5 ms·
The whole case turns on foreign adversary control of the data.
by tptacek 2y ago
The whole case turns on foreign adversary control of the data.
- mjmsmith 2y agoExactly, these are hostile political actors interfering in our country. This is also why Facebook and X should be banned everywhere except the USA.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoMeanwhile, it's perfectly fine for foreign adversaries to use American social media to interfere with American events. Anything for that GDP.
- mjmsmith 2y agoGood point. Social media accounts should only be available to people who live in the country where the company is based. Then there's no need to ban Facebook and X elsewhere.
- gWPVhyxPHqvk 2y ago... and also the USA, too.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- muglug 2y agoRight, Congress was shown some pretty convincing evidence that execs in China pull the strings, and those execs are vulnerable to Chinese government interference. As we’ve seen in the past couple of weeks, social media companies based in the US are also vulnerable to US government interference — but that’s the way they like it.
- ok123456 2y agoThey have? They released a Marty Rimm-level report citing that pro-Palestinian was mentioned more than pro-Israeli content in ratios that differed from Meta products. This was the 'smoking gun' of manipulation when it's more of a sign Meta was the one doing the manipulation.
- tptacek 2y agoThe opinion today has almost nothing to do with how content is controlled on the platform; the court is very clear that they'd have upheld the statute based purely on the data collection issue.
- derektank 2y agoI don't know what Congress has said but there absolutely is evidence that TikTok has been used to spy on users for political reasons. A US based engineer claims that he saw evidence that Hong Kong protestors were spied on in 2018 at the behest of a special committee representing the CCP's interests within ByteDance. This is not surprising, most major corporations within China maintain a special committee representing the government's interests to company executives https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2023/6/7/china-spied-on-hong-kong-activists-using-tiktok-lawsuit-claims https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2023/6/7/china-spied-on-ho...
- Zigurd 2y agoYou are assuming a lot about supposed evidence nobody has said anything specific about. One shouldn't also assume people in Congress know how to evaluate any evidence. Nor justices, based on the questions they asked.
- tptacek 2y agoAs a matter of political science and public choice theory, the legislature is the branch of government most trusted to collect information and make these kinds of deliberations.
- coldpie 2y agoYou might buy that, but I don't. Unless they can actually put forward publicly compelling evidence of a national security risk, this can only be seen as a handout to Facebook by the government. This saga just gives more evidence that the US government exists primarily to serve the interests of US's oligarch class. Aside for those oligarchs, it does nothing to serve US citizens' interests.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoWould you call Marjorie Taylor Greene a qualified and trusted investigator for the american people? I sure wouldn’t. Talking about what the legislature is supposed to be is irrelevant. What the legislature actually is is relevant.
- morkalork 2y agoCongress members speak of space lasers and weather control... I'm not sure they're competent as a whole. Actually, it reminds me of the Russian guy that always spouts nonsense about nuking UK into oblivion, and that theory that he's just kept around to make the real evil people look sane.
- eptcyka 2y agoGood thing Mr Zuckerberg is a shining beacon of independence from the US government.
- tptacek 2y agoHe's not a formally designated foreign adversary, at least not yet.
- jack_pp 2y agoThe difference is you can easily prosecute Zuck
- jeffrapp 2y agoEasily? No. Within the bounds of the US Constitution, yes.
- coldpie 2y agoNo. Zuck is very securely within the class of citizens that is immune to prosecution within the US.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoI’m sure he’s bending at the knee right now because he feels very secure and just had a change of heart about everything precisely one month after the election.
- coldpie 2y agoIs he bending the knee, or dropping the mask? The billionaire+ class rightly sees this as their big opportunity to seize power for the next several generations, removing worker and consumer protections and enshrining themselves as essential parts of the government.
- kevinmchugh 2y agoWhy is this true of Zuck but was not true of SBF?
- navi0 2y agoIs X vulnerable to Chinese government interference because its American executive has other business interests in China at stake? I’d argue the TikTok remedy should be applied to X, too.
- tartoran 2y agoThis should be applied to all social media.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoMedia flat out.
- kube-system 2y agoNo, X doesn't have a corporate governance structure that requires Chinese government control, because it is a US company. Companies in China (and especially those of prominence) have formal structures and regulations that require them to cooperate with the government, and sometimes require the companies to allow the government to intervene in operations if necessary. It is not possible for a CCP official to show up to a board meeting at X and direct the company to take some action, because that isn't how US corporations work.
- gWPVhyxPHqvk 2y agoA CCP official could show up at a Tesla board meeting and announce they're going to seize Gigafactory Shanghai unless Musk takes down some content on X. There doesn't seem to be much of a difference.
- kube-system 2y agoTesla is quite notable as the only foreign automaker which China has allowed to operate independently in China. All of the rest of them were forced to joint venture with 51%+ control being handed over to a Chinese domestic company. So, really it's pretty surprising that they haven't done that even before Musk owned X. But regardless, there is a huge difference between a request and actually having managerial authority -- the most obvious being that someone with managerial authority can simply do whatever they want without trying to compel someone else. Also, X, being subject to US law, must comply with that no matter what consequences Musk is threatened with. So, any threats may have limits in what they can practically accomplish.
- yard2010 2y agoThat's the way I like it for my children. Pardon the demagogue. The US, being the awful mess it is is still 100x better IMHO than the chinese government. It's the lesser evil kind of thing and honestly the reason I believe that democracy is 100% THE way to go. Things can only get US level nefarious with democracy. Far from perfect but much less evil. The only problem with democracy is that it's so fragile and susceptible to bad non-democrat actors intervention, which is more of an awareness problem.
- hedora 2y agoThat can’t be it. Facebook sells the same data to foreign adversaries including China and Russia. The most famous incident involved the British company Cambridge Analytica, which used it to manipulate election outcomes in multiple countries: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook–Cambridge_Analytica_data_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook–Cambridge_Analytica... Edit: Apparently it’s not common knowledge that this is still happening. Here’s a story about a congressional investigation from 2023: https://www.scworld.com/analysis/developers-in-china-russia-had-access-to-facebook-user-data-for-years-senators-say https://www.scworld.com/analysis/developers-in-china-russia-... And here’s a story about an executive order from Biden the next year. Apparently the White House concluded that the investigation wasn’t enough to fix the behavior: https://www.thedailyupside.com/technology/biden-wants-to-stop-foreign-spies-buying-americans-data/ https://www.thedailyupside.com/technology/biden-wants-to-sto... https://edition.cnn.com/2024/02/28/politics/americans-personal-data-foreign-powers-executive-order https://edition.cnn.com/2024/02/28/politics/americans-person... Edit 2: Here’s a detailed article from the EFF from this month explaining how the market operates: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2025/01/online-behavioral-ads-fuel-surveillance-industry-heres-how https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2025/01/online-behavioral-ads-...
- tptacek 2y agoI assure you, if you read the opinion, that is indeed it, and the objection you raise about other instances of data collection not being targeted is addressed directly.
- paganel 2y ago> That can’t be it. Facebook sells the same data to foreign adversaries including China and Russia. I'm not sure they do that anymore, not in the current geopolitical climate and not with the DC ghouls having taken over the most sensitive parts of Meta the company (there were many posts on this web-forum about former CIA people and not only working at the highest levels inside of Meta).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- zeroonetwothree 2y ago
- benreesman 2y agoThat may be true in a legal sense (and my reading of that is the same as yours). My interpretation of the parent’s comment is that we have pretty serious (and dubiously legal) overreach on this in a purely domestic setting as well. As someone who has worked a lot on products very much like TikTok, I’d certainly argue that we do.
- tptacek 2y agoThe short answer here is that directly addressing a threat from a foreign adversary formally designated by both the legislative and executive branches long before the particular controversy before the court affords the government a lot more latitude than they would have in other cases.
- benreesman 2y agoI’m not sure anyone is disputing that, certainly I’m not. There is an adjacent point that many of us feel is just as important, which is that there is evidence in the public record (see Snowden disclosures among others) that there is lawbreaking or at least abuse of clearly stated constitutional liberties taking place domestically in the consumer internet space and has been for a long time. Both things can be true, and both are squarely on topic for this debate whether on HN or in the Senate Chambers.
- josefritzishere 2y agoIt's still completely legal for Meta to sell that user data to Chinese owned companies. So no security is provided by this change. I see it as theatre.
- xnx 2y agoI thought this too, but I think there's a new law for this as well: "In a bipartisan measure, the House of Representatives unanimously pass a bill designed to protect the private information of all Americans by prohibiting data brokers from transferring that information to foreign adversaries such as China" https://allen.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=6203 https://allen.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=...
- tptacek 2y agoPeople keep coming up with other avenues by which China could get this information, but the court addresses that directly: the legislature is not required to address every instance of a compelling threat in one fell swoop.
- echelon 2y ago[flagged]
- rusty_venture 2y agoThank you for this concise and comprehensive summary. The DDoS threat had never occurred to me.
- bloomingkales 2y agoChina can show favorable political content to America and American youth. American culture has been such an influencing force on the world due to our conduits, movies and music. TikTok is a Chinese conduit, and I do believe this is happening. Our culture can be co-opted, the Chinese had John Cena apologize to ALL of China. They can easily pay to have American influencers spin in a certain way, influencing everything.
- doug_durham 2y agoChina can benefit without doing any influencing. It can simply mine the vast amount of data it gets for sentiment analysis. Say they want to be more aggressive against the Philippines. They can do an analysis to gauge the potential outrage on the part of the American people. If it's low they can go ahead.
- o999 2y agoSo China blocking US social media is justified for the very same reasons?
- likpok 2y agoChina has blocked US social media for years (decades perhaps?). I don't know if they've explicitly said all the reasons, but "social stability" is a big one. As an aside, TikTok itself is banned in China.
- ternnoburn 2y agoIt seems pretty bold to assume that Google, Facebook, Amazon, X, etc aren't adversaries. Foreign or otherwise.
- tptacek 2y agoThe case turns on the fact that China is formally designated a foreign adversary. The statute doesn't allow the government to simply make up who its adversaries are on the fly, or derive them from some fixed set of first principles. There's a list, and it long predates this case.
- ternnoburn 2y agoYour mistake is assuming I'm thinking about any sort of legal definition. Adversarial nature doesn't require or government to declare it for it to exist.
- mindslight 2y agoYes, there is a distinction there. The issue is that it's a small part of the overall problem when looked at the larger scale. The overarching issues of political influence at odds with individual citizens, hostile engagement-maximizing algorithms, adversarial locked-down client apps, and selling influence to the highest bidder are all there with domestically-incorporated companies. The government's argument basically hinges on "but when these companies do something really bad we can force domestic companies to change but we can't do the same for TikTok". That's disingenuous to American individuals who have been on the receiving end of hostile influence campaigns for over a decade, disingenuous to foreign citizens not in the US or China who can't control any of this, and disingenuous to our societal principles as we're still ultimately talking about speech.