4 ms·
> How does he know that the scale of the problem is what he thinks it is and not what “woke” people think it is? Broadly speaking, there is no limit to racism
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> How does he know that the scale of the problem is what he thinks it is and not what “woke” people think it is?
Broadly speaking, there is no limit to racism that has ever been proposed by the far left. One can reasonably, trivially dismiss most infinities.
> The essay can be summed up in one sentence: There should be no meaningful consequences for men who engage is lewd behavior
There is something deeper here you’re missing. Women can generally define lewd behaviour however they want; there is no similar official mechanism in the balance. A one-way institution like that will predictably build righteous backlash against itself. That backlash is partly performative and partly justified.
- scarface_74 2y agoI have absolutely no need to get anywhere near the line of what anyone would think of being lewd.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> have absolutely no need to get anywhere near the line of what anyone would think of being lewd How is that relevant? The point is if one party can inconsequentially, to them, subjectively define lewdness and cause consequence to others through it, you will wind up with abuse and backlash. Whether it’s lewdness or moral uprightness or loyalty to a flag is besides the point.
- gedpeck 2y ago[flagged]
- scarface_74 2y agoWhen Apple announced cycle tracking for the Apple Watch. You would be surprised how many people on HN thought that was a useless niche feature when it literally is something that affects every woman of child bearing age
- scarface_74 2y agoAre you really not capable of knowing what could be considered “lewd” and not go into that territory in polite company?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Are you really not capable of knowing what could be considered “lewd” and not go into that territory in polite company? I’m pretty sure I both am and am aware enough of the line and its ambiguity to weaponise it against someone else if I wanted to. Add to that cultural variance in where the line lies and you effectively wind up censoring cross-gender discussion of gender-relevant topics. I don’t think Graham is advocating for lewd jokes in the workplace, or suggesting the womens’ rights movements of the 60s were misplaced. He’s arguing against universally institutionalising rules of politeness, and being particularly wary of doing it one way. > in polite company Graham is arguing against the expansion of polite company to virtually the entire discussion space. In that, I kind of agree.
- scarface_74 2y ago> I’m pretty sure I both am and am aware enough of the line and its ambiguity to weaponise it against someone else if I wanted to. I have been in customer facing roles since mid 2020 as a consultant. There really is no ambiguity. I don’t talk about anything that can hint at going in a sexual direction, or politics or religion. I just don’t get involved with those types of conversation at work. Occasionally, I do have to talk about politics as it affects business especially since I spent a lot of time working in the Education/State and Local Government space. > He’s arguing against universally institutionalising rules of politeness, and being particularly wary of doing it one way. There has always been institutionalization of what one should and shouldn’t talk about in “polite company”. Those norms have changed through the years and rightfully so. Did your parents grow up in the Jim crow south? > Graham is arguing against the expansion of polite company to virtually the entire discussion space. In that, I kind of agree. How is that any different than it has always been? I talk differently when I’m with my friends and family in private than I do when I’m in public spaces. Society would look at me like I was crazy if I did the same amount of “cussing, drinking and telling lies” loudly like I do when I’m at home with my friends playing cards if I did it in public. We all “code switch” to an extent.
- renewiltord 2y agoAnd yet, here you are, making the lewdest of remarks. You're making me uncomfortable and need to stop making hurtful accusations that could be damaging to people. We're trying to have a polite discussion here.
- dang 2y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into flamewar hell. You can disagree without this. There was nothing lewd in what scarface_74 posted.
- svieira 2y agoCorrect, but if the point is "what is lewd can change out from under you without any consent on your part" ad contra scarface and in support of the OP, then this is a reasonable response (though I agree it would have been better to put it in quotes and then point out the issue in several follow-on paragraphs to better fit with the site. This isn't Reddit).
- scarface_74 2y agoSo give an example of what is now considered lewd that changed out from under you?
- shadowgovt 2y agoIf anything, they provided an example of how the counter-argument is disingenuous: one person's opinion of what is and is not lewd did not dictate the community opinion on the topic in this context. Many of these complaints about arbitrary rules changing, to my observation, come from people who were simply unaware of a decades-long conversation happening in spaces they don't care to be invested in: sociological studies, gender studies, cultural studies, human behavior studies, etc. And when those conversations reach a well-reasoned consensus with convincing arguments that sway the hearts and minds of people with control over interaction spaces, it can be a little startling when rules change! But being upset about it is a little bit like being upset that the web APIs changed due to the publications of WHATWG while consistently ignoring the well-publicized discussions and work of WHATWG. Graham in this essay seems to be laboring under the belief that because these norms didn't originate from the STEM education space, the STEM industry space doesn't need to adopt them or take them seriously... As if they weren't originating from the space of professional consideration of sociology and human behavior.
- gedpeck 2y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> obviously there is a limit Whether there is or isn’t is irrelevant. The fact that when asked “how much,” the answer seems to have no defined limit is what I’m criticising.
- gedpeck 2y agoI’m not the one who quantified things. Graham did. I take it then you agree with me that Graham’s statement was written without merit or justification. EDIT: Graham wrote, “Not a problem on the scale that the woke believe it to be, but a genuine one.” He stated a limit on the level of racism. He gave a bound on it. He said it is less that what woke people think it is. CrissCross is being deliberately obtuse. This edit is for people who come across this thread. My comment pointed out that Graham didn’t justify this belief. I don’t know the level of racism and I’m not arrogant enough to try.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> I’m not the one who quantified things. Graham did He quite literally didn’t. There are almost no numbers in the entire essay. The argument you object to is qualitative. > take it then you agree with me that Graham’s statement was written without merit or justification No. The exact limit is both irrelevant and not definable. Your comment demanded a “scale to the problem.” EDIT: > EDIT: Graham wrote, “Not a problem on the scale that the woke believe it to be, but a genuine one.” He stated a limit on the level of racism. He gave a bound on it. He said it is less that what woke people think it is One, still not quantitative. Two, nobody is debating whether there is a limit. (I said “there is no limit to racism that has ever been proposed by the far left,” and you said “obviously there is a limit.” These statements can coëxist.) The question is whether Americans’ subjective sense of our own racism is accurate. And I’m saying that someone who claims there is more racism than the average person thinks and then fails to define it (the burden being on them, after all, for rejecting the status quo), that said person is probably overestimating it. Not necessarily. And there are plenty of activists and academics who are quite precise about defining and measuring racism. But those folks aren’t usually the ones running around online calling others racist.