4 ms·
You still need to fix 2 other problems with software patents, otherwise it won't work. 1) shorten the software patent period to 3 years 2) dramatically decrea
by mtgx 14y ago
You still need to fix 2 other problems with software patents, otherwise it won't work.
1) shorten the software patent period to 3 years
2) dramatically decrease the vagueness and triviality of software patents somehow
Otherwise, you end up like in the mobile industry, where something like 250,000 patents exist in any given phone, and I assume most of those are not enforced, but if they were regulated, and manufacturers were forced to pay for them by default, I could easily imagine patents costing more than the product itself. This is why you need to drastically reduce the number of patents as well.
- jballanc 14y agoWell, I think my system would actively incentivize the reduction in the number of patents. Fewer patents would lead to higher licensing fee per patent, so you'd have an incentive to only patent the stuff that really matters (since every patent has a base cost to acquire). Also, I'm not proposing that there be some sort of strict requirement that you must pay the licensing fee for all the patents you use. Obviously cross-licensing agreements and such would still be valid. What I'm trying to cure is the system the patent trolls currently operate under: Patent Troll - "I'm going to sue you for $1 mil for infringing my patent unless you pay my licensing fee." Startup Founder - "How much is your licensing fee?" Patent Troll - "Only $10,000" You have to keep in mind that most patent lawsuits never see judgement. They exist only to coerce alleged infringers into paying licensing fees. The problem is that the licensing fees are arbitrary. They are not reflective of any sort of market, but rather reflective of infringement-penalty * chance-of-judgment-against (well, I guess this is a perverse sort of market: a market of jury pools).
- einhverfr 14y agoIndeed. Also may I say "thank you" to the Supreme Court for their wonderful decision in Caraco v. Novo Nordisk, which more or less ends the usefulness of method-of-use patents for drugs.
- loceng 14y agoI thought 3-5 years would be a good enough length of time (leaning more to 5 years for physical applications). Though companies may still then hoard technology that isn't ready for the market yet, which would slow innovation. Longer patent times are perfectly fine if fees are regulated.
- jandrewrogers 14y agoIt often takes more than 3 years to commercialize fundamentally new computer algorithms. It is not just development and implementation, there is also an integration and transition period from software designed under the assumption of previous algorithms. 10 years is probably a more reasonable limit for computer algorithms. The R&D cost that goes into computer algorithm patents is often substantial as well. When people say "software patents" they are usually talking about "business process" patents, not computer algorithm patents, and business process patents should be disallowed generally. They are inherently vague.
- slowpoke 14y ago>When people say "software patents" they are usually talking about "business process" patents, not computer algorithm patents, and business process patents should be disallowed generally. You are contradicting yourself. "Business processes" are nothing more than algorithms, themselves. Algorithms are math. Math isn't patentable.
- jandrewrogers 14y agoNot at all. What distinguishes "business process" patents from other patents is that any specification strict enough to be on par with traditional patent matter are largely useless; they are uniquely vague in their specification because that is what makes them useful. This allows an enormous amount of scope creep simply based upon the subjectiveness of the interpretation. Computer algorithms are "math" in the same way that chemical process patents are math. By the criterion upon which you deem computer algorithms to be math, you can prove that all subject matter is math via algorithmic information theory. To make the distinction, you can patent a specific sorting algorithm (legal, there are an infinite number of such algorithms) but you cannot patent the idea of sorting (illegal because it is a mathematical concept). If the argument that computer algorithms are invalid because they are mathematical concepts is going to be made, it needs to be applied consistently which would exclude all currently patentable subject matter. In fact, computer algorithms have always been considered patentable subject matter around the world because they strictly specify the design of an electronic circuit. Electronic circuit designs are a traditionally patentable subject matter. A mathematical concept has no such specification.
- ThePherocity 14y agoAt the current rate of change 1 year is more than enough for an iPhone/iPad/kindle/etc... to completely dominate the market in terms of mindshare. Software patents need to go away immediately, and technology patents, if needed at all, need to be a year at most. If your idea is so easy to copy, then it probably wasn't that great of an idea anyway. It's taken 5 years for Google to truly catch up to the iPhone/iPad and be a real competitor.