4 ms·
> MuZero plays Donut Go, a variant of Go where a hole has been punched out of the middle of the board, but has not been retrained. To be equivalent to a frozen
by ben_w 2y ago
> MuZero plays Donut Go, a variant of Go where a hole has been punched out of the middle of the board, but has not been retrained.
To be equivalent to a frozen/no retraining allowed AI, the human would need to have their brain chemistry prevented from altering synaptic weights.
The option to freeze weights in AI models is the only way they can be safely productised. Or training runs fairly compared — didn't Kasparov allege that IBM cheated by changing the algorithm during the game?
When it comes to "what even is this 'intelligence' thing?" there's definitely an argument about how much advantage these models take from the fact that silicon is around a million times faster than synaptic chemistry; but in practical terms, when it comes to "are we nearly obsolete?", it's the wall-clock time not the subjective time that matters — and AlphaZero took only 8 hours to beat its predecessor AlphaGo Zero, which itself beat AlphaGo Master, which in turn won 60:0 against professional players. So, how long would it take a human to get good at the new rules, and would it improve faster or slower than the wall-clock time of an AI learning the new constraints?
> I am not sure if they've done a Donut Go experiment, but DeepMind did show that the same algorithm trained on Breakout could solve Level 1 with superhuman skill yet completely fail level 2. I am fairly confident my thought experiment holds water, but it would be interest to run it IRL. There is an issue in that I'm not sure how you would get MuZero to "see" the hole... if it has a deterministic check for move legality then perhaps that could be updated.
Should be easy, given that MuZero did go, chess, shogi, and a standard suite of Atari games…
But yeah, 2019 is an eternity in AI, should be easy to do what you suggest today.