Since each person has their own taste, I suggest to browse IFDB's recommendations (https://ifdb.org/search?searchbar=played%3Ano+willplay%3Ano+wontplay%3Ano+rev

Since each person has their own taste, I suggest to browse IFDB's recommendations (https://ifdb.org/search?searchbar=played%3Ano+willplay%3Ano+wontplay%3Ano+reviewed%3Ano+rated%3Ano https://ifdb.org/search?searchbar=played%3Ano+willplay%3Ano+...) and choosing something that piques your interest. Personally I found Violet excellent as first-time adventure. The puzzles are hard but fair, and no mapping is involved.