4 ms·
Interesting, but I don't really by his it arguments. All that is required to learn in our industry is a sub $1000 pc (and on a budget, sub 500) or a $1500 mac.
by tomjen3 14y ago
Interesting, but I don't really by his it arguments. All that is required to learn in our industry is a sub $1000 pc (and on a budget, sub 500) or a $1500 mac.
Yet somehow we end up with people who cannot solve fizzbuzz.
That seems like a talent shortage to me.
- rogerbinns 14y ago> Yet somehow we end up with people who cannot solve fizzbuzz. Remember that those people (most likely) won't get hired. But they will keep fiddling with their resume/CV until they get called. So they'll keep showing up at interviews and be over represented. The talented folk will interview just a few times years apart so they are far less likely to be seen by interviewers. If you do end up interviewing someone who can't solve fizzbuzz then it is a very good indicator that the hiring process is broken. The usual solution is to keep adding extra requirements in an attempt to weed them out, but that also weeds out the talented people too since they are less likely to have the exact required set of acronyms. Hiring is hard - simple solutions like adding acronyms doesn't make it easier.
- glimcat 14y agoI have a hammer, but I have no clue how to get from driving nails into boards to building houses. I don't know what the road map should even look like, or what skills I would end up needing, or how to evaluate them along the way. Thus why software engineers often get a degree, buy books, pay for classes, and so forth. The self-education threshold tends to be even higher at the beginning. Most people have no clue how to get from owning a computer to Hello World, to FizzBuzz, to simple scripts, to a well-designed and documented program. The real failure is when people turn to university (etc.) to learn a skill, get a "QC Okay" stamp at the end - and then still can't FizzBuzz. You need shorter feedback cycles which focus on finding and correcting errors, not monolithic course grades and monolithic degree pass/fail stickers. You wouldn't expect it to end well if you tried code a major project that way. Why would it work any better as an education plan?
- netcan 14y agoMy instinct is to say that self education is hard & we still aren't good enough at it yet. On second thought I want to say that education is hard & our expectations are very high. One of my best friends has a 9th grade formal education, has done serious jail time and has still managed to succeed as a "professional" in the tech sector. I regularly listen to or read non degree people I would consider intellectuals. These aren't just brilliant edge cases anymore. Most of us know these people because there are lots of them. I have learned so much online. More than at work. More than at Uni. (Hard to compare it to school: learning to read & add was important). We are doing pretty well on self education. Lets pat ourselves on the back (or thank those people who made it happen) every so often. I think the reason my first instinct is to say we aren't good at self education yet is that we can see so much potential. There really is no reason someone couldn't get to bachelor level chemistry, biology, civil engineering or economics on their own. There are all sorts of problems that just go away and let everything go much quicker when you're self educating. People might be able to learn 4 year equivalents in 6 months.Who knows. Universities solve all sorts of problems in seemingly inefficient ways that we might see being superseded soon. A lot of the things they solve though are genuinely hard problems. Most people in an Econ2003 are not fascinated with Theories & Models of Supply Elasticity in A Recession. They are sort of interested in economics and have a general feeling that its something they should be studying. They might even be reading Why Keynes Matters. But, in a lot of cases they're cranky they have to take this stupid class in the first place. I'm not sure how that problem gets solved outside of a University. Maybe it doesn't need to get solved. Maybe the future is a word where students don't need to get dragged through material they don't want to learn. If it is, I'm excited. 35 year olds are looking back and thinking: "If I was 19 today I would do it like this..." But if you were 19, you'd be a different person, a 19 year old. You'd probably think like one. There are better tools than econ2003 out there a lot of the time. But they don't work for everyone all of the time. I think we have to accept some clunky systems that sort of get the job done.
- brlewis 14y agoI have a hammer, but I have no clue how to get from driving nails into boards to building houses. I don't know what the road map should even look like, or what skills I would end up needing, or how to evaluate them along the way. If you could tear into existing houses to look at how they're built, and if building practice houses were cheap and easy, building houses would be more like building programs. The feedback cycle is great with DrRacket. And I don't think that's the only beginning-programmer learning environment.
- 7952 14y agoWhy not just hire someone you like and expect them to learn on the job? You probably do this anyway, but wrap it up in complex requirements.
- tikhonj 14y agoIt's fine to have new hires learn the particulars of your technology and domain on the job. It's not fine to have them learn basic computer science on the job. Somebody who can't write fizzbuzz clearly does not have the fundamental CS background needed to do any sort of nontrivial programming. It takes most people years to get this background, usually in a university setting. You can't replace that with on-the-job training!
- 7952 14y agoSo it should be easy to find people to hire in a Country with such a world class higher education sector. Ignoring the financial implications; would you be adverse to teaching people CS on the job? It isn't inconceivable that the quality of the end result would be much higher.
- phaus 14y agoI'm a CIS student and a telecommunications professional, with aspirations of eventually being a professional programmer, so if this is a dumb question, please forgive me. If there are people who can't solve fizzbuzz that are getting programming jobs, what do they do at work? I can solve fizzbuzz easily, but I haven't ever built an application that I would consider useful. I've solved puzzles like fizzbuzz and completed lots of programming assignments (mostly involving stuff at the command line) and I feel like I know nothing when it comes to actually building something significant. I feel like it would be impossible for me to get an entry-level programming job right now, but from the sound of it, maybe not.
- greyfade 14y ago> If there are people who can't solve fizzbuzz that are getting programming jobs, what do they do at work? http://thedailywtf.com/Articles/The_Brillant_Paula_Bean.aspx http://thedailywtf.com/Articles/The_Brillant_Paula_Bean.aspx This is just one example, but it's a very accurate description of all of those people who can't solve fizzbuzz and yet still manage to get jobs.
- vorg 14y ago> If there are people who can't solve fizzbuzz that are getting programming jobs, what do they do at work? The good news: They cause the programming messes which you'll eventually get hired to clean up, while they're off somewhere else making another mess for you. > I can solve fizzbuzz easily, but I haven't ever built an application that I would consider useful. The bad news: All you're ever do is clean up those frauds' messes. Anyone can build a system with 100k lines of Java code (incl comments). But only people like you can come along after it's up and running and make it work, so that's all you're ever be doing. Unfortunately, the employers will expect you to carry a cellphone around and solve those problems at 3:00am. It's cheaper to pay you 10% extra for wake-up calls than take your time away from other maintenance clean-ups in the daytime.
- EvilTerran 14y ago"(incl comments)" Optimist.
- overgryphon 14y agoAnd all you need to be an olympic runner is a pair of shoes and some clothes. The tech industry, like many other industries, uses simple filters (such as work experience or a college degree) to pick the number of people they have time to interview. The skills required to be a talented programmer, and the skills required to get and keep a job (or earn a living programming without a job) are not equivalent.
- ommunist 14y agoRight you are, and the metaphore is brilliant. You cannot demand from a programmer to be a nice speaking salesman, when you do, you are ending with a half baked software well sold.
- Spooky23 14y agoI think you're missing the point. The problem is that when you go to hire someone, you get swamped by thousands of applications from candidates who may or may not have any qualification. So what happens is you apply filters to screen out people. One method is to filter out colleges, GPA, lack of work experience, underqualification, overqualification, or anything that isn't legally protected to get to a workable candidate pool. Another method is to only hire people you know, or people you know people you know. Still another is to build barriers (Civil Service exams, grammar tests, math test). The problem is that if you are an unfortunate soul who doesn't get through the filter (ie. 2.9 GPA, state school, etc), doesn't operate in you social circle, or doesn't know about or cannot get through the barriers, you're screwed.
- will_work4tears 14y agoSadly, both the GPA and the school are so me. I actually ended up with a 3.0 but same deal. Which is why I am making 17/hr and no benefits (no health/dental, no paid time off at all). Also probably why I spent a year looking for any job at all before I landed this one.
- Spooky23 14y agoDon't give up. For a variety of reasons, I ended up getting out with a 2.6. I was able to parlay one of my college jobs into a "real" job, and was able to go from there. Now I've "made it" from some people's POV. Some of the companies who wouldn't give me the time of day a decade ago would hire me in a minute now.
- will_work4tears 14y agoThanks for the words of encouragement. Unfortunately I feel my career is dead. I too feel that my lower GPA was due to a variety of reasons (no financial aid, working 40 hours a week, depression, health problems, etc), but at this juncture of life it is another set of seemingly insurmountable odds. Low pay, high debt, crappy job, new baby, demanding wife... Well, not to be self critical, but I don't see myself ever being a rockstar. I'll be lucky if I ever hit 60k+... Sadly even that isn't much here in the Seattle area. no scholarships anyway, plenty of student loans. Too many. I was 26 when I started college, and while my parents always told me they'd help if I went to college, all I got was co-signed loans. I'm 35 now.