5 ms·
I'm not sure what your point is. The argument isn't that corn syrup isn't being subsidized, it's that on a absolute basis the subsidy doesn't matter. If there's
by gruez 2y ago
I'm not sure what your point is. The argument isn't that corn syrup isn't being subsidized, it's that on a absolute basis the subsidy doesn't matter. If there's only 10 cents worth of sugar in a 2L bottle of coke, switching to sugar is unlikely to change the consumers buying habits.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThe point is it makes sense, at scale, with the existing systems in place around subsidies (corn) and price protections (sugar). > switching to sugar is unlikely to change the consumers buying habits. If this is the case, why has it not happened yet? The argument "the cost delta is not material enough to matter" comparing corn syrup to sugar, but the evidence based on participant actions leads us to conclude that is not the case. Edit: @gruez: I agree with regards to consumer demand for the foods in question, I was refuting the point "It's not like sugar is expensive. No more than a few cents worth in a 2L bottle of soda."
- gruez 2y ago>The point is it makes sense, at scale, with the existing systems in place around subsidies and price protections. I'm not refuting that, I'm only saying that in the context of public health, cheaper corn syrup being subsidized doesn't make a difference when it comes to consumer behavior. That doesn't mean that producers are going to be dumb and buy sugar when corn syrup is so much cheaper. Consumers aren't going to stop drinking coke because it costs 1% more, but the beancounters at coca cola are certainly going to care if they're spending 50% (made up number) more on sweeteners if they don't have to.
- daedrdev 2y agoThe delta does not matter to the consumer. They might pay <5% more, hardly a dent in demand would follow. The producer has a small profit margin so it does matter for them, since production and logistics cost a lot.
- smnrchrds 2y ago> If there's only 10 cents worth of sugar in a 2L bottle of coke, switching to sugar is unlikely to change the consumers buying habits. It matters enough that it determines where things get manufactured though. > There are two prices for sugar: the price you pay in the U.S., and the price you pay almost everywhere else in the world. > The price in the U.S. is about 15 cents a pound higher than the price in the rest of the world. That costs Spangler Candy an additional $3 million a year. > The higher U.S. sugar price is spelled out in U.S. law. You can find it right here, in the latest version of the farm bill, which says the U.S. government shall guarantee a minimum price for sugar that is not to drop below 22.9 cents per pound. > Because of the higher price here, lots of candies that used to be made in the U.S. — Life Savers, candy canes — are now made overseas. https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/04/26/179087542/the-lollipop-war https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/04/26/179087542/the-...
- arcticbull 2y ago> Because of the higher price here, lots of candies that used to be made in the U.S. — Life Savers, candy canes — are now made overseas. While true, if this was something we really cared about, it's easily solved with tariffs. This is an actual job for tariffs.
- jdietrich 2y agoCounterargument: the UK's Soft Drinks Industry Levy. In 2018, the British government introduced a tax on soft drinks with a sugar content of more than 50g per litre. The tax isn't particularly onerous, at 18p or 24p (22¢ or 29¢) per litre depending on the sugar content. The industry response was immediate - the majority of drinks were reformulated to reduce their sugar content to below the threshold, which is precisely what the government intended. Although initially controversial, the levy is now regarded as a clear victory for public health, with no significant economic impact on industry. Even if the purchasing habits of consumers are price-inelastic, the decisions of manufacturers most certainly aren't. https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/explainer/sugar-tax https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/explainer/sugar-ta...
- classichasclass 2y agoIt's certainly made me buy less UK Dr Pepper in Australia (I find artificial sweeteners generally unpleasant). Many places down under that sell it are now stocking US Dr Pepper instead, which suggests it sells rather better.
- HPsquared 2y agoI avoid the reduced-sugar ones. Actually these days I tend to buy the little miniature 150ml Coca-Cola cans. Original recipe but only 15g sugar as there's just less of it. Portion size is just as important as concentration!
- leoedin 2y agoIt completely killed my soft drink buying habits. So it was either a success or failure depending on how you look at it. I can’t stand the reformulated sweetened drinks. The flavour profile and aftertaste is completely different. I wasn’t a huge consumer of soft drinks to start with, but now I consume absolutely zero.
- Urahandystar 2y agoThis is a win from a public health standpoint also.
- 2y ago
- WillPostForFood 2y agoOn the other hand, it's demonstrably proven that food producers will switch from sugar to corn syrup rather than pay extra for cane sugar, so consumers are deprived of a choice.
- tptacek 2y agoWhat good would that choice do them? You can choose to buy products made with sucrose, but ceteris paribus, the sucrose product won't be healthier. This is a little like asking whether consumers can choose to buy less-sweetened food, and, of course they can.