4 ms·
Sure, I'll defend them, conceptually at least. I think most actors in this system are in some sense corrupt, and I don't think insurers are the most corrupt. Pu
by tptacek 2y ago
Sure, I'll defend them, conceptually at least. I think most actors in this system are in some sense corrupt, and I don't think insurers are the most corrupt. Pull up the 2022 National Health Expenditure table, "National Health Expenditures by Type of Expenditure and Program: Calendar Year 2022" and look at combined hospital and physician expenses compared to insurer expenses; it's pretty black-and-white.
- verisimi 2y ago> I don't think insurers are the most corrupt Lol, nice defence
- gedpeck 2y agoOne should not profit from denying care. All health systems ration care. Doing so in a way that people profit from denying care is immoral.
- jampekka 2y agoAnd inefficient to boot!
- tptacek 2y agoIf you believe that, you should have a bigger problem with what providers bill, because that's the ultimate origin of the constraints.
- gedpeck 2y agoI take it then that we agree that for profit health insurance companies profiting from denying care is immoral. That there are other immoral actors is not germane to the discussion.
- tptacek 2y agoNo, we don't agree. I think there are different values implicated in our system, in a system like the UK NHS, and a system like Australia's (for the record: I'd take Australia's over ours). The UK does a good job of hiding economic concerns from its users, at a cost in availability of services, especially high-end and experimental interventions. The UK makes these rationing decisions knowing that some people are going to be denied life-saving care, but in exchange for that everybody else in the system will get predictable access to their care. The American system does a good job of getting services delivered to customers; it does a better job of that than the NHS does, if you measure in interventions performed; it does such a better job at that that it's a real problem in our system: we overprescribe and overdeliver interventions that drive costs and decrease certainty as payers work out which things to cover and which not. The flip side of that is that everyone in that system can tell themselves that the system is doing what it can to gate delivery on whether care is truly needed and will be effective, and that it's not categorically denying care because of top-down mandates. Neither set of values is totally benign. You can prefer one or the other. I can go all 12 rounds on this topic, but if I keep writing about this I'm not going to write the work thing I'm supposed to write, so I'll leave it there.
- gedpeck 2y agoThen your reply above to me was a red herring and as such a bad faith reply. The American system does a good job of getting services delivered to customers; Therein lies one of the reasons the U.S. system is immoral. There are lots of people who can’t afford to be customers. It is immoral to profit from denying someone healthcare.
- bugglebeetle 2y agoYour argument would be more convincing (well, not really because it’s typical bad faith contrarianism) if insurers weren’t also some of the largest hospital and clinic owners in the U.S. and use this to rob people blind on both ends.
- tptacek 2y agoWhich hospital chains are you referring to?
- ceejayoz 2y agoUHC is the largest single employer of doctors in the US. https://www.statnews.com/2024/07/25/united-health-group-medicare-advantage-strategy-doctor-clinic-acquisitions/ https://www.statnews.com/2024/07/25/united-health-group-medi... > It’s no secret that UnitedHealth is a colossus: It’s the country’s largest health insurer and the fourth-largest company of any type by revenue, just behind Apple. And thanks to a series of stealthy deals, almost 1 in 10 U.S. doctors — some 90,000 clinicians — now either work for UnitedHealth or are under its influence, more than any major clinic chain or hospital system. They purchase physician groups... and then pay themselves higher rates. https://www.statnews.com/2024/11/25/unitedhealth-higher-payments-optum-providers-converts-expenses-to-profits/ https://www.statnews.com/2024/11/25/unitedhealth-higher-paym... > UnitedHealth Group is paying many of its own physician practices significantly more than it pays other doctor groups in the same markets for similar services, undermining competition and driving up costs for consumers and businesses, a STAT investigation reveals.
- loeg 2y agoIt follows that providers should provide care for free. Anything else is profiting from denying care. I guess you're just a full communist? If that's the case, just come out and say it so we can agree to disagree and move on.
- gedpeck 2y agoThere are other options. Think about it a bit. Nonprofit insurance companies for one. National healthcare is another option that does not require communism. Don’t be a lazy thinker.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> look at combined hospital and physician expenses compared to insurer expenses; it's pretty black-and-white I mean, yeah. They're doing all the work.
- tptacek 2y agoAnd billing us 4x more for it than Europeans, and, further: a lot of that work is wasteful and unnecessary (see: spinal fusion surgeries, back imaging). There were more MRI machines in Massachusetts in 2023 than there where in all of Canada.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> And billing us 4x more for it than Europeans In part, because dealing with insurers is immensely costly in staff and time. (Other parts include the immense cost of twelve years of secondary education here; a million bucks in student loans isn't uncommon.) > a lot of that work is wasteful and unnecessary (see: spinal fusion surgeries, back imaging) Which makes the "insurers are there to reduce waste!" argument especially tough to stomach.
- tptacek 2y agoDoctors don't make 4x more here than in Germany because of insurance costs.
- ceejayoz 2y agoHealthcare here isn't 4x the price because of doctor costs, either. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2023/08/04/doctor-pay-shortage/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2023/08/04/doctor-pa... / https://archive.is/ZBRMx https://archive.is/ZBRMx > Polyakova and her collaborators find doctor pay consumes only 8.6 percent of overall health spending. It grew a bit faster than inflation over the time period studied, but much slower than overall health-care costs. > “People have a narrative that physician earnings is one of the main drivers of high health-care costs in the U.S.,” Polyakova told us. “It is kind of hard to support this narrative if ultimately physicians earn less than 10 percent of national health-care expenditures.”
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]