4 ms·
This appears to be a vehicle interface designed by someone who doesn't actually drive much. When driving, you often care about acceleration as much as speed.
by rdl 14y ago
This appears to be a vehicle interface designed by someone who doesn't actually drive much.
When driving, you often care about acceleration as much as speed. Digital displays are horrible for indicating first and second derivatives; analog dials are great for first and adequate for second.
The best UI on a car I've seen (as far as actually driving it) is the Audi -- a Driver Information Display directly in line with the driver (showing next turn), and a center area. There's a reason for going for all-red indicators -- night vision. In rural areas, you often dial down the brightness of all controls to preserve night vision in case an animal or debris is in the road. If you're on I-5 driving from Seattle to SF, there aren't a whole lot of turns, so your nav system is really secondary (if on at all), and there's no reason for it to be in your line of sight.
For great designed interiors for drivers, I'd look to Audi, Porsche, and go from there.
When driving, I'd consider audio nav information to be primary, followed by simple next turn information, followed by a (north-centric, vs. vehicle bearing) map. 95% of the time the only nav info I need is "left turn in 200 meters, 100 meters, 50 meters, now", since I'm focused on other cars rather than my display. It's only with complex intersections (roundabouts, 5-6 way intersections where grids overlap, etc.) that I need to see the display.
Audio is inherently more minimal than visual information, so a car really needs to get it right. Simple things like the order of words in notifications, how frequently they happen, tones vs. words, etc. make a huge difference, and require design vs. advanced graphics to get right.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rdl 14y agoIt appears to take the place of all the indicators. I think Toyota is trying to be cheap/global and put all displays in the center, with just a steering wheel and brake/accelerator on left or right hand side. That alone would be a no-buy for me, regardless of the display technology.
- obilgic 14y agoyeap, I'm sorry. For me that is the worst part. I HATE digital speedometers. Because the thing is, I never look directly to the speedometer to read the speed, I look at the road but I can see the angle(and the acceleration) of the stick of the speedometer and thats how I feel how fast I am.
- rdl 14y agoI think they are trying to drive hybrid buyers who don't hate cars to the Lexus ES300h.
- digitalengineer 14y agoAgreed. I've had cars with digital and analog speedometers. I hate having to read the numbers. It takes more time that a glance at the angle. But hey, the old Prius interface really, really sucked. It showed an stupid animation of 'electricity running though pats of the car' or something. This took your eye of the road the entire time because of the motion.
- wsh 14y agoIt also appears to be a vehicle interface designed by someone who hasn't read Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 101, with its specific, prescriptive requirements, including the "confusing icons of traditional cars" that the designer intends to eliminate, an "MPH" or "km/h" label for the speedometer, and as noted in another comment, a display of the transmission shift position sequence. The idea of a "built-in digital manual that guides you through maintenance and emergency situations" is also nothing new; it sounds like the ECAM system found on Airbus airplanes for many years and would be equally inapplicable to most automotive emergencies. If there is a serious problem with a car, the driver should pull over and stop, after which there is plenty of time to consult the index in a printed manual, which doesn't depend on the electrical system and can be used outside or away from the vehicle, if needed.
- rdl 14y agoWhat I would like is nav integrated with vehicle fault reporting more closely (not done since nav is usually an option). If the serious check engine happens (flashing vs solid), some indication of where I could get service would be nice, and maybe for some faults (coil pack on i4), a 35mph or slower route to destination. Being able to inform the driver about "absolutely non drive able fault, must call for flatbed recovery vehicle" vs "slow speed for 3 miles is ok" would be nice. Cars really should have novice (rental) and expert (personal car) mode. I think people spend enough time in their own personal cars to get to know most systems, but if I am renting or borrowing a car, a standard UI would be nice -- even stupid things like finding parking brake, 4 way flashers, headlight controls, etc are sometimes a pain.
- camtarn 14y agoAck... Fat fingered the downvote button, sorry :( I really do like the idea of a beginner mode for a car: getting into your rental car, and having it quickly run through 'wipers are here, they work like this; parking brake is electronic and turns off automatically' would be awesome. Also, even for people who use their cars regularly, they might still use a Siri-like interface where you could ask 'It's snowy, what should I do?', 'I've got a trailer connected, how do I adjust my headlight beam height?' or 'Where are my fog lights again?'
- bonzoesc 14y agoAs far as navigation, I really like how it's done on the HUD in the Camaro and Corvette. Normally, the HUD shows digital speed, analog tach, current gear on autos, and a couple status things like turn signals and headlights. When a navigation command is coming up (turn right on US-1), it shows a little progress bar indicating when you have to turn, an arrow pointing the direction to turn, the name of the road, and the speed in smaller text: http://www.flickr.com/photos/bonzoesc/7176906639/sizes/h/in/photostream/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/bonzoesc/7176906639/sizes/h/in/... When the song changes on satellite radio, or you tune the radio, it shows the artist and song title temporarily. As far as getting a secondary read on acceleration vs. speed, I'm spoiled by driving manual, and I generally know how I'm accelerating based on pedal position, current gear, and engine note. The only car that's really scared me with a lack of speed feel was the Nissan Murano, with a continuous transmission and no changing engine note from about 30mph to 90mph.
- DannoHung 14y agoDude, you must drive only in long, lonely stretches of road. In any urban driving condition, looking at your instruments long enough to gauge your acceleration by them is a good way to crash into something. Knowing to the 50 meter increment where the next turn is isn't so helpful when there are multiple branching exits right next to each other. Being able to visually see at a glance where a turn is in relation to where your car presently is makes shit so much easier. No matter how good the audio is, it's not going to be easier than just seeing where you're supposed to go.
- rdl 14y agoIn the city, I don't really check my speed at all (or any instruments, really). The only time in an urban area I check is when I'm in a school zone or when I see a cop; otherwise no one cares if you're going 30 or 35 in a 25. It's intuitively obvious if you're going much faster or slower than that. My car tells me "next left" or "second left" (and "onto streetname") in addition to distance. That seems ideal for most situations.
- Mythbusters 14y agoI think its a personal choice whether you prefer a lot of information there or little. I liked the design for it "metro" look.
- arethuza 14y agoI have an audio warning set up to tell me if I go over 30 mph - works pretty well.
- TeMPOraL 14y ago> followed by a (north-centric, vs. vehicle bearing) map. Isn't north-centric map confusing for you in such situations? I know it is for me. Vehicle bearing maps take away one quite expensive mental step of translating and rotating your world to fit the map (or vice versa) in your imagination. I personally always prefer maps oriented in the direction where I'm heading, to the point that I always rotate paper maps in my hand so that it is constantly aligned with the direction I'm looking at. I wonder if anyone else does the same?
- freehunter 14y agoI sit there rotating my phone sometimes to point in the direction I am facing. Last thing I need to worry about while lost is "is that turn really a right turn like it shows, or left because I'm headed south?"
- rdl 14y agoIt might be easier to know which direction your turn is, but using bearing vs. north=up maps makes it a lot harder to learn where things are around you in general. I keep my "next turn" vehicle-relative, but the map display itself north=up, which seems to be the best of both worlds.
- FireBeyond 14y agoI liked the existing SatNav in my Prius for this. I could split the display, the left hand side showing the 3D turn-by-turn navigation view, and the right showing a top down, north-oriented view. On longer trips, I'd also zoom the right map all the way out to show start and end, so I could visualize the entire trip.
- amalag 14y agoI hate it when my GPS does it, i can't turn it off and it completely disorients me to the point where I can't tell where things are properly. I always keep my map north facing and in my mind always have east as right, I am not a great navigator, maybe maps oriented in my direction is the way to go, but it doesn't make sense to me. I do sort of have to turn to tell if it's a right or left coming up, but at least I know where i am in relation to other objects in the map.
- steve19 14y agoTo be fair, most car interfaces are so horrible that they must have been designed by people who don't drive ;)
- jamesaguilar 14y agoI don't really understand why you'd need an instrument to show acceleration. Can't you feel it? The point of the speedometer is that it's something much less easy to feel.
- lloeki 14y agoThe "best" (as far as I'm concerned) UI I've ever encountered is in my current car ([0] sports with satnav, [1] classic without satnav). It is also, as far as many other people are concerned, one of the most startling ones. - information is divided in three distinct physical and logical areas: 1. primary, topmost 2. secondary, behind the steering wheel and 3. tertiary, centermost. The entire dashboard is designed to reduce information overload and let the driver focus on actual driving. - the primary area sits topmost, right in front of the driver. It holds the most critical pieces of information: frontmost and unmistakable, the speed, in huge, high contrast lettering. On the left, the rev alert: six orange leds, off most of the time, light up as you get close to the limiter. On the right, the display differs according to the version: Type-R gets a logo and a red i-VTEC led when the aggressive valve timing engages, while other models get a symmetric indicator similar to the rev alert, showing the ECU logic regarding fuel injection, which gets presented as 'Eco' leds: the less fuel is in injected regarding the map, the more leds light up. Big bright green turning indicator arrows are present in this area too, one on each side of the speedo. This display stands up and far. it can bee seen by far-sighted people (presbyopia) without glasses. Like a HUD, I can actually read it while looking at the road in front of me. When looking far away ahead, the information is shown in such a way that I can, at the bottom edge of my vision, notice changes in display and evaluate revs/eco. Leds "progress bars" light up two at a time, making changes visible even without focusing. - the secondary area gives richer information, but sits closer to the driver. The area is actually three-dimensional: the centermost display sits on a black 'tower' and the needles themselves are noticeably above the digits. The lightning makes the tower invisible, and the needles pop out even more which reinforce the sense of depth. The minimum of information is shown (revs, fuel, engine temperature), and more as required (lights state, other system warnings and alerts). The LCD on the center 'tower' can display select information at will. When an event is triggered (low fuel, oil, door opened...) this display turns orange, with both a pictogram and text explaining the condition. When any alert pops up, there is an audible chime, along with a bright orange (i) notification on the right side of the primary area. This notification stays up until you manually clear it. - tertiary gives accessory information: time, audio, A/C, satnav (if applicable). The dashboard being drawn along an arc, the display faces the driver (really visible in [2]). The recess is made such that the passenger can see this display, but the primary consumer of the information is the driver. - from the steering wheel and the gear stick, every important button is within fingers reach. Every secondary button requires minimal movement. Thanks to the enveloping arc shape , the car fits the driver, like a hand in a glove. From outside, the car is (love it or hate it) unlike any other, and this is enough to warrant curiosity from both relatives and random people. When looking at the cabin, the words "Star Trek" have yet to fail to be mentioned. It's an entirely fresh design that strike many as odd and gimmicky, but that I find extremely convenient and well thought, with every detail having a reason to be. Compare and contrast with the proposed design, which like many designs before, crams all levels of information in a single display area (two screens side by side is a single area), facing the area between the two front seats (I'm sure the dog in the boot loves to see where he's going and at which speed). Display in the center is an atrocity. People have a tendency to go where they look, and if they look at the center display, their line of sight is outside the road, and uselessly increases the left blind spot. Making the farside display touch make sit even worse. Not only will it bring in the gorilla arm effect, the body of the driver is required to move far from its proper driver position. [0] http://wowallpaper.com/wallpapers/civic-type-r-dashboard-1280x1024.jpg http://wowallpaper.com/wallpapers/civic-type-r-dashboard-128... [1] http://www.km77.com/marcas/honda/2006/civic/gama/gra/35.jpg http://www.km77.com/marcas/honda/2006/civic/gama/gra/35.jpg [2] http://www.eurodb.com.au/New-used-car-review/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/honda-civic-type-R1-300x229.jpg http://www.eurodb.com.au/New-used-car-review/wp-content/uplo...
- samstave 14y agoExactly. My Audi A3 was the best car ive ever owned. I did have my navigation always on, but because I like to have a constant ETA. I would drive from SF to Tahoe/Reno every weekend and I looked forward to the drive because it was so pleasurable, especially when I got up into the mountains. Driving 120 in that car felt like going 60, with faster visuals. Audis are, IMO, the best cars made (that are still in an affordable range)