12 ms·
They shut down and reopened without any changes to the law. They are open now, despite the law being in effect.
by ceejayoz 2y ago
They shut down and reopened without any changes to the law. They are open now, despite the law being in effect.
- extheat 2y agoThey reopened with formal understanding that there will be an executive order tomorrow to suspend the enforcement of the ban. That is a big deal and it's something that they can point to to defend themselves in court should that happen. When President Biden signed the bill, it gave him the ability to extend the deadline by an amount which he declined to do (beyond saying "I'll let Trump admin deal with it"); and soon-to-be President Trump is saying he will do it tomorrow.
- kllrnohj 2y agoI'm pretty certain an executive order cannot overrule a law. So they're just hoping to either get an actual reversal of the law while Trump is in term or just hoping nobody after him will care. It's like betting on jury nullification but without the benefit of double jeopardy protection. It's unclear if any of the US companies the law is aimed at will risk it.
- kelnos 2y agoAn executive order can't overrule a law, but it can direct the DoJ not to enforce a particular law.
- kllrnohj 2y agoWhich would be an EO counter the constitution and obviously not durable itself. In 4 years the next DOJ can just enforce the law on the books with 4 years of evidence of companies openly breaking it. It'd be a slam dunk case
- anon7000 2y agoThe law allows the president to grant a one time 90 day extension. (In this specific case)
- kllrnohj 2y agoTrump isn't president and the ban went into effect before he was. There's no legal extension possible anymore under this specific case.
- paulddraper 2y ago> formal understanding I think you mean "campaign promise." No legally significant action has been taken between now and yesterday.
- somenameforme 2y agoAre you privy to the private discussions between Trump and the heads of TikTok, Apple, Google, and Oracle? Or are you simply assuming there have been no such private discussions?
- comp_throw7 2y agoTrump isn't president yet, so any such conversations are not legally significant actions the way the person you're responding to meant.
- somenameforme 2y agoNot actions, but legally binding statements of intent. If Trump offered a binding statement to the heads of all major players that he intends to offer TikTok the 90-day window and work out a "deal" once in office would be more than sufficient justification for these companies to ease enforcement until things become more resolved.
- comp_throw7 2y agoThere is no mechanism by which Trump can offer a statement of intent that legally binds him to following that specific course of action after he becomes president.
- fc417fc802 2y agoAny violation and associated fine would proceed though court. I assume such a statement of intent would have meaning there.
- 2y ago
- Retric 2y agoIt’s federal law, and the president can offer a pardon allowing anyone to ignore federal law for as long as they remain in office. The courts on the other hand can permanently block laws.
- cyanydeez 2y agoAlso, the technical bit serms entirely on app distributors. This is the internet.
- mr_00ff00 2y agoThis feels like a stretch, I don’t think it’s a pardon they are after. Pardons don’t really work like that. TikTok I think was going for more of a shock factor. Maybe even without talking to Trump they have credited him as restoring it, might seem weird for him to “go back on it”. Or maybe it’s to put him in good light.
- Sparyjerry 2y agoTrump issued a statement saying that he would issue an executive order after he became president that retroactively would dismiss any fines which satisfied both TikTok and the app hosting providers (Apple, Google).
- psyklic 2y agoThe President can offer pardons for criminal matters. However, he is required to uphold laws passed by Congress, particularly bipartisan ones affirmed by the Supreme Court. For example, why would the President have a veto power if he can simply post-facto ignore laws they pass?