3 ms·
Statistically, denials of medical care are highly likely to have killed more Americans than the ~2k Americans killed in Iraq by enemy fire over a ~20 year perio
by ceejayoz 2y ago
Statistically, denials of medical care are highly likely to have killed more Americans than the ~2k Americans killed in Iraq by enemy fire over a ~20 year period.
- tptacek 2y agoBy that logic every health care system in the entire world has has killed countless people. Further, under the zero-sum logic you offer here, every doctor that has ever overbilled RVUs is an accomplice to murder.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> By that logic every health care system in the entire world has has killed countless people. Probably, but motive matters in “killed” versus “murder”. I’m much more inclined to be mad about profit-driven medical decisions of this nature.
- tptacek 2y agoIf motive matters, none of these people have killed anybody.
- ceejayoz 2y agoI’m… not sure we agree on that.
- tptacek 2y agoThis doesn't seem like so much a difference of opinion as of fact; when an insurer denies someone coverage, they aren't motivated to kill that person, nor is that their intent. Like health insurance administrators in every system in the world, they're required to make decisions about who gets what, and that implies that some people won't get what they want. In fact, by the logic you're using, administrators in the NHS are far more culpable than US insurers, since they issue categorical denials they know with certainty are going to result in preventable deaths; an insurer can at least tell themselves they're conditioning coverage situationally and based on effectiveness. Would you like some specific examples? I think this "health care" "murder" thing is just a really bad analogy and people should stop using it.
- ceejayoz 2y agoA hit man is motivated by profit. Not personal dislike of the person, but it’s still a murder. I have a hard time seeing “we can boost profits by fighting claims until sick people give up” as all that dissimilar. The NHS admins aren’t getting bonuses for boosting share prices.
- tptacek 2y agoA hitman is motivated to murder and has that intent. Insurers are motivated to eliminate waste, which is absolutely rife in the US health care industry; insurers are getting continually worked over by hospital chains, which take in something like 9 times as much money as insurers and have 3-5x their profit margins. I don't think the analogy is salvageable. Even if the point I just made wasn't true (it is), you'd have run aground on the distinction between wanting and intending to kill someone and not. But the flaws run much deeper than that. Respectfully, you should stop saying this.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> Insurers are motivated to eliminate waste… This is Patrick Stewart levels of bald assertion. Call it “negligent homicide” if you prefer.
- tptacek 2y agoYou can't have Googled this even once and concluded there is no waste in our system. I don't particularly like health insurers, but if you're trying to bait me into a fulsome defense, I'm prepared to offer it. It's not homicide at all, and it's deeply irresponsible to suggest otherwise. You should stop. What's obviously happening here is that the behavior advocated by the person who made these cards, and of many people online reacting to the murder of the UHC executive, is obviously and categorically indefensible, and people are going through contortions trying to avoid a reckoning with that.
- ceejayoz 2y ago