3 ms·
> the reality is the market segments, new expensive housing only releases limited amounts of cheap housing, and does not significantly affect low cost housing a
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> the reality is the market segments, new expensive housing only releases limited amounts of cheap housing, and does not significantly affect low cost housing availability
Yes on the former, no on the latter.
The differential effects of new luxury versus affordable housing on pricing in our most-expensive real estate markets is pretty much entirely a hypothetical given we haven't built enough of either to have a massive effect. What we can say is the effect of both is marginal and systemic. (Where affordable housing plays a unique role is in inhibiting gentrification through the creation of high-amenity neighbourhoods.)
In terms of the effect on affordable housing, you have to dig to find cases where the gentrification effect is positive, i.e. where more luxury housing didn't moderate or lower lower tier rents.
That all said, a YIMBY who argues against public housing is a hypocrite. We need more housing. How it comes up is less relevant than that it does. The parsimonious solution is to remove the restrictions that inhibit both public and private housing creation. Barring that, either is better than neither. (And yes, that includes only new luxury housing.)