5 ms·
If by "called out" you imply criticised, then that is not correct. Instead, the NTSB final accident report (https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/accidentreports
by nctk21 2y ago
If by "called out" you imply criticised, then that is not correct.
Instead, the NTSB final accident report (https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/accidentreports/reports/aar1003.pdf https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/accidentreports/reports/..., p. section 2.3.1) praises the specific quick action:
"Although the flight crew was only able to complete about one-third of the Engine Dual
Failure checklist, immediately after the bird strike, the captain did accomplish one critical item
that the flight crew did not reach in the checklist: starting the APU. Starting the APU early in the
accident sequence proved to be critical because it improved the outcome of the ditching by
ensuring that electrical power was available to the airplane. Further, if the captain had not started
the APU, the airplane would not have remained in normal law mode. This critical step would not
have been completed if the flight crew had simply followed the order of the items in the
checklist.
The NTSB concludes that, despite being unable to complete the Engine Dual Failure
checklist, the captain started the APU, which improved the outcome of the ditching by ensuring
that a primary source of electrical power was available to the airplane and that the airplane
remained in normal law and maintained the flight envelope protections, one of which protects
against a stall."
The final report also gave a new safety recommendation (A-10-66, p. 124) to develop more appropriate (shorter) checklist for dual-engine failure specifically for low-altitude incidents.
- f1shy 2y agoSorry I wanted to mean “it was pointed out”. I’m not sure of the connotation of “call out” Thanks for citing the report, which I was too lazy to do. That is my point, as I was replying to “it is just one button” comment. If you do the procedures in the right order, it could be they didn’t have the time to start the APU