8 ms·
Device uses wind to create ammonia out of air
- ada1981 2y agoHow do we create this right now? What are the costs for the catalysts and how long do they last? Those sorts of questions feel important to understand.
- Tagbert 2y agoMost ammonia is produced via the Haber process. It takes nitrogen from the air and hydrogen from natural gas and combines them into ammonia. It uses an iron catalyst. This process emits significant CO2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haber_process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haber_process
- adrian_b 2y agoCurrently hydrogen made from natural gas is the cheapest, but the Haber process could equally well use hydrogen made from water electrolysis using solar/wind energy. In that case there will be no production of CO2. The only reason why this is not done yet is because avoiding the production of CO2 would raise the cost of ammonia, then the costs of fertilizers and various other chemical substances, including explosives, which would trigger a cascade of price increases in food and in many other products.
- gs17 2y ago> but the Haber process could equally well use hydrogen made from water electrolysis using solar/wind energy. You can also use methane pyrolysis, which outputs solid carbon instead of CO2. It's supposed to be somewhere in the middle of cost between steam methane reforming and water electrolysis.
- blueflow 2y agoTake that ammonium, burn it, have heat, power a steam engine, infinite energy? Where does that energy come from? 1st law of thermodynamics?
- LincolnedList 2y agoThe energy comes from the sun, without it the atmosphere would freeze and this device wouldn't work.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kurthr 2y agoThe power could come from anything (solar, wind, wave) other than the dominant current source for all ammonia, the Haber Process. TFA mentions this in the headline? Could this be done before by just using water+air+solar, yes it could. Frankly, this is just a proof of concept and any commercial solution would be different for scaling reasons. Professor Aldo Rossa started popularizing a lot of this in the 80s. https://patents.google.com/patent/US4107277A/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US4107277A/en Having something other than a fossil fuel source for the most common fertilizer in the world seems useful. Also, it's easier, cheaper and safer to ship ammonia around than Hydrogen since it's a low pressure liquid and more energy dense. People have been talking about using it as a shipping fuel for decades.
- blueflow 2y agoYou didn't read the article? "The process requires no external power" right after the headline.
- hansvm 2y agoLike you said, the energy comes from somewhere. If I had to guess, it's effectively solar powered (the catalyst lowering the activation energy enough that photons can actually do the work), plus indirectly solar powered in that you need wind to physically move the compounds around.
- adrian_b 2y agoI have read the research paper and the energy appears to come mostly from the pump, because the flow of gas and vapor in the device causes contact electrification, which helps the redox reaction. They have not given any numbers about the energy consumed by the pump, but at least in this experimental devices it is likely that the amount of ammonia that is produced is very small for the energy consumed by the pump, in comparison with other synthesis methods. For now, the ammonia is produced as a solution in water with very low ammonia concentration. Perhaps this could be usable directly as a fertilizer for plants. For any other uses, concentrating the ammonia produced in this way would require a large amount of additional energy. In the form presented now, this method of ammonia synthesis would be too inefficient, but the authors hope that the efficiency can be improved some orders of magnitude.
- hammock 2y agoSo they invented a (chemical) bean plant/rhizobium? Or Nitrobacter. AKA atmospheric nitrogen fixer
- btbuildem 2y agoNo small feat!
- bparsons 2y agoThere are a million ways to turn large amounts of energy into smaller amounts of energy.
- BobaFloutist 2y agoAnd many of them are incredibly useful. Take, for example, the burning of fuel. Or eating and digesting.
- foxyv 2y agoHopefully, one day they will turn large amounts of cheap energy into valuable chemical feed stock and fuels. When you think about it, aluminum producers are doing something similar.
- K0balt 2y agoI hear there is a small fortune to be made in this technology. First, start with a large fortune. This fits with most VC backed companies. Back in 30 minutes with my showHN post!
- 0xedd 2y ago[dead]
- _aavaa_ 2y agoAmmonia as a fuel is an absurdly stupid idea. It is trading the lives and safety of crews and passengers for a bit of money.
- ReptileMan 2y agoWhat is so dangerous about it compared to lets say a gasoline engine converted to use LPG or Methane? There are many of those in Europe where I live.
- _aavaa_ 2y agoYou mean aside from being a colorless toxic gas that will kill you in as little as 5 minutes?
- ReptileMan 2y agoJust like propane, nitrogen, laughing gas, and methane ... I don't follow?
- fred69 2y agoI'm guessing you have never gotten a snoutfull of ammonia? Relatively low concentrations in air feel like asphyxiation. It also hangs around near the ground rather than floating upward.
- smaudet 2y agoI think the concern here is somewhat misplaced...ammonia powered passenger vehicles are probably a bad idea. But there's no reason that needs to be true for e.g. automated shipping industries. The danger to the water seems relatively low as well, as water dilution seems to be one of the best ways to deal with spillages. I'm uncertain the environmental repercussions, however it does seem to be the case that aquatic mammals and humans have natural methods of elimination, making it a game of concentration and dispersion vs e.g. an oil spill that is both highly toxic and nearly impossible to properly clean up. The majority of other applications are industrial (fertilizer, energy storage): there are major issues with our current distribution systems, cheap ammonia batteries could be the key to efficient electricity and hydrogen production and distribution.
- ThatGuyRaion 2y agoFractional Distillation is nothing new.
- einpoklum 2y ago"Researchers produce NH_3 fuel from N-gas-compound with H_2O vapor" Doesn't sound so exciting. But, sniping aside - is there a potential for cheap enough production in abundant enough amounts to use safely in machine engines? Or as grid-level storage medium for solar energy? The very transformation is neat, but the application is what would be interesting.
- pjc50 2y ago> produce NH_3 fuel from N-gas-compound with H_2O vapor At room temperature! That's the interesting bit.
- adrian_b 2y agoIn TFA the alternative methods for making ammonia are mentioned. One such method, which already works at room temperature for combining hydrogen with nitrogen into ammonia, uses electricity together with a platinum-gold catalyst and it has a 13% energetic efficiency. The methods described here uses cheaper materials and the authors hope that some time in the future it might reach a better energetic efficiency.
- chrisbrandow 2y agoAssuming the energy input is atmospheric warmth, then the real question is what volume of ammonia can you produce with this device per acre? Then how does that amount of captured energy compare with wind/solar in the same area? Otherwise, you’re just better off, producing electricity from one of those sources, or producing ammonia, using electricity from one of those sources, after accounting for losses in the various processes of course.
- dexwiz 2y agoAmmonia is very common in industrial applications.
- tomrod 2y agoTrue. Commonality of ammonia references ammonia demand whereas grandparent comment was referencing the supply capacity per acre.
- smaudet 2y agoSibling commenters mention industrial uses, sustainability means far more than just cars or electricity, part of why the focus on electric/cars is so short-sighted (never mind the issues electricity distribution brings to the table)... But for cars/electricity, this is potentially excellent news (assuming longevity and cost of the operating equipment). The distribution costs are much lower than Hydrogen, and it could be used easily to power existing Hydrogen fleets. I'd wager this even makes electricity distribution easier, as ammonia batteries could be relatively stable and easily distributed as well.
- bluGill 2y agoAmmonia is far to dangerous for cars. Household cleaning ammonia concentrate is 99% water. That is concentrate, you dilute it for use (generally 16:1), and it is still nasty stuff. No car with enough ammonia to use it for energy will be allowed in a tunnel. To work on a car that uses this for fuel will require extreme protective gear - a chemical breathing mask, and protective clothing covering the entire body. Working on machines in such gear is not easy.
- selimthegrim 2y agoDidn’t a group from KAUST falsify Zare’s results about microdroplets a few years ago and show that they weren’t anything special
- seemaze 2y agoThe article mentions "Traditional methods for ammonia production require high temperatures and pressures" in reference to the existing Haber-Bosch process for producing NH3 from thin air, an interesting historic story on its own. https://blog.rootsofprogress.org/turning-air-into-bread https://blog.rootsofprogress.org/turning-air-into-bread https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/73464/the-alchemy-of-air-by-thomas-hager-author-of-the-demon-under-the-microscope/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/73464/the-alchemy-o...
- trestacos 2y ago+1 "alchemy of air" is a great read. The angle that would be most interesting to the HN crowd is that it exposed me to how much innovation was happening in chemistry in this pre-WWI era. Reminds me a bit of silicon valley. The also a fascinating look at how the inventors got heavily caught up in WWI and WWII due to being in Germany and how tied up their industry became with government. Interesting to reflect on in current times. Truly a great book.
- lancewiggs 2y agohttps://www.liquium.nz/ https://www.liquium.nz/ is working on reducing the energy (a lot) required for the Haber-Bosch process.
- dizzant 2y agoThe comments here are focused on how much energy it would take to turn this into fuel. The real story here is decentralized fertilizer production, buried at the end of the article: > this innovation could fundamentally reshape fertilizer manufacturing by providing a more sustainable, cost-effective alternative to centralized production The high energy cost of Haber-Bosch, plus the additional cost of transportation from manufacturer to farmer could potentially be eliminated by distributed, passive fertilizer generators scattered around in the fields. I'm no expert, but assuming sufficient local production, low concentration could potentially be overcome by continuous fertilization with irrigation throughout the growing season. Let's find out. Some quick fiddling with a molarity calculator and an almanac: -- 100 uM ammonia -> 1.7 mg / L ammonia -- 82% nitrogen -> 1.4 mg / L nitrogen -- My lawn needs around 1 lb / 1000 sq ft, or around 5 g / m2 -- So my lawn needs about 3500 L / m2 of fertilized irrigation total for the season -- Ballpark farming irrigation is around 0.2 inches per day, or around 5L/m2 I would need to water my lawn about 700 days in the year, or more realistically up my irrigation rate by about a factor of 4, AND source all of the water from the fertilizer box. I'm a little skeptical that I can allocate space for enough production and still have a lawn left to fertilize. The tech probably isn't ready for the big time on an industrial farm yet, but for research demo, this seems like a promising direction! Much more than concentrating it for fuel.
- darth_avocado 2y agoUntil big fertilizer lobbies to make decentralized fertilizer illegal. Insert national security, wrong hands blah blah
- cogman10 2y agoNGL, it would be an easy sell. You are just a hop/skip and a quack away from turning that decentralized fertilizer into a decentralized bomb making system.
- dizzant 2y agoA hop, skip, quack, jump, and fairly obvious high-energy distillation process away. The national security angle probably isn't a concern here for the same reason that this process doesn't produce good fuel.
- aaroninsf 2y agoRelated: my personal wistful thinking is, AI -> safe deployable fusion -> power for desalination and exactly this sort of thing. In particular I daydream about use of "free" power to perform carbon sequestration back into liquid hydrocarbon fuels for existing ICE etc. infrastructure...voila, no delay to retool civilization while getting down to the business of bringing carbon back under 400 ppm.
- worik 2y ago> Related: my personal wistful thinking is, > AI -> safe deployable fusion This reminds me of the recent HN referred article on Cargo Cults
- rotexo 2y agoI interpreted that causality as AI leading to deployment of carbon-neutral energy, then when the AI bubble bursts, we’ve pushed carbon-neutral electricity sources off the learning curve cliff and it is available for cheap without the original consumers needing it. From that perspective, it could be any carbon neutral electricity (fusion, fission, enhanced geothermal, super-deep geothermal etc.). I could be misinterpreting the parent comment.
- alexchamberlain 2y agoThe was an article here a while back about the production of propane from water and CO2 (via a catalyst and electricity). I think "renewable fossil fuels" are the only way we can handle the fluctuating production of renewable energy and get the density of fuel we need for storage, especially mobile storage like fuel for cars & lorries.
- cyberax 2y ago> The process can be powered simply by ambient wind to pass the water vapor through the mesh. That's not how chemistry works. You need to input external energy to produce ammonia out of water and nitrogen. It's the law of energy conservation. In this case, the ultimate energy source appears to be the wind. It tears off microdroplets of water from larger water bodies, so the energy is stored in the surface tension of microdroplets.
- Suppafly 2y ago>> The process can be powered simply by ambient wind >the ultimate energy source appears to be the wind Seems like you are agreeing that, that is how chemistry works.
- darksaints 2y agoAre these really catalysts in the traditional definition of the word? Meaning that the catalyst is non-sacrificial? This appears to be suggesting that nitration can be done with atomospheric N2 simply with the right catalyst. But N2 is triple bonded, and the lowest theoretical threshold to react N2 with anything is by breaking at least one of those bonds, which is incredibly energy intensive even under theoretically optimal conditions. Some of the most promising research in replacing Haber-Bosch is actually plasma-assisted nitration, which is basically just as energy intensive as Haber-Bosch, but with drastically lower capital requirements...something that could be done in your backyard. I struggle to see how an ATP catalyst-only method could even do anything close to breaking an N2 triple bond.
- littlestymaar 2y agoIdk but soil micro-organisms do break N2 to make ammonia so there sure exists a pathway that just implies catalysis at low temperature.
- hnmullany 2y agoSoil nitrate fixation is also energy intensive. The nitrogenase enzyme takes about 27 ATPs to break a single N2 bond. Legumes feed about a third of their entire photosynthesis output to their nitrogen fixing nodules in order to generate significant amounts of nitrates. There is no free lunch.
- btbuildem 2y agoI wonder what are the side effects of extracting nitrogen out of air -- supposing this was developed and deployed at scale.
- pjc50 2y agoIt's 80% of the atmosphere. You're not going to run out. What might be a risk is dumping it, nitrogenation of rivers is already a problem in places.
- atrus 2y agoI doubt much. We've been pumping billions of tons of co2 and only slightly raised co2 and that's a small small portion of the air in the atmosphere.
- amock 2y agoWe already make ammonia from the nitrogen in the air.
- hnmullany 2y agoHere is an overview I wrote of next generation methods for ammonia synthesis: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/climatetech-134-de-carbonizing-fertilizer-michael-mullany-ghuge/?trackingId=KbIwLlGrS1SKd2rui4t9cA%3D%3D https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/climatetech-134-de-carbonizin... (FWIW - there are many many promising lab results that turn out to be false positives because the researchers did a bad job of controlling potential contamination in their ammonia measurements. Low concentrations of ammonia are everywhere, and you have to do a really good job making sure you're not measuring background levels vs. what you think you're producing)
- casey2 2y agoAm I being trolled? Scale it up a trillion times and you still have nothing, not even compared to the current hourly production.
- ternnoburn 2y agoDo you think the first lab produced ammonia was also made at current hourly production rates? Alternatively, you are looking at a scale model and asking, "what is this, a school for ants?!" Maybe we should learn to do things in a new way then spend a few decades rolling them out?
- NotAnOtter 2y agoAmmonia is 1 Nitrogen bonded with 3 hydrogen. The raw stuff is definitely there. Thought I'm sure there are easier ways of making it.
- maxrmk 2y agoI'm vaguely amused by the headline of "requires no external power" right above the image of it sitting on top of (and plugged in to) a giant portable battery.
- cluckindan 2y agoIf this is indeed possible, then it must also be possible to create simple hydrocarbons (CO2 + H2O => CxHx + O2) using a similar process.
- ternnoburn 2y agoYes? There's already a cottage industry trying to do exactly that? The problem is getting enough co2, as it's not particularly concentrated in our atmosphere. So the main ways they go about it are big fans, which is tons of energy, capturing at the source (in smokestacks, etc) which requires complex transport and management, or growing plants and pyrolysing the biomass. The fundamental theory behind it is quite simple, it's really more of a logistics problem.
- pkphilip 2y agoThis is huge! The ability to create ammonia from scratch - provided it can be done in a way which is also safe in terms of storage of the generated ammonia, can be game changer as it can be used as a carrier for hydrogen for Hydrogen-powered vehicles, generators etc.
- guy234 2y agothis observation is present in the 3rd paragraph of TFA