3 ms·
There was another good analysis in the CBC of Canada's next upcoming companies: http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/story/2012/07/12/f-canadian-technology-industr
by dmix 14y ago
There was another good analysis in the CBC of Canada's next upcoming companies: http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/story/2012/07/12/f-canadian-technology-industry.html http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/story/2012/07/12/f-canadia...
The key question is not whether there ARE tech companies getting started in Canada, it's whether they will stay in Canada once successful to help re-invest in the industry here.
But the most common pattern presently is that companies leave before they get (legitimately) successful. Either via acquisition or the need for capital - both not easily found in Canadian cities as it can in SV or NYC.
- allbombs 14y ago"The key question is not whether there ARE tech companies getting started in Canada, it's whether they will stay in Canada once successful to help re-invest in the industry here." I think that movement is changing.. Yes, it's harder to raise money up north but the cost for talent and gov funded programs here make Canada one of the most attractive places to start a company. Once established, why move down south?
- potatolicious 14y ago> "Once established, why move down south?" Later, and much larger, rounds of funding that is entirely unheard of in Canada. Also, talent. This might be inflammatory, but I venture that the bulk of Canada's A-talent is already in the USA. Given the ease of the TN visa, I think it's not a stretch to say that if you're offering $70K for software engineers in Toronto, you are not hiring any of Canada's top talent, because they're all in the US making $150K+. In my experience the few talented people who remain do so out of philosophical or family-related reasons, and that's a tiny, tiny slice of the overall pie. > "I think that movement is changing.." As a Canadian expat in the US I disagree. In fact, if anything, in recent years the brain drain of software talent from Canada to the US has increased as the software industry heats up down south. If your top players are consistently moving out of the country, it doesn't matter what government programs exist, you've already lost. Talent is 95% of the problem. So long as US companies are offering fresh graduates $120K+ comp packages to live in sunny California, and Canadian firms have trouble ponying up more than $60K, the brain drain will continue, and Canada will continue to be scraping the bones of its own talent pool.
- mikepurvis 14y agoDefinitely agree with this. I enjoy my work for a small company in Waterloo, but the compensation is definitely a pittance, and that aspect has frustrated me the entire time I've been there. We get a lot of government money too--- IRAP, SR&ED, OCE, etc, but the lack of a VC scene means we're basically stuck bootstrapping the company. Everyone's very wealthy on paper, but stock options don't put a roof over a young family. We've stayed in the area for exactly the reasons you speak of---proximity to family, and concerns about US politics, healthcare, etc. But it's agony to look around and see so few job alternatives, especially when I've been invited on multiple occasions to apply for positions in the valley based on nothing more than a HN comment. sigh
- Cyranix 14y agoAmerican expat in Canada here. Agreed that the compensation is not as competitive as in the US, and the prospect of living in bustling NY or sunny Cali is probably quite alluring for Canadian programmers to boot. (Having moved from Texas, I'm not sure I could thrive in Toronto and am quite relieved that Victoria has lovely weather.) That said, the Canadian system seems to be far less dysfunctional than its American counterpart. Perhaps the brain drain will diminish if political or economic turmoil continues to make the US less appealing for the liberal crowd?
- mcrider 14y agoNot to mention cheap, quality education drawing Americans and other foreigners into Canada (it did for me and I stayed after my degree was finished).
- anona 14y ago> Also, talent. This might be inflammatory, but I venture that the bulk of Canada's A-talent is already in the USA. Given the ease of the TN visa, I think it's not a stretch to say that if you're offering $70K for software engineers in Toronto, you are not hiring any of Canada's top talent, because they're all in the US making $150K+. A computer programmer/software engineer/software developer is not technically eligible for TN status. A 'Computer Systems Analyst' is eligible for TN status, but as an informal rule if your jobs involves more than 10%-20% coding you do not qualify for Computer Systems Analyst. While I'm sure many developers are working as a Computer System Analyst, they are at risk of being denied entry every time the enter the country if the USCIS official decides they do not qualify. So there are still significant immigration barriers that act to keep a good portion of Canadian talent in Canada.