3 ms·
Psychometrics peddlers looking for suckers (military, large corporations) buying the “this is the best measure in psychology” argument when it is not even techn
by paulpauper 2y ago
Psychometrics peddlers looking for suckers (military, large corporations) buying the “this is the best measure in psychology” argument when it is not even technically a measure — it explains at best between 2 and 13% of the performance in some tasks (those tasks that are similar to the test itself)[see interpretation of .5 correlation further down], minus the data massaging and statistical cherrypicking by psychologists; it doesn’t satisfy the monotonicity and transitivity required to have a measure (at best it is a concave measure). No measure that fails 80–95% of the time should be part of “science” (nor should psychology — owing to its sinister track record — be part of science (rather scientism), but that’s another discussion).
IQ testing incurs legal risk and yet companies use proxies like the wonderlic, because there is some correlation between IQ and competence, that is not possible to predict otherwise.
- tptacek 2y agoNo it doesn't. I think this is a genuine example of an urban legend; many large employers, companies with deep pockets against whom employment lawyers would gladly take cases on contingency, very publicly administer IQ and general cognitive ability tests. There's nothing specifically risky about IQ; any employment fairness regime that proscribed Ravens Progressive Matrices would also proscribe the Wonderlic or CCAT test. Griggs vs. Duke Power doesn't mention "IQ" even once --- but does specifically call out the Wonderlic.