3 ms·
People don't have the time to become familiar enough with every subject to form well reasoned opinions. It's the same reason we don't build everything we own fo
by verdverm 2y ago
People don't have the time to become familiar enough with every subject to form well reasoned opinions. It's the same reason we don't build everything we own for ourselves. Specialization and deferring to experts has been a natural human behavior forever
While I don't disagree that people could be better prepared by our education system, they also have to want to be capable of thinking for themselves.
- ddxxdd 2y agoBy all means, feel free to fact check our textbooks, news broadcasts, and statements from official sources. But when I log on to social media to rant about how UFOs are time-traveling humans, I don't want a teal-colored, official-looking div element to alert the world that the online version of my personal expression is objectively wrong.
- verdverm 2y agoThe problem is that someone can say "they are eating the cats, they are eating the dogs" and that turns into hate and violence in the real world. They are not separate spaces, both the physical and the digital are part of the same world So where does the line get drawn? Many believe that American style free speech goes too far and enables the malicious freedom to manipulate Also, online platforms are currently anti-competitive, so when you don't agree with the provider, there are significant costs to choosing another. That's why efforts like ATProto & ActivityPub are important to the next generation of social media applications.
- proc0 2y agoWell, I do agree but to an even further extent. Not only can we not become familiar with all the information, but experts also cannot do this. There is way too much information, and it updates way too quickly. There are of course exceptions when the domain is specific and focused enough, but in general, even experts will make mistakes and cannot process so much information. For me it's about keeping an open mind, and being conscious of getting exposed to a variety of opinions and perspectives. The problem from both the general public and the experts tends to be lack of epistemic humility, i.e. getting too entrenched in your own beliefs and refusing to consider alternatives.