5 ms·
I've been trying to put this effect into words for a while, now I don't have to - this is really clearly stated: "AI tools create a significant productivity bo
by simonw 2y ago
I've been trying to put this effect into words for a while, now I don't have to - this is really clearly stated:
"AI tools create a significant productivity boost for developers. Different folks report different gains, but most people who try AI code generation recognize its ability to increase velocity. Many people think that means we’re going to need fewer developers, and our industry is going to slowly circle the drain.
This view is based on a misunderstanding of why people pay for software. A business creates software because they think that it will give them some sort of economic advantage. The investment needs to pay for itself with interest. There are many software projects that would help a business, but businesses aren’t going to do them because the return on investment doesn’t make sense.
When software development becomes more efficient, the ROI of any given software project increases, which unlocks more projects. [...] Cheaper software means people are going to want more of it. More software means more jobs for increasingly efficient software developers."
- nickfixit 2y agoThis is the way.
- jameslk 2y ago> More software means more jobs for increasingly efficient software developers This assumes software developers will be the ones needed to meet the demand. I think it will be more like technical product managers
- simonw 2y agoI think it will be the software developers that lean more into the kind of skills you see in technical product managers, or maybe vice-versa.
- nicoburns 2y ago> I think it will be more like technical product managers Even with traditional software development you'll be a much more effective software developer with good product management skills in a lot of niches (basically anything that's building a something user-facing)
- QuiDortDine 2y agoBut who will they blame when the solution inevitably fails to live up to the inherently contradictory demands of the different stakeholders?
- swatcoder 2y agoYou're splitting hairs over a title, but effectively talking about the same individuals. Whatever juice there is to squeeze out of generative AI coding, the people who will squeeze the most from it in the near future (10-20 years) are current and incoming software developers. Some may adopt different titles as the role matures, especially if there's a pay differential. This already happened with data engineering, database administration, etc So it's possible that the absolute number of people carrying the title approximately like "software developer" may be fewer in 10 years than it is today, although I personally find that very unlikely. But the people leading and maturing whatever alternate path comes up, for the next generation or so, will more often than not have a professional or academic background in software development regardless. The whole point of the article is that generative AI represents a lever that amplifies the capabilities of people who best know how to apply it. And for software development, that's ultimately going to be software developers.
- jameslk 2y ago> You're splitting hairs over a title, but effectively talking about the same individuals. I disagree. SWE skills are not the same as TPM skills. Those who like doing SWE work may not like TPM work nor be good at it. And my point is TPM skills will be what’s likely more needed. Therefore they may not be the same individuals, though many will need to adapt. Or go into woodworking or something
- baggy_trough 2y agoIt depends how good the AI becomes. There aren't a lot of horses employed for commercial transportation any more.
- pants2 2y agoIf we had some sort of enhancement that makes horses 500% faster and stronger, we probably would.
- recursive 2y agoDon't think so. They need medical care, food. And a 500% strength horse is still not as fast as a semi truck.
- loco5niner 2y agoMaybe that's why we measure the transportation vehicles they were replaced by in horsepower.
- captainkrtek 2y agoCars didn’t eliminate the need for someone to still operate transportation, going from horses to cars to ships just changed the vessel and if anything opened up more jobs as efficiency increased. We may have to adjust our roles as software engineers, but wholesale eliminating the role as a job family feels a bit difficult to picture. When software written by an LLM (which has been trained on human written code) ultimately fails or has some bug/edge case, I don’t think TPMs will have much fun debugging outages via their LLM..
- wruza 2y agoI think this effect will be even greater this time (last time being higher-level “slow” languages like python and js), because AI will allow for a new wave of developers who won’t care about the “right” code that much and will perceive it as a disposable resource rather than a form of art. This aligns well with many smaller businesses that are by nature temporary or very dynamic and have to actually fight with developers tendencies to create beautiful solutions after the ship has sailed.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoIME the software quality (including my own) is already on the edge of the unmaintainable slop threshold. I don't think it can slip much further without taking their hosts down too. Even Apple's software quality seems to be hit or miss lately.
- wruza 2y agoThat's really okay for the most non-clueless-user facing software. Inhouse worked like that since forever. Half-assed, barely working out of happy path, dangerous if you tick that box, but doing its job anyway. There's still a large margin to drop from, to make software that isn't "boxed/saas" but tailored to very specific needs. Many devs may have felt that moment, when some personal tool or a script worked just fine, but any attempt to turn it into "an app for a user" resulted in a complexity mess. Maybe the answer is not better software, but less software and more code doing the job. I don't think it's a bad thing, if it will help real people rather than the usual bigcorp/unicorn critters.
- gsf_emergency_2 2y agoAs it becomes easier and more profitable to accrue tech debt, more tech debt will be accrued.. See also: Jevon's paradox >[Tech companies], both historical and modern, typically expect that higher [revenues] will lower [tech debt], rather than expecting the Jevons paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- afavour 2y agoI feel like a lot of those problems are already addressed by no-code products. CRMs, project management tools, web site builders… those with relatively straightforward needs who aren’t that fussy about how it gets done are already served. I don’t doubt AI will help some people here but I’m not convinced it’ll be by an industry changing amount.
- captainkrtek 2y agoVery well put. The efficiency improvement I don’t think is the piece to debate, it’s pretty clear (like having auto complete for typing out text messages). I have yet to feel threatened (job security wise) by LLMs.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoDoesn't this assume there will always be significant business needs that can be met by software, but are not yet? Or at least not as efficiently as they could be? I imagine there is an upper bound on how much of the world can be eaten by software, and the trend seems to be getting closer to that point. Unless there are some massive breakthroughs in robotics or cybernetics which open more of the physical world to software. There's also a point where incremental software improvement requires bulldozing, paving, or burning so much nature that we'll be worse off in the end. Watching billionaires squabble about who gets the new AI data centers makes me wonder if we haven't crossed over that point a few funding rounds ago.
- throwup238 2y agoI don't think we’re anywhere near the upper bound yet and IMO the prevalence of SaaS software that could be better done in house if resources permitted demonstrates that. The future will be a lot more bespoke. Like Simon’s quote above says, software is a competitive advantage so when one company develops software that makes them more efficient or grows revenue, competitors have to follow suit or get left behind. It’s an economic arms race. That’s why the dreaded outsourcing wave of the 2000s never materialized: companies ended up hiring a bunch more software engineers in the US and outsourced a bunch of other engineering to India and other countries. The interesting question is how this will interact with current interest rates and the end of ZIRP.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoSoftware is being commoditized by SAAS. Generally that means it's table stakes, not necessarily a competitive advantage.
- throwup238 2y ago90% of the small SaaS products I’ve seen used within business introduced tons of pain points and inefficiencies, ranging from constant bugs to manual data entry moving it from one SaaS to the next. Once you throw in all the per-seat licensing, their value proposition isn’t always that great. I think a product like GithubNext Spark [1] that can handle deployment, SSO, databases, uploads, etc with an LLM fine tuned on the managed runtime API will be a very productive tool. It already works surprisingly well in my experience although it’s an mvp and they havent fleshed out database stuff yet. Kind of like a higher code Retool that can still be used by non-programmers. [1] https://githubnext.com/projects/github-spark/ https://githubnext.com/projects/github-spark/
- etrautmann 2y agoThis is essentially Jevon's paradox [1] applied to software development. As it becomes easier and more efficient to create software, more if it will be consumed/demanded/created. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox edit: whoops that's the point of the original article
- gsf_emergency_2 2y agoI'd go further than TFA and say it with tech debt.. As it becomes easier and more profitable to accrue tech debt, more tech debt will be accrued
- paradite 2y agoThe counter argument is that if business can always find more projects that brings in revenue, they would not be laying off people, or shutting down. The reality is business can't really just scale their revenue by adding more profitable or positive ROI projects. There are not enough of them to go around. Eventually you hit a plateau in terms of growth and the R&D / engineering productivity can't translate into revenue anymore.
- emseetech 2y agoNot all businesses can scale their revenue, but the businesses that can eat the ones that can't.
- Retric 2y agoWhich then kills off even more high paying jobs. Machines shifted things away from manual labor, but AI sifts it from intellectual labor.
- emseetech 2y agoI don't follow. If AI can make high paying workers more efficient, then the companies that leverage that efficiency to grow will outpace the companies that can't. There's no net loss of high paying workers.
- rightbyte 2y agoI think there are greatly diminishing returns. 10x of me would probably not give even 2x the output. So instead it might make sense to employ 0.2x of me to get 2x the output.
- Retric 2y agoIf tractors can make farm labor more efficient why would that reduce the number of farmers? The argument boils down to diminishing returns. Honda can’t scale to producing 10,000x as many cars. What they can do is sell the cars they are already producing for less, so if some aspect of their business becomes more efficient they don’t just do more of it endlessly, they quickly cross a threshold and then spend less on it.
- nine_zeros 2y ago> A business creates software because they think that it will give them some sort of economic advantage. The investment needs to pay for itself with interest. There are many software projects that would help a business, but businesses aren’t going to do them because the return on investment doesn’t make sense All this is fine but then they take this to the extreme by laying off developers when there are no more ROI projects. Then bit rot sets in, systems degrade, customers abandon ship, and suddenly there are no engineers to help the business. And no, hiring contractors last minute doesn't cut it because they don't know what pile of gunk has been running and what caused the degradation. Software requires maintenance, much like a bespoke car. For every bespoke car you produce, you need to continuously service it with bespoke skills else it will stop working - and cause your revenue to drop.
- deepGem 2y agoEssentially software is going to become like email. Dirt cheap to produce. The folks who will get employed and continue to make money like crazy will be the email automation company equivalents. Perhaps a bad analogy but the jobs are not gonna go away anywhere. Engineers will still continue to work like crazy and produce 100x the output. The pay could still remain the same because the profit margins on these newly developed software is gonna be so much better. That being said, I think there will be a cycle of adjustment - may be 2-5 years for this reality to set in. So in that interim there may be joblosses.
- jamil7 2y agoI just witnessed an example of more or less this at a startup I’ve been contracting at. The engineering team on the core product is tiny with no slack for extra projects. One non-technical founder and a few other non-technical people build a prototype piece of software using AI and low code tools for facilitating another revenue stream. They started using it with a few customers and raised more money around it. The money they raised is going directly into expanding the engineering team to work on both products.
- streptomycin 2y agoAI has been drastically improving for the past couple decades, and if that continues then AI is obviously going to kill the software industry and many other industries. Sure, maybe apparent exponential growth tails off into an S curve at some point, as often happens. But this blog post seems to assume that is guaranteed to happen, which is a big leap of faith, and also makes this not a very interesting blog post. Because it's basically just, "Well if I assume the best arguments against my position are wrong, then I don't even need to address them, and I can instead focus on lesser arguments that are easier for me to discuss".
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y ago"This view is based on a misunderstanding of why people pay for software." Do many people pay for software. Other than some small, one-time donations to shareware back in the day and to more recent project that operates outside of "app stores" I pay zero dollars for software. It is a negligible expense. No doubt businesses still pay for software. Having friends in software sales, I know it does not necessarily sell itself. It takes (non-developer) work. Whether businesses truly need to purchase these licenses is an open question. Most companies I know want to reducedd their software bill, some believe they are being overcharged.
- Nevermark 2y ago> AI tools create a significant productivity boost for developers. I think the first step betrays the weakness in this reasoning. We already know that more powerful software tools do not make all developers more efficient. So the reverse can be true. For software jobs to remain, not only must the tools keep making human developers more efficient, but the human developers need to continue making the automated developers more efficient. Both directions must be accounted for. Question: what is something our best human developers can do, that will always enhance the artificial developers results? Regardless of how far automated developers scale in quantity, quality, speed, economy and complexity of work? It is the same question for any new automation vs. previous process. You need to identify that, for anything past your first reasoning step to have a chance. But if you can definitively answer it, I don’t think you need any more steps.