3 ms·
For me being a retired psychotherapist AI can and will never replace or be as good as a human therapist. Ai maybe able to use some sort of formulaic structured
by reify 2y ago
For me being a retired psychotherapist AI can and will never replace or be as good as a human therapist.
Ai maybe able to use some sort of formulaic structured therapy like CBT but will never be able to manage human intuition, projections, projective identification, phenomenology, transference, counter-transference and the all important interpersonal, intrapersonal relationship and quality free association and dream analysis as per Freud and Lacan.
You know that same CBT that claims to cure depression, eating disorders and others after 12 sessions. Yet all the research I have read comes to the same conclusion, that the symptoms return not long after a course of CBT finishes.
A CBT ptractitioner trains the client to be his own therapist by teaching him or her CBT, the ABC's of CBT so that the client can use that to help themselves. But people with depression for instance to do not have the capacity to continually monitor themselves when they are depressed every day. This is not therapy,
For me and most of my colleagues CBT is a brainwashing technique and to be honest CBT has never been allowed in any of the charitable organisations I worked for for many years.
CBT is cheap. CBT practitioners do not have to engage in any personal therapy, It takes just a year to train as a CBT therapist wheras I and my colleagues have spent the absolute minimum of 6 years training to Masters level and then a lifetime of continued professional development.
Here in the UK you can get a good couples therapist for £80 for the 50 minutes and you wont be filling any forms every week. nor risking the eventul and pretty much guaranteed intrusive hack and all your personal private sessions spread all over the internet
How does AI guarantee confidentiality? it cannot, Without confidentiality there is no trust which is fundamental to all good therapy
- yardstick17 2y agoThanks for your thoughts and for taking the time to write all the points you mentioned. I will try to address them one by one: - You mentioned ALL research says symptoms return after 12 sessions + CBT being not effective: I will quote: "..on average, 40 months after the end of therapy. A long-term benefit was also seen in terms of remission of symptoms. In view of the fact that, at baseline, most CoBalT participants had severe and chronic depression, with physical or psychological comorbidity, or both, these results are noteworthy and have clear implications for clinical practice." from https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpsy/article/PIIS2215-0366(15)00495-2/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpsy/article/PIIS2215-0... - Re: £80 for 50 minutes in person 1 session Vs £80 for month-long support - We don't aim to replace human therapists or the profound human elements you mentioned—intuition, transference, and interpersonal relationships. Instead, we aim to augment and complement. Ideally, we would like to place ourselves as proving support between sessions. - We're not saying this approach is for everyone or every situation, but we do believe it can help where traditional therapy might be inaccessible. - For confidentiality, we have BAA / HIPPA compliant I’d be happy to discuss further if you have additional thoughts.