3 ms·
Notable due to it being written by Bloomberg's editorial board, acknowledging the failings of the program. > First, the lottery — by design — doesn’t reward to
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Notable due to it being written by Bloomberg's editorial board, acknowledging the failings of the program.
> First, the lottery — by design — doesn’t reward top talent. This deficiency, coupled with loose oversight, has made it vulnerable to gaming and doomed to mediocre results. A recent Bloomberg News investigation found that IT staffing firms routinely flood the pool with entries, often for more visas than they need, crowding out companies that play by the rules. These practices — which US officials have called fraudulent — prioritize a sector that tends to pay relatively low wages for routine IT work. (New rules to curb abuse don’t go far enough.) As a result, many of the world’s smartest engineers are shut out from the most lucrative, in-demand jobs, and shortages at the top end persist.
> Second, visa holders with middling skills are more likely to be substitutes for, rather than complements to, American workers. Replenishing the job market with extraordinary talent that can’t be filled domestically increases productivity, innovation and growth; saturating it with lower-paid workers will tend to drive down wages. Official data show that 85% of H-1B petitions are awarded to employers paying well below the median wage, as determined by occupation and location.
- antihero 2y agoMaybe there needs to be something between J1 and H1Bs?
- PaulHoule 2y agoProbably. I want to laugh at the idea that "startups" need H1Bs but I should cry. If someone is really a "key employee" of a startup they can't be subject to a game of chance. Google, IBM, Infosys and others who file thousands of them can easily play the numbers. I quit the ACM because I couldn't accept their policy of 100% advocacy of H1Bs and joined the IEEE Computer Society because it refused to take a position. (An anti policy could be easily misunderstood) I am not against immigration, in fact I've seen H1Bs put people in a terrible position -- I knew a brilliant data scientist who was being dicked around and I wanted to tell them "your skills are in demand and you can get a better job" but it wasn't true. This person would tell me about his struggles with immigration and realized my story that my ancestors left a failing agricultural economy in Quebec and the horrors of WWI in what was then Austria-Hungary and made a new home here would be cruel to recount to him.
- slt2021 2y agoElon musk was on H1B when he was working for a startup. I think it is valid to allow startups hire H1Bs. Mind you today it is extremely hard and a lot of early atage atartups dont even bother to hire h1b due to uncertainty if the lottery
- claudiug 2y agoElon musk was on H1B when he was working for a startup. -> and now we have space karen or adrian...
- PaulHoule 2y agoPerhaps I didn't explain that I'm not against having visas for people to work here (the individual that I'm talking about got in the position he did because he was educated here and already had some standing) but that putting them behind a lottery is something senseless and cruel that only a politician could think up. As for Musk (as much as I admire Falcon 9 and Starship) I think he's self-centered and unprincipled and that, observing the success of Donald Trump, he thinks that these traits can win him admiration. He's for immigration when it's good for him, otherwise he's indifferent or against it if he thinks its good politics.
- munk-a 2y agoLets not ignore O1 visas either. O1 visas are, in my opinion, what we should lean into instead of continuing with employer specific specialized worker visas - if you're accepted into the US you should be free to work for whomever you chose and the power to change jobs is requisite to ensuring a fair labor market.
- jltsiren 2y agoO-1 is like H-1B, but worse. It's also tied to a single employer, the application process requires more work, and transitioning to a green card is a bit harder. Which means an O-1 worker is even more dependent of their employer than an H-1B worker.
- fmajid 2y agoThe obvious counter is to make it not be a lottery but rather an auction, the highest-paying employers wins the slot. This would get rid of the bottom-feeding body-shops that rent out H1-Bs by the hour. It would also cut off non-tech businesses like restaurants employing specialized chefs. Perhaps do this in bands by industry (this info should already be collected as part of the Dept of Labor certification).
- aprilthird2021 2y agoIt will also cause a lot of things to be shut down. This Will work for the FAANGs of the world and for very very few of the industries where there is a genuine labor shortage and hiking the cost up on them makes it unproductive to stay in business
- drivingmenuts 2y agoThat will just give the FAANGs the opportunity to make more acquisitions and expand their power base, which is ultimately desorable from their standpoint.
- bradleyjg 2y agoHow many of those are getting through the lottery today, given the flood of it staffing agency applications?