3 ms·
most people are embarrassed about the truth. So they will over report vegetables while not mentioning how much alcohol or tobacco they had (or illegal drugs whi
by bluGill 2y ago
most people are embarrassed about the truth. So they will over report vegetables while not mentioning how much alcohol or tobacco they had (or illegal drugs which the study probably legally must report to the police). Or a self proclaimed vegetarian will not report meat they ate despite their claim. fat people will report they skipped desert.
- graemep 2y agoI came across a comment as a humorous rule of thumb for this. 1. If you ask someone who much the drink double the answer 2. If you ask them how much the smoke, multiply the answer by five 3. If you ask them how often they have sex, divide the answer by 10.
- BoxFour 2y agoWhy would that be a problem for reporting relative results if the entire population is doing that? If everyone is under-reporting their alcohol consumption, that seems fine. The absolute numbers will be way off, the relative numbers to their peers won't.
- bluGill 2y agoStatistics can do a lot to find data from noise like this, but it is still noise. The biggest issue is nobody knows what variables are important, which are correlated, and so on. Edit: there is another issue I forget until now: time. Statistically I have several more decades of life left. So even if you get accurate results of my meals yesterday, you need to report when I died, and you probably won't have the meals for the rest of my life. Did some meal I at when I was 10 have a big effect on my life? For that matter if I know you are tracking just one day's meals I will probably eat what I think is better and that doesn't tell you anything about what I eat the rest of the time. It is easy to track people who have had a heart attack - they are likely to die of another heart attack in a few years so the study times are short. However does having had a heart attack mean either genetic difference such that your results only apply to a subset of the population, or perhaps some other factor of having had a heart attack.