6 ms·
Life expectancy/years of life lost in adults w ADHD in UK: matched cohort study
- _yb2s 2y agoI have ADHD, and I am certain that most of the reduced life expectancy is from chronic stress- a well established killer. With ADHD you frequently don’t have the executive control to do what you decided to do, and needs to get done. This leads to constantly being terrified of failing at everything, and letting everyone in your life down. Often calling yourself (and being called by others) lazy, unreliable, disorganized, etc. even when you care deeply and are doing everything you can to succeed. It would be nice to figure out what can be done about this. I’ve found I usually have dangerously high blood pressure, but a few minutes of slow exhale breathing exercises and a short walk brings it down to normal. Which I usually feel I am too stressed and busy to do.
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoDepression is a common co-morbidity also.
- AutistiCoder 2y agoprobably as a result of all the systemic issues surrounding ADHD.
- heyjamesknight 2y agoIt's much simpler and more biomechanical than that. ADHD at its core is a dopamine disorder. Effort without dopamine is extremely difficult in anyone, and ADHD makes it tough for these dopamine mechanisms to get going. Once that dopamine effect does get going, you're off to the races. That's the ADHD Hyperfocus effect you see. But when you add in the modern quick dopamine fixes we've surrounded ourselves with—media, social media, processed foods, pornography, etc.—you've built a situation where ADHD individuals are prioritizing those activities over productive ones. This leads to a downward spiral: less productive action means fewer opportunities for future productive actions. Lock into that mode for weeks at a time and you've got both situationally-supported and biochemical depression.
- hirvi74 2y ago> ADHD at its core is a dopamine disorder. This is still merely hypothetical is it not? I have noticed people home in on dopamine, but no one ever mentions serotonin, glutamate, gaba, and all the other neurochemical systems. I also thought the biochemical basis for depression has been completely thrown out, is that also not true?
- _yb2s 2y agoYeah, we don't understand nearly enough about the brain to have a very mechanistic view of ADHD. With so many different types on a spectrum, and sometimes symptoms being caused by things like physical trauma or infection, it is likely there are different possible mechanisms. However, it certainly appears like dopamine is highly involved, but noepinephrine also seems to be involved as well. Medically, it is defined symptomatically, and not mechanistically.
- TheLegace 2y agoIt’s not that simple. The brain is a very complex system and once you get other components of your brain to a neurotypical baseline or even better ADHD is a gift. Those regions being sensory motor cortex and prefrontal cortex. But simply its a system of networks and attention regulation. Those networks can be trained and I have experienced it first hand by reversing engineering my own brain and training it beyond normal baseline. This training is called neurofeedback and it transformed my ADHD into a super power. During my evaluation my ability to focus(was measured) was worse than the average ADHD person. Afterwards it was above even normal people. I need don't even consider myself someone with ADHD and everything just seems to come together naturally. ( Deadlines, managing details, time management and planning- all prefrontal cortex) The networks in my brain have been training to switch normally, and hyper focusing is just focusing but on anything I really want. It was the cure I’d been searching for my whole life and it actually worked.
- bruce343434 2y agoCan you divulge more details about your neurofeedback training? What was it like, how long did it take, how did they measure the brain, what stimulus and which "punishment" for bad brain behavior was used?
- hirvi74 2y agoI completely agree with this. It's hard to not feel like a failure, you don't belong, low motivation, etc. when other people constantly reinforce this idea with both their words and their actions. I think a lot of this fuels the substance abuse issues in ADHD as well. I have always spent too much time playing video games, doom scrolling, etc.. It's all just an escape. But I think many do not understand -- I, and perhaps many others, escape from this world because I do not belong. Treatments for ADHD are cute and all, but nothing I have tried has really moved the needle much. At least not for long. There is always a reversion to the mean, and this condition always wins in the end.
- seizethecheese 2y agoYep. Immense stress can also be a learned proactive tactic. You build up stress via procrastination until the level is high enough to overcome any disfunction.
- tstrimple 2y agoI called it anxiety based development when I was in dev roles. Worked okay up until the physical symptoms forced me to find alternatives. The alternative for me is I no longer write code for a living.
- _yb2s 2y agoWhat do you do now, and is it better?
- tstrimple 2y agoI moved from development to architecture and that helped for a few years. New focus different things to learn. Then the same things started happening there. I moved more into management and was good there for a bit and then same patterns emerged. Jumped to consulting and it’s the same story. Now am exploring more “leadership” style roles. I realize I personally do a LOT better when I’m actively learning and doing new things in a job. If it’s something I know I can do and have done it many times it’s like my mind refuses to engage eventually unless the anxiety overrides it. It’s getting more difficult though. Especially with consulting giving me insights into how dozens of very large technology orgs are run. The problems are almost always the same and it’s rarely technical. I used to always enjoy starting at new companies. But more and more it’s just the exact same patterns and even that is rarely engaging. At some point I think I’ll have to leave tech altogether and explore something completely different. Just hope I can survive until the kids are out exploring on their own so I can take a break on the cash flow demands.
- cbsmith 2y agoIt's taken me most of a lifetime to figure out that this is kind of the opposite of the right way to deal with the problem. You're effectively fighting fire with fire, and the whole thing needs to not be a fight at all.
- 9dev 2y agoThis is so hard to explain, especially to people dear to you. Like, how many times can you say I‘m sorry, I didn’t ignore your messages on purpose, I just… couldn’t before they grow tired of it? And at the same time you notice how you desperately long for the contact, but the guilt and shame for letting people wait indefinitely makes it ever harder to actually reach out. It’s a devious cycle, and constant source of ever-increasing stress. Don’t have energy cause I fucked things up, fuck things up because I don’t have energy.
- _yb2s 2y agoI know, there is nothing I hate more than letting people down and yet end up doing so multiple times per day- and it’s demoralizing. I have so many systems, reminders, etc. that do help a lot but not enough.
- AutistiCoder 2y agoalso, you're less likely than the general population to get hired and more likely to be fired if you do get a job.
- hirvi74 2y agoGood luck getting any help if you live in one of the only countries that has healthcare tied to employment. It's easy to slip into a hole with almost no way out.
- giantg2 2y agoI wonder if chronic stress leads to a reduced life expectancy for ASD too?
- enragedcacti 2y agoSubstance abuse, suicide, and impulsive behavior are also likely contributors[1]. There are multiple studies that have found medication is associated with a significant reductions in unnatural deaths [2][3]. It really is underappreciated IMO that ADHD medications are some of the most effective pharmacological interventions in all of psychiatry. There are risks and concerns but by and large they are figuratively and literally life-saving. [1] https://www.adhdevidence.org/evidence#premature-death https://www.adhdevidence.org/evidence#premature-death [2] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10936112/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10936112/ [3] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10901868/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10901868/
- DontchaKnowit 2y agoI guess it depends on the treatment, but amphetamine based adhd treatment was for me, the fucking devil. It absolutely ruined my life for the 8 years I was on it. Fucked my health up, fucked my personality up, fucked my interpersonal relationships up, etc. But hey I was slightly better at focusing at work. Kinda. When I wasnt habitually dopamine chasing by playing video games or jerking off
- cbsmith 2y ago> I guess it depends on the treatment, but amphetamine based adhd treatment was for me, the fucking devil. Fortunately, we now have options other than amphetamines, but yes, in general, like most diseases, ADHD is categorized by symptoms, not really causes, and so lots of treatments that work wonderfully for some people with ADHD are literally the worst thing for other people with ADHD.
- moltar 2y agoWhat are the new options? Thank you.
- cbsmith 2y agoSo, on the medication side, there are NRIs (norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor) and alpha-2A agonists. The latter in particular work kind of the opposite of stimulants. A psychiatrists described the difference to me with the metaphor of a sound system where you're having trouble listening to the music. The stimulants are amplifiers that push up the volume. The other approach is a better preamp that does a better job reducing the noise. Depending on the nature of your problem, one is going to help a lot, and the other is going to be useless at best, but could well make the problem worse. I presume you're aware of the other non-pharmaceutical interventions, like CBT. Generally they don't have as high a success rate, but that doesn't mean that they aren't be the right solution for you.
- mantas 2y agoSimplify your life, go cheap and use extra time to both reduce stress and spend less time in stressful situations. I’m probably an undiagnosed ASD and that’s what I ended up doing and plan to take to more extreme level as life situation allows. Fancy stuff and „fitting in“ is not worth it.
- hirvi74 2y agoI am starting to come to this same conclusion. What is the point in playing the game if you can't win? If I accomplish all my goals and fulfill my ambitions, then what? I can just be like Ozymandias?
- s1artibartfast 2y agoIt is interesting to see so many people wrestling with this question. I think it is a break through moment for a lot of people to realize that you get one life and get to spend it however you choose. There are no rules, only tradeoffs. You can be a beach bum in South America, or a hermit goat farmer.
- hirvi74 2y agoThe reward center of my brain is probably all kinds of jacked up, so perhaps people get something from these accomplishments that I do not. However, I agree with you. I have noticed this sentiment is leaking into even otherwise health individuals too -- mainly Gen Z and younger. I guess society is heading towards some massive existential crisis. If AI eventually meets the predictions that some people have, then perhaps the issue will only get worse too.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoIm not sure I follow, but I think there is something about it related to either age or generation. It seems like a lot of people are going through life on autopilot without thinking about what they really want, questioning what makes them happy, and ending up very dissatisfied with the results. I think there is something powerful about feeling like you chose the life you are living among the options available.
- floxy 2y agoPeople with ADHD are involved in more car crashes: https://www.publichealth.columbia.edu/news/research-shows-strong-link-between-adhd-car-crashes-older-adult-drivers https://www.publichealth.columbia.edu/news/research-shows-st... They are also at higher risk for any type of unintentional injury: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10107297/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10107297/ I believe that people with ADHD are over-represented in first-responder type careers, which also carries more risk: https://www.ems1.com/ems-products/fitness-mental-health-wellness/articles/distracted-impulsive-understanding-adhd-in-first-responders-K0N3YlP94MxGJaYa/ https://www.ems1.com/ems-products/fitness-mental-health-well... And are know to engage in more risky behavior in general: https://neurolaunch.com/no-sense-of-danger-adhd/ https://neurolaunch.com/no-sense-of-danger-adhd/ And substance abuse among those with ADHD is much higher than the general population: https://www.webmd.com/add-adhd/adhd-and-substance-abuse-is-there-a-link https://www.webmd.com/add-adhd/adhd-and-substance-abuse-is-t...
- hirvi74 2y agoI am somewhat skeptical of the car crash research. Being "involved" in a car accident does not paint a clear enough picture. I think it would be more interesting to see that data on whether people with ADHD are more likely to be found at fault in car accidents. With cellphones and other distractions now, I feel like the data would be even harder to parse through. Is a person with ADHD more likely than the average person to text while driving? I do not think that would be an incorrect assumption, but I would like to see data suggesting this.
- cbsmith 2y agoFault is a tricky term in this context. Humans face a number of challenges when driving. Cars, roads, laws, traffic systems, etc. have all evolved to help them meet those challenges, but it is all shaped by our expectations of the humans. When a human doesn't perform to those expectations, we say it is their fault. When an accident occurs despite them meeting those expectations, it's not their fault. But folks with ADHD have brains that don't match society's expectations; cars, roads, laws, traffic systems, etc. have not evolved to help them. Their brains are effectively a chaos factor for all the safeguards we have in place... Even their advantages can be disadvantages because everything was designed to help someone who didn't have them. Even if an accident wasn't their fault, I think it's quite credible that people with ADHD might just be more likely to be in situations where there is a higher risk of an accident... and I'd expect it'd be more common for accidents to be their "fault", because again, how we determine fault is defined by expectations they conform to.
- cbsmith 2y agoStress is certainly a killer, but it's a facet of a broader factor. Society has built up a lot of systems to support people, to protect us from our environment and ourselves, and they've been incredibly successful; average lifespans have increased dramatically... literally by decades. For the most part, these systems are built in response to and designed around how "we" expect peoples' brains work. If your brain doesn't work those ways, many of those support systems are unnecessary, ineffective, or worse still: harmful. There's also no doubt a bunch of systems that could be designed & built that could to help support & protect people with challenges that are largely non-existent for people whose brains work as we expect. That the combined consequence of this is less that a decade of life expectancy for people with ADHD is actually quite remarkable, but let's not kid ourselves: we could be doing so much better.
- hirvi74 2y ago> we could be doing so much better I do not see that happening in my life time. Modern society values none of the things that would help people with ADHD -- relaxed deadlines, less emphasis on productivity, valuing human lives over profits, etc.. Maybe someday in the future AI can take much of the burden off us, but till then, I only see things getting worse.
- cbsmith 2y ago> Modern society values none of the things that would help people with ADHD Yeah, I wouldn't expect that modern society is going to value things that would help people with ADHD. One might hope that modern society might value people with ADHD, at least enough to help them some. It's not like society's expectations of people don't change over time. They do. That said, my statement that "we could be doing so much better" wasn't really a hopefully statement. It was more a statement of fact, and a recognition that society's expectations are killing a lot of people with ADHD.
- morkalork 2y agoI find that stress leads to this endless cycle of drinking at night to clam the brain (otherwise I spend half the night panicking and ruminating over every little thing), followed by energy drinks the next day to keep focused without taking proper medication. I ended up having to quit most of it when the toll on the body was too much after years and years.
- dwaltrip 2y agoThere are other ways. Please get help if you can, you deserve it. We all deserve help in overcoming the obstacles we face. I made the most progress once I got help in accepting and loving myself, thanking parts of me for fighting hard to take care of me and get where I am, and gently letting go of old patterns that don’t serve me anymore. A good therapist (hard to find) can help immensely Wishing you the best.
- kanwisher 2y agoWould love a summary of this
- _yb2s 2y agoThey establish that people with ADHD live shorter lives by about 6-9 years on average. They speculate on, but do not directly investigate possible reasons for this.
- amarcheschi 2y agoCopy pasting the article: The aim of this study was to provide the first estimate of life expectancy for UK adults diagnosed with ADHD. We found that adults diagnosed with ADHD are living shorter lives than they should: the apparent years of life lost for males was around 7 years, and for females, 9 years, compared with the general population. We believe that this is unlikely to be because of ADHD itself and likely caused by modifiable factors such as smoking, and unmet mental and physical health support and unmet treatment needs. The findings illustrate an important inequity that demands urgent attention.
- sillypuddy 2y agoThat's hilarious, can't tell if it's intentional or not.
- skylurk 2y agoLife's too short, I guess.
- ben30 2y agoVia Kagi Universal Summarizer Title: Life expectancy and years of life lost for adults with diagnosed ADHD in the UK: matched cohort study | The British Journal of Psychiatry | Cambridge Core ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder affecting attention and impulse control, often persisting into adulthood for about 90% of diagnosed children. The global prevalence of adult ADHD is estimated at 2.8%, yet many adults in the UK remain undiagnosed and unsupported. Individuals with ADHD face significant social and economic challenges, including educational underachievement, unemployment, and increased risk of substance abuse and mental health issues. Adults diagnosed with ADHD have a higher likelihood of experiencing various health problems, including cardiovascular diseases and mental health disorders, as well as a greater risk of suicide. A meta-analysis indicates that individuals with ADHD are twice as likely to die prematurely compared to the general population. The study estimated that adults with ADHD in the UK experience a loss of approximately 6.78 years of life for males and 8.64 years for females compared to their non-ADHD counterparts. The research utilized a matched cohort study design, analyzing data from UK electronic health records to assess mortality and life expectancy. Adults with ADHD often have comorbid conditions that complicate their health outcomes, leading to increased mortality rates. The findings emphasize the urgent need for improved support services and interventions for adults with ADHD to address their unmet health needs and reduce health disparities. The study calls for policy initiatives similar to those addressing the life expectancy of autistic individuals, highlighting the necessity for targeted support for adults with ADHD to mitigate the risks associated with the disorder.
- viraptor 2y agoThere's a video on this from Russell Barkley https://youtu.be/-byrKlZsUug https://youtu.be/-byrKlZsUug
- localghost3000 2y agoBarkley has been HUGE for me in understanding myself and how to manage my symptoms. Cannot recommend him enough.
- chuankl 2y agoThe study found reduction in life expectancy to be 6.78 years for males and 8.64 years for females. I wonder what could contribute to that difference.
- yapyap 2y agoSame, maybe giving birth.
- bhelkey 2y ago> The apparent reduction in life expectancy for adults with diagnosed ADHD relative to the general population was 6.78 years (95% CI: 4.50 to 9.11) for males, and 8.64 years (95% CI: 6.55 to 10.91) for females. It's not clear to me that there is a difference. It looks like the confidence intervals overlap.
- wizzwizz4 2y agoYou'd need to do a different analysis to decide whether there's a <5% chance of this data being generated by two identical distributions – but if we're not doing that, then we can't conclude that they're different.
- snailmailstare 2y agoThere is a difference in life expectancy in general so it would be remarkable if these are nonzero and the same. (I.e. exact same increase in risk of death at any pre-retirement age for both populations means higher change to life expectancy for women.)
- _yb2s 2y agoThis is just pure (somewhat informed) speculation. ADHD is diagnosed roughly twice as often in men than women, and when diagnosed in women it is much more likely to be of primarily inattentive rather than hyperactive type compared to men. Many suspect ADHD may not actually be rarer in women, but just that the inattentive type is harder to diagnose, and more often never diagnosed- mostly because it is less disruptive to others in school settings. I speculate that the women that are diagnosed are much more enriched for severe inattentive type ADHD, and I also speculate that inattentive type has a shorter life expectancy than hyperactive type. Just judging from myself, and other adults I know with ADHD: the hyperactive type ones tend to remain really physically active even into old age- unusually so, and the inattentive type tend to have a lot more depression, anxiety, and stress.
- swatcoder 2y agoThe ugly possibility, which this (good) study is too shallow to surface, is that a lifetime of pharmaceutical treatment might be at play. While amphetemines and adjacent drugs may provide critical relief of symptoms and may be experienced differently by sufferers than non-sufferers, they're still deeply unkind drugs to the body, and years or decades of daily use might have inconvenient consequences that show up in data like this, once someone starts looking. It's not directly implicated by the results, as no particular causitive factors are, but it's an unfortunately possible factor that the authors chose not to suggest in their discussion.
- kqr 2y agoYou may be underestimating the badness of untreated ADHD. As unkind as the drugs are, they are for many the kinder alternative to staying untreated.
- heyjamesknight 2y agoIn the short-term, yes. But over a lifetime, medication has massive health downsides, and fewer and fewer psychological upsides over time.
- swatcoder 2y agoNot at all. I was specifically careful not to do that. The discussion isn't about necessity or efficacy, it's about potential long-term consequences and whether this might be revealing some. People make what compromises they need to, but deserve to understand as much about those tradeoffs as can be identified.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hirvi74 2y agoI am not so sure. I mean everyone is different, but if you ask me, I have been on medication for a decade now. I am somehow worse in terms of productivity, social life, physical health, etc. than I was before starting medication. Of course, my anecdote proves nothing, but I would be surprised if I were alone.
- tcj_phx 2y agoI have a friend whose son was prescribed Adderall when he was 12-13 years old. She noticed the adverse effects right away, so she discontinued the drug, and took her son out of school for a year. He did much better getting homeschooled, and was able to return to the public school system after a year. Most of the "mental health" diagnoses have to do with metabolic problems. Emotional stress is one of the drains on the body's energy reserves. Stimulants like amphetamine 'shred' our mitochondria. It's okay for a short-term boost, but causes deterioration too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18211048 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18211048
- hirvi74 2y agoI follow the trail of links, but they lead to nowhere. Also the dosage of cocaine is typically orders of magnitude higher than therapeutic amphetamines/mph. Not saying that there is or is not some truth to this, but the jury is still out on this one.
- swayvil 2y agoOur culture demands that you just do the unpleasant activity and suck it up. Often. It's a lifestyle. School, work etc. Normies just say "ok" and get on with their life. ADHDers can't really do that. They can't eat it and get on with their life. They get stuck at the threshold. It's a choice between eternal stress or rejecting society. Both deliver a shortened lifespan.
- jrapdx3 2y agoAfter decades of providing treatment for ADHD adults I've come to the conclusion that ADHD is one of the most disabling mental health disorders. In some ways ADHD can be as devastating to a person's life as bipolar disorder or schizophrenia. While ADHD is highly prevalent among adults its manifestations are typically subtle. As a result, symptoms are attributed to incidental factors and the nature of the person's condition remains hidden. The article does a good job of addressing factors that contribute to ADHD-linked disability, and ways to deal with them. Clearly underdiagnosis sums up the primary issue. Solving a problem starts with recognizing the problem exists. However the article didn't discuss an important reason ADHD is overlooked, that is, widespread tremendous bias against recognizing the realities of adult ADHD. Reducing the burden of ADHD via social approaches faces a major challenge: how to inform or educate the public about realities of ADHD throughout the life cycle. While there has been marginal improvement over the last 25 years, prejudice or misunderstanding remain predominant. IMO the place to start is with the provider community. Healthcare practitioners need training to recognize ADHD among comorbidities and participate in its management. Once providers are actively advocating appropriate treatment for ADHD patients, family members, et. al., will likely follow clinicians' lead, become more amenable to helping ADHD individuals. Economic costs of ADHD are substantial. Reports give estimates that of $143 to $246 billion/year in the US alone.[0] If nothing else these figures illustrate the potential benefits of providing proper care to adults with ADHD. [0] https://www.jaacap.org/article/S0890-8567(12)00538-2/abstract https://www.jaacap.org/article/S0890-8567(12)00538-2/abstrac...
- klipklop 2y agoThese results sadden me when I know there is such a stigma about treating it. From the doctors to the pharmacist you get treated like crap trying to seek the most effective medication for this disorder, stimulants. There are so many legal hurdles and shortage BS you gotta go through as well.