2 ms·
This is very one sides - not necessarily wrong, but in general simple solutions to complex problems are wrong and this pushing of biochar/coal is likely to be a
by bluGill 2y ago
This is very one sides - not necessarily wrong, but in general simple solutions to complex problems are wrong and this pushing of biochar/coal is likely to be another one. Maybe part of the solution but not enough alone.
- franktankbank 2y agoWhat's the complaint? This is one ingredient that can be added all on its own (apparently) and have good results.
- bluGill 2y agoThere are plenty of universities around the world doing real science on soil. I don't see any of them quoted.
- franktankbank 2y agoHuh, I don't know, it seems like common enough knowledge. Why need to exhaust all possible options to get to MAX GAINS (sometime in the future but not today) when they are proposing something that seems to work now and is better than whats possible today? Seems like you end up bikeshedding a simple idea to death.
- magicalist 2y agoThere are literally citations throughout the article? It's still unclear what the complaint is. It just seems to be a short intro into biochar.
- bluGill 2y agoThe citations were only to biochar working (at least what I could see) and not a comparison of biochar to other options. Why would/should some (read a farmer) spend some money on biochar if something else works as well or better?
- Empact 2y agoAt scale, we can restore the soil the same way it was built up in the first place, through rotational grazing of ruminants. I keep chickens to that effect and am planning on sheep. Very low-effort, highly productive animals, each, even apart from their soil building.
- bluGill 2y agoThat is one option. Research is needed to see if other options work.
- titzer 2y agoIndeed, I think a lot of people undervalue or are unaware of how important the soil microbiome is. That can't be restored at scale and requires the active participation of the other parts of the ecosystem, particularly the digestive tracts of animals. It's a complex interplay. If you've ever seen cowpies sprouting grass out in some arid, quasi-desert environment, it's because their droppings contain grass seeds, insect eggs, worms, bacteria, fungal spores, and raw nutrients. Droppings are like ecosystem spores; they can help the originating ecosystem bootstrap itself in a new area, complete with hundreds if not thousands of species of microbiota, plants, insects, etc. Life is a team sport.
- franktankbank 2y agoAlso lets not forget dude! Buffalo create wallows which adds such an amazing diversity to the landscape: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_wallow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_wallow . Get this! Wallows are estimated at 5/acre across the prairie (obviously before buffalo disappeared and land plowed under). Let's bring back the Buffalo!
- franktankbank 2y agoDon't forget fire every few years. Natural biochar (at small scale).