6 ms·
Divers recover Phoenician shipwreck that sank 2.6k years ago off coast of Spain
- ivan_gammel 2y agoA good book to read more or less related to this shipwreck: https://www.amazon.com/How-World-Made-West-History/dp/059372979X?dplnkId=ec26943b-3552-40fc-8f01-3edac8a5ca7b&nodl=1 https://www.amazon.com/How-World-Made-West-History/dp/059372...
- behnamoh 2y agoHow did people come up with alphabet? Phoenicians were one of the first to invent this technology, but I assume language existed way before that? How did that happen? Like, how did people agree on saying certain things to mean specific things? Starting from the mind of the first humans who didn't have language, how did we get to where we had language and it was so ubiquitous that even ancient civilizations like Phoenicians put it in writing?
- detourdog 2y agoRealize that any successful language came from a close family with repeative daily tasks. To be successful they would need common terms to cooperate.
- fouronnes3 2y agoThis is basically unknown. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origin_of_language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origin_of_language
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gostsamo 2y agotry to recreate reality and a limited but repeatable form. roar like a lion, sing like a bird. remove everything that a thing looks like in order to leave what it is. break it into components and try to recompose them in new ways. general principals of intelligence, I'd say.
- Tainnor 2y ago> but I assume language existed way before that Way, way, way older. Writing is an incredibly novel development. There are still today linguistic communities without writing, although they're becoming much rarer. Writing was unknown in parts of the world until quite recently - the Aborigines of Australia didn't have it, nor did many pre-Columbian civilisations. It's a safe bet that writing first emerged out of a need for accounting and this thus closely tied to larger agricultural civilisations. That's why we find it in places like Mesopotamia and Egypt first. Of course, those weren't alphabets yet, but logosyllabic writing (characters could stand for either meanings or syllables). The alphabet is a specifically Phoenician innovation, although similar systems (such as abugidas), which are also phonetic, have emerged elsewhere.
- yread 2y ago> the Aborigines of Australia didn't have it, nor did many pre-Columbian civilisations. No need to go that far, the Slavs didn't write down their languages until ~800s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glagolitic_script https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glagolitic_script
- defrost 2y ago> No need to go that far .. Seems relative .. I literally grew up on Aboriginal land in the Kimberley and attended school with multi lingual kids that had non English speaking parents. Most are still not writing in their own language. What is "Far" for you is neighbours from school and locals of the town I now live in. Certainly these are closer in space and time than Slavs from a few hundred years past.
- mattclarkdotnet 2y agoPerthite Brit here. I’m hugely curious about the situation before the Europeans came. Was there really no writing? Were there really no boats? It’s all so murky because the history was literally not written by the aboriginal communities. But has a story been passed down?
- mseepgood 2y agoPeople come up with new things all the time. It happens in this very moment, all around the world. I don't see how this is astonishing.
- naasking 2y agoUnknown, but I'd hazard a guess that old cave art that depicts animals and sizes probably had sounds associated with them too. Humans like to tell stories, so probably cave art had oral history of some kind, and pictures probably became progressively more precise to handle progressively more complex stories, maybe about seasons, places, counting to keep track of things, etc.
- alganet 2y agoThat is a sound idea, but it makes more sense for hieroglyphs and ideograms. My guess for phoenicia is that their alphabet comes from numbers (or maybe other smaller individual set of symbols) borrowed from another culture, but I wouldn't be able to determine from who or where.
- adrian_b 2y agoThe Phoenicians did not invent their alphabet, they inherited an older alphabet. Nevertheless they had a very important role in spreading the alphabetic writing system to many other populations, which was a consequence of their travels and commercial relations with everybody around the Mediterranean and even farther away. Because of this, the ancestry of the majority of the alphabetic systems, even of some far away in South Asia can be traced back to the Phoenician alphabet. Because of the importance of the commerce with Phoenicians and because of the many Phoenician colonies, the Phoenician language has also been spoken by many non-Phoenicians. This had as a consequence a simplification of the pronunciation of the Phoenician language, because for most foreigners it was difficult to pronounce some of the sounds specific to the Semitic languages. The result of this simplification in pronunciation was that the number of letters of the Phoenician alphabet has been reduced to 22 letters from the 27 letters of the older North-Semitic alphabet inherited by the Phoenicians, because some of the sounds that were written with different letters in the older alphabet have evolved towards an identical pronunciation, so eventually the redundant letters from each pair with the same pronunciation have been dropped. 22 letters is a too small number for most languages, which has forced those who have adapted the Phoenician alphabet to other languages to add supplemental letters, like in the Greek alphabet, then in the Latin alphabet. The small number of letters has created problems also for the writing of other Semitic languages, like Aramaic, Hebrew and Arabic, which did not have the simplified pronunciation of Phoenician. The older North-Semitic alphabet from which the Phoenician alphabet had been derived would have been perfect for such Semitic languages, but by the time when writing has spread from the Phoenicians to their Semitic neighbors the older Semitic alphabet had been forgotten, exactly in the same way (and probably for the same reasons) as the Mycenaean writing had been forgotten in Greece (i.e. toward the end of the 2nd millennium BC there have been a few centuries of "Dark Ages" when much prior knowledge had been lost, after the destruction of many cities). Because the older Semitic alphabet had been forgotten, the Hebrew alphabet has 22 letters derived from the Phoenician alphabet through the Aramaic alphabet, despite the fact that this number was not enough to write all the consonants of ancient Hebrew. One Hebrew letter has now 2 variants distinguished with diacritic marks, i.e. "shin" and "sin", because originally it was used to write 2 different sounds, one of which no longer existed in Phoenician (modern Hebrew has lost that sound, so now "sin" and "samekh" are pronounced in the same way). Writing has been invented independently in many places around the world, but in almost all writing systems the written symbols have been used to denote either syllables or words. The Egyptian writing system and the alphabetic writing systems, all of which have been derived from the Egyptian writing system, are the exception. A subset of the symbols of the Egyptian writing system was used to denote single consonants, while the remainder were used to denote multiple consonants, regardless of which vowels were pronounced together with the consonants. The ancient Semitic alphabet has simplified the Egyptian writing system by retaining only the symbols that denote a single consonant. The ancient Semitic alphabet has retained thus the principle of writing only the consonants, and it has also inherited from the Egyptians the direction of writing from right to left, which has been preserved in the Hebrew and Arabic writing systems. Besides changing the meaning of some Phoenician letters from consonants to vowels, developing thus the first alphabetic writing system in the restricted meaning of the term "alphabet", i.e. with an approximately one-to-one mapping between all phonemes and letters, not only between consonants and letters, the Greeks have reversed the writing direction and this has been inherited in the other European writing systems.
- nkrisc 2y agoYou might be confusing language (a natural human skill which we evolved) and writing (a technology invented by humans, within the last 5-10 thousand years - very roughly). As far as I’m aware, there no evidence that modern humans ever existed without language. And other recent hominid species that until recently co-existed with our ancestors probably had language too. So probably there was never a human without language. Any non-lingual ancestor of ours was not human and probably pre-dates humans. As for writing, to be reductionist, it is essentially arbitrary.
- WalterBright 2y agoWe co-evolved with language - the evidence is our adaptations to control over the voicebox, tongue, lips, etc.
- nkrisc 2y agoYes, that is what I meant though in retrospect I see I didn’t make that entirely clear. What I meant was that language and vocalizations go way, way back than any ancestor remotely human-like. Where you draw the line between mere “vocalizations” and “language” is a pretty open question, IMO.
- cladopa 2y agoActually, the alphabet invention was precisely that the same alphabet could be used for different languages. They did not agreed on using certain sounds for specific things. They already did that on their own languages, each with their specific sounds. What the Phoenician Alphabet did was transcribing those sounds that already existed to a writing system that was common. The Phoenicians did not invent the alphabet but they used it so much that developed it a lot. They used it for communication as a Lingua Franca for commerce in the Mediterranean. It actually became a language on its own. They will use a native word from the native language of some particular good or commodity and then everybody around the Mediterranean Sea will use that written name and sound for referring to that thing. It was extremely useful, so people used it more and more creating over time latin and greek scripts.
- gwervc 2y ago> Actually, the alphabet invention was precisely that the same alphabet could be used for different languages. No. Multiple languages were written with the same alphabet because of the borrowing of that technology by speakers of other languages, not because it was designed as such. Actually the process of borrowing is fondamental to the emergence of alphabets: the three biggest (by corpus size) logographic scripts all gave birth to more phonetic scripts across language boundaries. That happened with hieroglyphics (the case we are discussing), but also with Sumerian cuneiform > Akkadian writing and Chinese characters > Japanese kanas.
- p3rls 2y agoWe have the notes from a zoom meeting between the priests of Ba'al and some early Phoenician scribes when they were designing the alphabet and outside of sacrificing children they were actually really concerned about accessibility standards
- WalterBright 2y agoWe're currently evolving back to pictograms.
- ocschwar 2y agoThe Phoenician alphabet started as the Proto-Sinaitic script. For context, if you're trying to write things down in the Sinai, you're logging the wares carried by caravans going back and forth from Egypt to the Phoenician heartland and back. You don't need the full range of hieroglyphs, so you don't need the training of an Egyptian priest. So you start with a reduced list of symbols. Someone in this position started using those symbols to register the sounds of the Semitic languages, and the rest is literally history.
- WalterBright 2y agoMan's first words were: awk grep ping biff ip yum du curl sed
- kedarkhand 2y agoand don't the most important of them all, neofetch, it is posited that they used it for colorful displays to attract mates. How successful it was, we do not know ;)
- kstrauser 2y agoWritten with ed, of course.
- quesera 2y ago> awk grep ping biff ip yum du curl sed Not to offend anyone, but ip yum and curl are neologisms introduced in later translations. Wars have been fought over this disagreement!
- mmooss 2y agoHere is a good history, by an expert, of how writing evolved from a counting system to a full written language: https://sites.utexas.edu/dsb/tokens/the-evolution-of-writing/ https://sites.utexas.edu/dsb/tokens/the-evolution-of-writing...
- dghughes 2y agoCanaanite workers who went to Egypt to work in the mines saw these picture things used on walls. They had an idea to use it only instead of a picture per word the just used them for sounds. The Ox Head they saw they used for their Aleph sound. It was adjusted and rotated a bit then later on rotated again until we get our modern letter A.
- Aloisius 2y agoEgyptian hieroglyphs were used sometimes to represent 1-3 consonants, rather than words or ideas. Egyptian Hieratic script simplified the forms down for writing with ink. Canaanites simplified it further by tossing all the ideograms, logograms and multi-consonant symbols to create an abjad. The Greeks added the first vowels to create a true alphabet.
- noneeeed 2y agoThere is a decent BBC documentary "The Secret History of Writing" which is all about the origins of writing. If you are interested in how it developed in all its different forms it's worth a watch.
- Loughla 2y agoThis is only tangentially related, but if you like history and ship wrecks and live near Kansas City, go to the Steamboat Arabia museum. They're digging up a steamboat that sunk, and they found after the river changed its course. It's super cool. When we went the last time we were driving across the states, one of the guys actually doing the excavating was there. He gave our kids a guided tour and talked about all the exhibits with them. It was super cool.
- xandrius 2y agoCool indeed but 1856CE is not quite as incredible as 300BCE.
- WalterBright 2y agoWhat was in the 1856 wreck has rewritten the history of commerce on the Mississippi.
- Munksgaard 2y agoYou'll never guess what happened next!
- adolph 2y agoThis is the one weird trick that museums use to pull in donor dollars.
- joseppudev 2y agodid it rewrite the slave trade part as well or did that remain as it is written?
- Alive-in-2025 2y agoLook around Wikipedia, you find a little more info re slavery and this ship. Kansas and Missouri were on the violent border with a mixture of pro and anti-slavery views, even as the geographical boundary of allowed slavery separated "the south". The museum website says there's clothing on the ship that has a pro-slavery mark, to be sent to some store. The ship at one time was boarded by pro-slavery forces who found hidden guns that were being shipped to abolitionists. It does not appear they sent slaves on it en mass. There were plenty of people who were pro slavery in those days. Mixed all across the US, read Mark Twain. There were plenty of people against it. More to the point, I wonder if the museum addresses this. I'm going to guess only in a small way, having lived half my life in the south. Maybe someone with actual knowlege can comment instead of web search "experts" like me.
- martyvis 2y agoFYI 2600 and 2.6k use the same number of characters.
- Bootvis 2y agoIt doesn't mean the same though, 2.6k implies somewhere between 2550 and 2650 years ago and 2600 an exact number of years.
- kstrauser 2y ago2600 only has 2 significant digits. It's not an exact number.
- defanor 2y agoUnless the precision (resolution) is known (stated), it is unclear whether the trailing zeroes are significant or not, one may only guess (while such a guess looks reasonable in this case). A convention for writing that unambiguously is to avoid insignificant trailing zeroes: e.g., writing it as 26e2 or 2.6e3. Then the written number carries along its precision.
- golol 2y agoDoesn't writing out the trailing zeroes mean that you clain 4 significant digits? At least in the physics context.
- busyant 2y agoI think there are a few conventions for expressing sig digits. Where I was taught… 2600 has 2 sd 2600. Has 4 sd 2.6e3 has 2sd 2.60e3 has 3 sd Edit. If I had been in charge of setting sd rules, I would’ve said … 2600 has 4 sd 260? Has 3 sd 26?? Has 2 sd The fact zeros are overloaded (they can be placeholders or they can actually mean 0) is confusing to students.
- olddustytrail 2y agoThis reminds me of Andrew Scott Waugh, who surveyed the height of Mount Everest. He was sure his method was accurate to the nearest foot but he measured the height of the mountain at exactly 29,000 feet. Since he thought people would assume it was a rounded figure, he reported it as 29,002. And is therefore known as the man who first put 2 feet on the top of Everest.
- Boogie_Man 2y agoPhoenicia will rise again
- numbsafari 2y agoBring on the Sea Peoples (maybe)
- mythrwy 2y agoDifferent set of people (although they both traveled on the sea).
- c0redump 2y agoThe sea peoples likely came from around the Mediterranean, but primarily were Nuragic people from modern-day Sardinia
- w0de0 2y agoThat’s one hypothesis for one component of the Sea Peoples. Like all the hypotheses, it’s very weakly evidenced - iirc correctly (from Eric Cline), in this case, there’s a possible philological link with the Egyptian exonym ‘Sherden’ and one possible representation of a nurhag.
- numbsafari 2y agoahem... https://xkcd.com/356/ https://xkcd.com/356/
- nothrowaways 2y agoMPGA
- w0de0 2y agoIn some sense it never died. Lebanese people are largely their descendants, and their diaspora is extremely mercantile. Tyre is yet inhabited, as are many of the ancient metropoles of Phoenicia.
- shpx 2y agoPreserved ancient shipwrecks are why I don't believe when people say some material "degrades in X years".
- BurningFrog 2y agoIn most waters, wood will be consumed by various life forms fairly quickly. No ancient shipwrecks are found there. The exceptions include the Baltic, the Black Sea, and the deep ocean. Don't know what saved this old boat though.
- userbinator 2y agoOf course the Titanic has been continuously rusting away too, along with being eaten by bacteria.
- Unearned5161 2y agoIn water yes, but ancient shipwrecks are found all over the place because they've been buried under sediment. That is the case with this one, you'll notice in the article that they say, "the sand protection is leaving", which I take to mean that while it was discovered in 1993, it was covered up with sand and so protected from issues such as water movement, sun, and life forms. The sand is now eroding away and leaving the ship unprotected, hence the move, hence the article. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaeology_of_shipwrecks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaeology_of_shipwrecks
- BurningFrog 2y agoThanks. I wasn't aware of this!
- LtdJorge 2y agoIt was also protected with a metallic coffin when discovered in the 90s
- mongol 2y ago
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y ago> They spent 560 hours diving at the wreck site to make detailed diagrams of its many cracks and fissures. I feel a bit jealous of them, me being in tech, doing hard work like this to preserve the history of humanity.
- fritzo 2y agoDiving with a little compressor tube looks fun. I used to clean my dad's pool that way, as a kid.
- dghughes 2y ago"The wreck will be conserved, protected and eventually reassembled". I wonder if Phoenicians labelled the parts of ships like their fellow Carthaginians (Chanani)? Or is this a Carthaginian ship but it's referred to as Phoenician?
- ricardobayes 2y agoFun-fact that the ship was found on a beach that is near the Spanish city called "Cartagena".
- ocschwar 2y agoMany of the cities in the region have Carthaginian names. It's a little surreal to see them when you speak Hebrew: Cadiz: "boundary" - the city that guarded access to Britain. Malaga: "Queen City". Cartagena. Barcelona ("barkel" - blessing)
- marcusverus 2y agoFun fact #2: that city was founded by Hasdrubal Barca, father of Hannibal Barca!
- w0de0 2y agoThere’s also a ‘Carthage of the Indies’ (Cartagena de Indias) in Colombia.
- rsynnott 2y ago"Carthaginian" is more or less a subset of "Phoenician".
- thaumasiotes 2y agoWhich is why the adjective associated with Carthage is "Punic".