4 ms·
"This is very, very far away from the majority view of modern psychology (which has dismissed the vast majority of Freudian thought), but I still hear it repeat
by Alex3917 14y ago
"This is very, very far away from the majority view of modern psychology (which has dismissed the vast majority of Freudian thought), but I still hear it repeated all the damn time."
Actually a lot of therapists still use personal mythology construction as a therapy tool, which is very similar to Freud's idea of directing anger outward in the sense that both creating a new identity for the person or strengthening their existing one. It's basically the same idea but expanded a bit and better explained. If you search for personal mythology on Amazon there are all sorts of books about this.
- gcb 14y agoI may be wrong, but personal myth is not a Freudian concept and it used to beoften associated with dream analysis... a long time ago.
- eavc 14y agoHe wasn't talking about what "a lot of therapists" do but rather the modern understanding of depression and its causes and solutions.
- Alex3917 14y agoWhat a lot of therapists do is by definition part of the modern understanding of depression and its causes and solutions. Depression is a biopsychosocial disease, so to have any real understanding of it you need to look at it through a variety of lenses and disciplines.
- light3 14y agoI assumed "view of modern psychology" as used by parent meaning some generally accepted views of academics backed up by current experimental research results. Which as the parent states is in conflict with current practices of therapists.
- eavc 14y agoExactly. But to be clear, there are, of course, many, many therapists that practice scientifically supported approaches to treating depression.
- eavc 14y ago"What a lot of therapists do is by definition part of the modern understanding of depression and its causes and solutions." No. What psychologists have determined constitutes the modern understanding. Therapists ought to work in a way that reflects that knowledge. Most do.