2 ms·
> the YIMBYs who said any new housing development was good were wrong The article says nothing about price. Based on precedent, we can expect this glut of luxu
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> the YIMBYs who said any new housing development was good were wrong
The article says nothing about price. Based on precedent, we can expect this glut of luxury housing to reduce housing prices and rents in the affected markets.
Precedent: "Zillow data from 2013 to 2018" shows "new buildings lower nearby rents in low-income neighborhoods" [1]. In New York, "new high-rise construction (greater than seven stories caused nearby high-end and mid-range rental building rents to decrease" and no "significant rental decreases for housing at the low-end of the mark." The only place luxury housing had a gentrification effect, i.e. where more luxury housing increased community amenities, thereby causing "lower tier housing" to see "a 6.6% rise in rental pricing compared to comparison" was Minneapolis, and that's due to "a limited number of low market tier buildings in th[e] distance band."
Anecdotally, I years ago used the opening of luxury buildings in my Manhattan neighbourhood to negotiate a lower rent. The builidngs, which opened around the same time, competed heavily on discounted amenities. My building was 25% unoccupied; I showed my landlord the math for why, after accounting for gym and laundry costs, the luxury building was cheaper than our pre-War given the rent I was paying. He agreed and lowered it. (If he hadn't, I'd have moved and saved money.)
[1] https://www.pdx.edu/realestate/sites/realestate.web.wdt.pdx.edu/files/2022-11/01_NateGrein_2Q22.pdf https://www.pdx.edu/realestate/sites/realestate.web.wdt.pdx....
- miguelazo 2y ago“Anecdotally,” middle class has fled/been pushed out of NYC because of the development you are praising. There was an entire Harper’s magazine cover story about how the city is “over.” Most of it taken over by rich, entitled, boring people. Especially Manhattan. Edit:+ https://harpers.org/archive/2018/07/the-death-of-new-york-city-gentrification/ https://harpers.org/archive/2018/07/the-death-of-new-york-ci...