4 ms·
So it's legal for cops to seize your residence, confiscate your postal mail, open it, and write replies impersonating you to whomever they want? How is this an
by stephengillie 14y ago
So it's legal for cops to seize your residence, confiscate your postal mail, open it, and write replies impersonating you to whomever they want?
How is this any different? Because there's an electronic device involved?
- sophacles 14y agoEven more similarly, what is the law on answering machines? Can someone leaving a message on an answering machine be subjected to a similar interception and impersonation without a warrant? What about emails? Can emails be faked without a warrant?
- rprasad 14y ago1) Not quite. A person leaving a message on a suspect's answering machine can be called back without a warrant for them (as the original warrant/search would still be valid on the original suspect). But a separate warrant would be required to intercept (EDIT: removed impersonate) that caller. EDIT: They can impersonate a person without a warrant. 2) Yes. Emails cannot be searched without a warrant, but police can fake emails without a warrant. However, if they attempt to entrap another person by faking emails, they run into the classic entrapment defense. Furthermore, if they cause harm to a person's reputation, etc., through the impersonation, they are usually liable for crazy damages.
- grecy 14y ago> However, if they attempt to entrap another person by faking emails, they run into the classic entrapment defense. So they can do it with a cell phone (in the article), but not an email?
- rprasad 14y agoNo, they run into the entrapment issue either way. But it's easier to show entrapment with email because the fake emails are recorded. With a phone call, it is not necessarily a given that the call was recorded (as the police may not have had proper gear set up), so it usually becomes a he-said-cop-said problem. Cops usually choose not to record calls unless they need to, because for evidentiary reasons (for the prosecution) it is better to make the dispute one of credibility.
- grecy 14y agoIn the article it's made very clear they entrapped multiple people by faking text messages, that didn't seem to be a problem.
- rprasad 14y agoJournalists do not understand the law very well... In this case, the police hit up a bunch of people they suspected of being the dealer's customers and asked them if they wanted to buy more drugs. The callees who were arrested agreed to buy more drugs without persuasion. That's not entrapment. Left out of the article, because they were not relevant to the opinion, is those people the police texted who chose not to buy drugs from the dealer being impersonated.
- grecy 14y ago> The callees who were arrested agreed to buy more drugs without persuasion. That's not entrapment. It seems I'm confused about what constitutes entrapment. If an officer walks up to me on the street and offers to sell me drugs, is that entrapment? (I see that as exactly the same as sending a text message, or email)
- aidenn0 14y agoEntrapment is a hard defense though. The burden shifts to the defendant to show that he/she was not willing to commit the crime. For example: Cop: Hey, want to buy drugs? Defendant: Sure!" Not entrapment. Contrariwise: Cop: Hey want to buy drugs? Defendant: No way! Cop: Come on, you could make lots of money reselling it Defendant: It's not worth it man Cop: I know it's risky, but you could send your son to college! Defendant: I guess... okay Maybe entrapment
- Cushman 14y agoI think people have a much closer connection to electronic devices. We arbitrarily say that police can't force me to say something, so where do we draw the line? Can they fake my voice in a recording? Can they use a clone? As brain-computer interfaces become more feasible, this will be a less theoretical concern. There's an interesting overlap with encryption laws, also. If the authorities can force me to decrypt encrypted material, can they also force me to cryptographically sign material? What if unlocking my device implicitly signs my communications?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 14y agoIf the cops have a warrant for your postal mail, then yes they can do that, even if they have no warrant involving those you are communicating with.
- ken 14y agoI don't know the answer to the first question you ask, but state law seems to indicate that yes, electronic devices -- at least when used for illegal drug sales -- are special: RCW 9.73.200: "conversations regarding illegal drug operations should be intercepted, transmitted, and recorded in certain circumstances without prior judicial approval in order to protect the life and safety of law enforcement personnel and to enhance prosecution of drug offenses, and that that interception and transmission can be done without violating the constitutional guarantees of privacy". [1]: http://apps.leg.wa.gov/rcw/default.aspx?cite=9.73.200 http://apps.leg.wa.gov/rcw/default.aspx?cite=9.73.200
- ams6110 14y agoI think the article addressed this, the claim being that there is no "long established expectation of privacy" in text messages, unlike postal mail and voice telephone calls. Thus warrant required to search/wiretap the latter, not the former.