3 ms·
Cases have made it to the Supreme Court --- recently! --- and it held up just fine. This is another message board fixation. I'm sure it's abused all over the pl
by tptacek 2y ago
Cases have made it to the Supreme Court --- recently! --- and it held up just fine. This is another message board fixation. I'm sure it's abused all over the place. It wasn't in this case.
- bb88 2y agoIf the cases start with: "US v $200,000", that probably needs to go away. I doubt I would be able to get away with "bb88 v $2B". It should so belong to me.
- cryptonector 2y agohttps://www.law.upenn.edu/live/news/16740-civil-forfeiture-decision-may-present-hope-as-well https://www.law.upenn.edu/live/news/16740-civil-forfeiture-d... ? That's not very conclusive.
- tptacek 2y agoWhat part of this makes you thing CAF is on shaky constitutional ground? This is a CAF case with reach-y fact patterns for the government and they won it handily. We didn't even get close to the question of whether CAF is itself constitutional; the court simply presumed it.
- cryptonector 2y agoThis was about the timing of a hearing about forfeiture, not about whether forfeiture is ok. Though I've not read this case yet, but now that I'm aware of it I'm keen to read it. I'll comment again later.