5 ms·
These cars need an emergency stop button which brings the car to a halt as fast as could plausibly be safe and then opens the doors. This is standard equipment
by kragen 2y ago
These cars need an emergency stop button which brings the car to a halt as fast as could plausibly be safe and then opens the doors. This is standard equipment on all industrial machinery and used to be standard equipment on all trains as well; I got into a lot of trouble once for pulling the emergency stop cord on a train when I was young. The inconvenience and occasional danger of unwarranted emergency stops is almost certain to be outweighed by the lives saved in the rarer cases where the E-stop is necessary.
- mattlondon 2y agoPresumably opening the door would stop it? I would hope that would be something they thought about and do not lock the passengers in...
- LocalH 2y agoI wouldn't assume anything about a modern system
- oneeyedpigeon 2y agoHe said "I can't get out the car", which suggests otherwise.
- kragen 2y agoMaybe he was afraid to try because he thought that opening the door of a moving car would be dangerous? It is.
- technothrasher 2y ago> I got into a lot of trouble once for pulling the emergency stop cord on a train when I was young. You are the hero of every young child that has ever been on a train and wondered what would happen when they pulled that cord. I know that certainly was a dream of mine when I was four or so. I couldn't understand why my dad was so insistent I not try it.
- psychlops 2y agoYou could always tug the steering wheel. That's supposed to stop it.
- belter 2y ago"...Additionally, you may not sit in the driver’s seat, touch the steering wheel, pedals, or driving controls. Violating these rules will impact your account standing and may lead to permanent revocation of ride privileges..." https://support.google.com/waymo/answer/15486190 https://support.google.com/waymo/answer/15486190
- netsharc 2y ago"Well, I got in a wreck and had 3rd degree burns, but at least my account is in good standing!" (Yes I know it's a totally different scenario to the article's)
- kragen 2y agoYeah, safety regulators would also need to prosecute companies that discourage people from using the E-stop button with terms like those.
- madmulita 2y agoHow would a malfunctioning AI decide it's safe to stop?
- kragen 2y agoIt wouldn't decide whether it's safe to stop. A separate E-stop processor would have a preprogrammed stop routine that stops the vehicle as fast as it can stop safely, which is to say, without skidding and without making rear-end collisions inevitable if you're on the freeway.
- crazygringo 2y ago> and without making rear-end collisions inevitable if you're on the freeway. That means it has to decide whether it's safe to stop. Stopping safely is no less complicated than the self-driving software in general. Sure you can have backup driver software, but it's just going to be the same software.
- Zak 2y ago> but it's just going to be the same software It does not have to be the same software. Its task is much simpler, and many situations where the normal software has to look for an optimal resolution can be handled by activating the hazard lights, stopping the car, and telling the passengers that the emergency stop is complete.
- adapiz 2y agoPeople talk a bunch of stuff about malfunctioning, bugged software and so on. We can assume, the car was just trapped in some infinite loop so it'll never reach it's goal for some reason but also wasn't able to realize that and call the routine for that. Fine. It's not a dangerous situation for the passenger but it definitely something that makes you feel very uncomfortable which could lead to panic because you're trapped. The doors are locked and even if they weren't you cannot simply exit the car. That's okay. Trains don't allow this either to open the doors on a track section. You need a supervisor to do that. In case of an emergency you can still unlock the doors mechanically. So after pulling the emergency brake you can still do that. It would be interesting how these cars behave in case of a fire inside or something which leads me to my final thought: In case of issues on or with a ride in a theme park, there are usually operators. So in case of a technical malfunction there's an emergency stop which should make disarm systems in a safe manner and bring the ride into a safe position or at least make sure it stops safely. Of course it's not possible to trigger an e-stop as passenger but an operator can do that in case you can somehow make clear that it's needed right now. The situation in the video is a very bad experience because a phone call from the passengers device is needed and he was asked to do something in the app. Probably to identify the car and enable the remote control. Elevators handle this much better. There's an emergency system in the cabin which transmits all important information to the service center, so it's immediately clear where the emergency call originated from. An app on a smartphone should never replace this installation!
- dist-epoch 2y agoOne problem is if you are on a freeway, you can't just stop. Also passenger might be inebriated and randomly push the button. While I agree with you on principle, it's a hard problem to solve.
- kragen 2y agoYes, I agree that pushing the E-stop button is not free of risk. But it's a risk under the control of the person who will suffer most of the consequences.
- crazygringo 2y agoThat's not true. If you're on the freeway you could wind up killing multiple people behind you. It could be extremely dangerous.
- belter 2y ago> It could be extremely dangerous. You are on a beta, experimental, self driving vehicle. The time to update your life insurance has passed.
- alibarber 2y agoNo, I'm driving normally at 50 in the rain or whatever and some AI hype-wagon in front of me has slammed on the brakes and swerved across my lane. The CEO of HypeAI releases a heartfelt video in which they say they are truly sorry for my family's loss and by way of compensation offers them unlimited credits for HypeRides in select US cities conditions apply.
- kragen 2y agoIf the hype-wagon is swerving across lanes because of control software bugs, you definitely want the person in it to be able to hit an E-stop button so that it stops swerving after a finite number of lanes.
- ajross 2y agoThere was no emergency! The car wasn't "spinning", it was just driving around a parking lot and failing to find a location to stop. This was a navigation failure, not a control failure. And the solution is to call the human operators who can control it remotely. Which is what happened, and they did. Pulling an "emergency stop" level would have made things worse and not better. Is it embarassing for Waymo? Sure. But the BBC basically lied to you here, and you bought it. The circumstance you're imagining is not what happened. Just watch the video.
- belter 2y agoSo if there is no connectivity?
- ajross 2y agoPresumably it pulls over and stops if the backend connection drops, no? This is a kind of goalpost motion: you're countering an argument about an incorrectly-identified failure mode by positing that the condition would still obtain if there was a dual mode failure instead (i.e. that the car would get stuck in a navigation loop and have a bug in its recovery from connectivity issues). That's bad engineering, because you can always get to some kind of catastrophe if you keep piling on layers. Might as well just skip to "What if the motor circuit fails open and it accelerates forever?!" in that case.
- kragen 2y agoAn E-stop button would also solve the problem of the motor circuit failing closed, causing the kind of uncontrolled acceleration you're talking about.
- ajross 2y agoUh, that was sarcasm. Unintended acceleration failures are huge deals in the industry and absolutely already designed in with multiple (probably dozens) of layers of safety/redundancy at all levels up to and including human control. The point was that you can still imagine a N-mode failure that defeats all of that and use it to justifify whatever whizgig you're demanding in your local internet discussion. And that this was ridiculous, because that's not how you do engineering. And... you did.