3 ms·
Why do humans live long enough to be grandparents? It's because grandparents take care of the grandkids while the parents work.
by WalterBright 2y ago
Why do humans live long enough to be grandparents? It's because grandparents take care of the grandkids while the parents work.
- derektank 2y agoI find the grandparents hypothesis compelling at first glance but it sort of begs the question, why don't we live indefinitely in the first place? There are obvious answers, we make tradeoffs to improve performance early in life at the expense of long term function, but it doesn't seem like the reproductive benefits of caring for a grandchild that only shares a 1/4 of your DNA necessarily tips the scales of selection towards longevity. Especially when, in theory, men remain fertile their entire lives and thus there should have always been some selection for longer life spans. You would expect the reproductive benefits of a 70 year old caring for their own child might be at least comparable to 70 year old caring for a grandchild.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y ago> why don't we live indefinitely in the first place? It doesn’t seem to be necessary for the survival of our genes. > You would expect the reproductive benefits of a 70 year old caring for their own child might be at least comparable to 70 year old caring for a grandchild. They’re competing with 20-30 year-olds with better physical fitness for a mate. This would be relevant for ~99% of human existence even if it’s not totally relevant today.
- WalterBright 2y agowhy don't we live indefinitely in the first place? 1. need to make room for the young, ecosystems are not unlimited 2. we accumulate parasites and diseases as we live. Dying kills them off, too 3. much slower evolution, implying losing ground compared with quickly evolving competitors
- thrance 2y agoMembers of some species take care of the children of others, as well as theirs (Orcas come to mind, humans too if course). There is an advantage in helping others with similar DNA than you, because they will reciprocate.
- EdwardDiego 2y agoObviously because Tree-of-Life didn't survive on Earth, so we could never achieve our final form. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pak_Protector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pak_Protector
- jajko 2y agoI don't think its that simple. If we look back far enough, it was more like the man/men hunted or gathered and women took care of kids, fire and cooking. If I look at less distant ancestors, they all worked in the fields, and so did grandparents (who were not as old as these days when 15 was a good age to start bearing kids, so 35 years old granny was normal). So it again falls mostly on women. Grandparents, those still living, much less.
- hinkley 2y agoThere’s the historian factor as well. They’ve found that African Elephant populations are largely constrained by water availability. Creating artificial watering holes is helping restore elephant populations better than most other attempts. But the matriarch is typically one of the oldest female members of the group, and elephants remember watering holes that they haven’t visited since they were young. During a drought they will check all of these secondary and tertiary water sources. If that elephant is killed by poachers, the herd may lose the last remaining record of water resources and suffer for it. I also recall watching a documentary about a troupe of primates. They adopted a young male kicked out of another troupe. Nothing remarkable about him until, again, a drought year. Turns out not all knowledge of edible foods is instinctual. They discovered him eating a fruit none of the tribe had eaten before. When he didn’t die they all started eating it too. So I think we underestimate the value of record keeping with respect to longevity and inter-group mixing. It’s not all genes and safety in numbers.
- EdwardDiego 2y agoIn Māori culture in NZ, tribal elders (kaumātua) function much the same, they are the keepers of knowledge, history and cultural practices for their group(s). I suspect you'd find the same in many cultures that didn't have writing to transmit knowledge. (There's also the aspect of "mana", a very hard word to translate, "face", "influence", "power" or "really respected" are good approximations. A kaumātua with mana accords your group (iwi/tribe or hapu/sub-tribe) with their mana. So, say your Granddad was a renowned warrior or diplomat, even though he's in his 80s, the respect his opponents developed for him still persists, and flows onto you.)