4 ms·
I propose a fun and existing amendment to intellectual property cases: if the plaintiff loses, the defendant gets to shoot the plaintiff (or the plaintiff's CEO
by kstrauser 14y ago
I propose a fun and existing amendment to intellectual property cases: if the plaintiff loses, the defendant gets to shoot the plaintiff (or the plaintiff's CEO) and the losing legal team. Not at a distant time and place, mind you, but right there on the spot. "We the jury find the defendant not liable blam blam."
I think that should reduce the number of patent lawsuits to approximately the number appropriate for an educated and free society. If you really, really feel that you've been wronged, go for it! But don't waste the court's or society's time, resources, and goodwill on horrid antisocial crud like this.
- jmduke 14y agoThe fuck? Replace 'intellectual property' with 'whistleblower' and you've suddenly illustrated exactly the terrible climate that scares a lot of people away from doing the right thing. The problem isn't overzealousness. Hell, overzealousness should be commended. The problem is a system which drains time and resources regardless and outcome, and a general ignorance due to the complexity of technology & prior art.
- kstrauser 14y agoWe want overzealous IP litigation? To the contrary: yes, that is exactly the problem.
- jmduke 14y agoOverzealous litigation is preferable to underzealous litigation with the assumption that litigation always favors justice and truth. Obviously, that latter is not true, and that's the issue here.
- freehunter 14y agoHow about a more realistic thought (the humor in your post has been noted), how about if when you lose a patent case as the plaintiff, you (or your company) are no longer allowed to file patents in the future, and your existing patents are now invalid.
- kstrauser 14y agoI could get completely behind that, or at the minimum, the specific patents used in the lawsuit are invalidated.
- Natsu 14y agoPeople being sued for patent infringement often go on the offensive, filing reexamination requests with the USPTO in order to invalidate the patent. One problem is that the courts, especially those in East Texas, do not care to wait for the reexamination procedures to finish, so you can infringe on a patent later found invalid. It would be very interesting if Notch got their lawyers to supervise a crowd-sourced search for prior art, though. I hope he does so!