4 ms·
Red Hat Woos VMware Shops with OpenShift Virtualization Engine
- lenerdenator 2y agoWhat're the FLOSS technologies underlying OpenShift? Sounds like KVM?
- samcat116 2y agoProbably kubevirt if I had to guess (which would then use KVM under the hood)
- houseofzeus 2y agoYes you are correct, it is kubevirt and leveraging KVM as the hypervisor coupled with the QEMU/Libvirt userspace pieces.
- natebc 2y agoOpenshift is Kubernetes+. Openshift Virtualization Engine is kubevirt (aka kvm/libvirt).
- lyarwood 2y agohttps://github.com/kubevirt https://github.com/kubevirt specifically for OpenShift Virtualization
- whalesalad 2y agoeverything ultimately boils down to kvm or qemu, usually
- jaitaiwan 2y agoOKR for the open source kubernetes, kubevirt for the virtualisation part.
- antithesis-nl 2y agoWell, the Enterprise-hypervisor market is certainly wide open right now, due to Broadcom turning the financial screws on VMware customers hard. There are, broadly, two categories of potentially-profitable VMware customers up for grabs: -Large enterprises that previously purchased hardware-with-accompanying-VMware-licenses from OEMs like Dell-EMC: Broadcom refused to even honor pre-acquisition license keys from these sources, leaving many private data centers in the lurch, unless they paid a huge premium for a new Broadcom-originated annual subscription (whereas the original key was one-off) -Service providers with an ongoing "small-percentage-of revenue per year, payable in arrears" agreement, that were suddenly forced into a "hard vCPU and vRAM limit" subscription, payable for at least 2 years upfront. However, the magic word for both customer segments is "vMotion", i.e. live-migration of VMs across disparate storage. No OSS and/or commercial (including Hyper-V) solution is able to truly match what VMware could (and can, at the right price) do in that space...
- zellyn 2y agoI think Oxide's stuff does live migration, but I don't know how well it runs on non-Oxide hardware.
- antithesis-nl 2y agoAs far as I can tell, Oxide is all about compute, not storage -- i.e., as long as you can guarantee a stable storage layer, your Oxide racks will be fine. VMware used to go a bit further, in that they allowed your compute nodes to fail and/or your storage nodes to fail, without adverse effects. If Oxide can do that, out-of-the-box, right-now, they'll be having a field day. Otherwise, my reservations about Oxide's business model remain...
- zellyn 2y agoI _think_ their storage layer is fault tolerant. Not sure though. Hopefully one of them will weigh in here.
- 2y ago
- mjtechguy 2y ago[dead]
- whalesalad 2y agoIf I were building a datacenter today I would go with proxmox. It's "just debian" under the hood and can be customized and controlled a multitude of ways (UI, CLI on the box, Terraform, API, etc)
- throw0101c 2y ago> If I were building a datacenter today I would go with proxmox. I use Proxmox as well in a small-ish deployment, but have also heard good things with Xcp-ng. At a previous job used OpenStack.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- NexRebular 2y agoOr if you'd like to help preventing linux monoculturalization of datacenters, MNX Triton or vanilla SmartOS are very good options too.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoMy impression, strengthened by https://wiki.smartos.org/managing-instances-with-vmamd/#using-vmadm-sendreceive https://wiki.smartos.org/managing-instances-with-vmamd/#usin... , is that SmartOS preferentially operates at the per-host scale, which is probably a disadvantage in a datacenter setting. (I don't know enough about MNX Triton to comment)
- whalesalad 2y agoThe cool thing about proxmox is that it is - again - "just debian" so there is really no vendor lock-in. Yes they do have commercial support/update subscriptions but the community offering is open (https://github.com/proxmox https://github.com/proxmox). So I do not worry too much about lock-in or monoculturalization. At the end of the day it is a wrapper around fundamental components of Linux. They do not have any proprietary secret sauce that would F you down the road. Correction I see now that the projects you reference are Solaris based. I am down with that cause too - but if you are a BSD/Solaris shop expect to do a lot of things on your own. The linux virtualization space is substantially larger (not necessarily suggesting it is better...)
- stego-tech 2y agoThey’ve been hammering us pretty hard, especially some folks in the leadership chain who worked with them before. While I have no direct beef with the product, the reality is that our Enterprise workload (and in fact, most Enterprise IT workloads in my experience) are VM-first, not container-first. My research conclusion at the time was that, while OpenShift is a great product worthy of consideration, it really only shines in organizations that are heavily invested in microservices or Kubernetes. If you (or more specifically, your vendors) haven’t migrated into that state, it’s not worth it compared to a RHEL server license and their KVM+Cockpit solution for bog standard VMs.
- woleium 2y agoor proxmox.. i was going to say for small shops, but i have heard of some larger deployments recently.
- mogwire 2y agoThis is a VM only version of OCP. No containers or microservices. So if you haven’t migrated into that state mentioned but want a Hypervisor that isn’t VMware and have enterprise support.
- more_corn 2y agoMoving off VMware (yay!) Onto open shift (crap.)
- breakingcups 2y agoRed Hat just hit us with 300% price increases for OpenShift across the board right after we went live in production after a little over a year of implementation. The entire org is very, very unhappy about it.
- woleium 2y agoAn IBM by any other name would smell the same?
- mogwire 2y ago300% and you added no additional compute? Prices went up but not 300% unless you got a major discount and added compute.
- breakingcups 2y agoNo additional compute. I don't think we had a major discount before.