not any inherent racial differences. But whatever the reason, whites and blacks both have similar access to guns and similar gun ownership rates, yet if you only count white americans, you'll find a fairly similar gun crime rate to the rest of the first World, so clearly, easy access to guns isn't the problem. The closest country I can think of to our situation is South Africa (Rights recently restored to an historical lower class. Though it's still not a great comparison because of their relatively lower GDP per capital, and different demographics). Their gun violence rate is about 5 times that of the US.
- sgoranson 14y agoOffhand, do you know of any material that delves deeper into that taboo topic? Sociologically I find it really interesting but like you said, it's not a popular subject.
- learc83 14y agoYou can check the DOJ for statistics, but I've found it incredibly hard to find any unbiased analysis. I was interested in the topic after I saw a DOJ chart that listed crime by race. I had to research myself to find anything really useful, and by research I just mean taking data from DOJ statistics. The thing is, it's like we live in 2 separate countries, if you're white or asian, America is almost as safe as other first world countries. If you're Black or Hispanic it's much, much more dangerous.