3 ms·
While I found myself in furious agreement with the section titled "Jevons Paradox", I'm less convinced by this argument from the "Comparative Advantage" section
by simonw 2y ago
While I found myself in furious agreement with the section titled "Jevons Paradox", I'm less convinced by this argument from the "Comparative Advantage" section:
"While AI is powerful, it’s also computationally expensive. Unless someone decides to rewrite the laws of physics, there will always be a limit on how much artificial intelligence humanity can bring to bear."
The cost for running a prompt through the best-available model has collapsed over the past couple of years. GPT-4o is about 100x times less expensive than GPT-3 was, and massively more capable.
DeepSeek v3 and R1 are priced at a fraction of OpenAI's current prices for GPT-4 and o1 model and appear to be highly competitive with them.
I don't think we've hit the end of that trend yet - my intuition is that there's a lot more performance gains still to be had.
I don't think LLM systems will be competitive with everything that humans can do for a long time, if ever. But for the things they CAN do the cost is rapidly dropping to almost nothing.
- thfuran 2y agoA human brain runs on about 20 W, and I see no reason to believe that that is the absolute limit of efficiency. It's probably quite efficient as far as mammalian meat goes, but evolution can only optimize somewhat locally.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoIndeed, the laws of physics don't put any limits on artificial intelligence that don't also apply to natural intelligence. It's a strange place to look for a comparative advantage argument.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TheDudeMan 2y ago> I don't think LLM systems will be competitive with everything that humans can do for a long time It's looking like about 3 years. That will be another ~100x cost reduction, $100s more billions in infra, new training algorithms, new capabilities.