4 ms·
Not every user owns an iPhone
- herbst 2y agoThose of us who learned computing mostly trough it's limitations are building software considering for them, even if mostly not necessary. Other just use electron for a command line wrapper.
- SoftTalker 2y agoBut the users who matter do.
- sandoze 2y agoSadly this rings true. Of all the apps and games we've ported to Android the cost has never been worth it. The games were pirated more than purchased and across both apps and games our support tickets went way up.
- cptcobalt 2y agoIt's also just harder to support because of the sheer fragmentation. I give my engineers different Android phones as their primary development devices and yet the weird Android issues that keep cropping up are near constant.
- lawgimenez 2y agoIn our case, the weird Android issues we encountered a lot lately has been due to the Jetpack Compose’s bugs. It’s amazing how buggy that framework is.
- smaudet 2y agoThis is difficult, because the mess that is mobile(?) (Android?) development could be better in general, but that also sounds like your software just is poorly designed... When it's a "works for me" on one platform but falls over with different hardware, that usually points to some serious issues (e.g. threading, contention, false assumptions) in your code/app. Not to say that there probably aren't buggy areas in Android itself, however with an appropriate test budget you could determine which are likely hardware (different phones) vs OS (common across devices, with simple repro apps) vs your software (you have bugzorz).
- arp242 2y agoIt's the Tesco app we're talking about, so none of that even applies. Saying that half the population somehow doesn't matter for one of the country's largest supermarket chains is completely mental on every level and is not a serious viewpoint.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kaladin-jasnah 2y agoIs this really true? In terms of monetary value, I am not sure what the deal is, but the author of this article works for Tesco, and the Tesco app is free on both platforms. In the UK, the market share of Android devices is much higher than in the US. I am an Android user who would almost certainly file useful bug reports.
- fidotron 2y agohttps://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/united-kingdom https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/united-kin... It's slightly more, but still not continental style: https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/germany https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/germany Android users in the english speaking world do have a habit of being way more trouble than they are worth.
- jckahn 2y agoIs this the world we want to live in? Reserving good things for the already advantaged? Wouldn’t life be a little better if we considered the needs of people a bit less lucky than ourselves?
- tomoyoirl 2y agoEh. If one wanted to do charity for the less fortunate, it might be better to just work for or give to bona fide charitable causes - rather than operating a marginal, possibly unprofitable Android app.
- jckahn 2y agoThis is missing the point. Shouldn't software generally work well for the people who use it? Or are we really just saying out loud that we build software for our own enrichment and the users are just a means to that end?
- smaudet 2y agoAgain, this sort of mind-rot is the worst... What happens when your general approach (ignore the margins) means the "bona fide charitable causes" can't operate because they all require top-of-the-line equipment to even be functional? Software is already shite, stop trying to justify making it more shite.
- silversmith 2y agoI own a Samsung S24 Ultra, by choice. Would not consider myself a charity case. I got my first smartphone years and years ago, and it was an android. Then they came out with the iPhone 3GS, and I briefly had that. Didn't like it, traded for an Android. Was ready to experiment back then, even briefly ran Windows Phone flashed on a HTC device. But inertia had its way with me, and I've been sticking with Android ever since. I have all the apps I need. I have my ages-old "weird" workflows set up, like keepass synced through OneDrive. I run an andblocker on firefox. Moving to an iPhone would be just so much pain for no real gain. If you don't provide an Android app, well, provide me with a burner iPhone if you want me to use your service.
- 2y ago
- nyrikki 2y agoSo was Internet Explorer at one time. I view maintaining android compatibility as a part of a vendor mitigation strategy, avoiding the creep of tight coupling that can make adjusting to market shifts an intractable problem.
- bad_user 2y agoI'm an Android user by choice. I must not matter. Personally, I don't understand why people buy iPhones. If you're in the US, I can understand the texting and video calls lock-in, but even then, I'd buy an Android just because I'd refuse to be a hostage to Apple's services, and I'd wear that green badge with pride. Furthermore, paying the price of the latest iPhone Pro (or Samsung S Ultra for that matter) is ridiculous and is only acceptable to people with high prices on their contracts. Much like what US people are going through — i.e., if you're paying $100+ on a mobile plan, might as well throw an iPhone in the mix to sweeten the deal. But on my 5 EUR unlimited data plan, me and others do not want an expensive phone included and prefer to pay for that phone up front.
- scarface_74 2y agoThe article tells you why, even the fastest Android phone has the same performance of a four year old iPhone. And you can get a phone plan for $15/month https://www.mintmobile.com/plans/ https://www.mintmobile.com/plans/
- Novosell 2y agoAs if performance is a consideration for 90% of phone buyers. It is to a point, yes. But any decent phone is well past the point of it not mattering.
- scarface_74 2y agoWell, according to the very article, there is a noticeable difference in performance between Android and iPhone.
- fidotron 2y agoThink about what you're saying here: the signal of someone being an Android user instead of an iOS one means they're willing to sacrifice their own user experience for (not that much) money and being tied to Google. As a company do you want people like that as your customer? Tesco is a low-mid end supermarket chain in the UK, so this is kind of irrelevant as they need to hit everyone, but in such circumstances people should not complain if the UX sucks on their device because they were excessively cheap, and yet, of course, they do. The truth is the numbers in the article are unacceptably slow across the board.
- cardanome 2y agoIf you are only focused on the US market and have a paid app, maybe. Outside the US, Android is the dominant platform by a wide margin and iOS support is lower priority. And for many services you can't just exclude users anyway, be it for legal reasons or because network effects.
- moi2388 2y agoWhat are you even doing that your website requires 3-5 seconds before it becomes interactive? This isn’t a iOS vs android problem, it’s a “our website isn’t optimized and we run 1000 ads and trackers” problem.
- hnthrow90348765 2y ago>If an engineer is frustrated at the responsiveness of an ‘Add to cart’ button click during development, then they’re probably more likely to investigate why and resolve it. IMO this should be in QA/SDET's realm (ideally via automated testing). If you're rich maybe you have one or a few SWEs devoted to performance. This will force other people within the company to also think about these metrics. Don't be a siloed developer quietly fixing all of these things for free just because it's slow on your machine.
- havaloc 2y agoAfter years of being iPhone-only, my site recently released an Android app. One month in, and we received a review that simply says "asking money"—unfortunately, the stereotypes seem to hold true. At this rate, we might break even on Android if we're lucky.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AnotherGoodName 2y agoWe framed some 1 star reviews that were essays of how terrible we were for asking for money for the app. All caps “this is a deceitful bait and switch how dare you ask for money! From the bottom of my heart I stab at thee...” for two pages type of ranting. You have to just laugh at shit like that.
- BizarroLand 2y agoI typically use android and have bought a few apps. They tend to fall into 2 categories. 1, you pay for the app, the app disables ads and/or enables full functionality. End of transaction 2, you pay for the app, the app then redirects you to the next "tier", where you are expected to pay more (or monthly) for some added feature. If you do not, you now get less functionality than you did before you paid for the app. You no longer get random ads, instead you get the same ad over and over telling you to spend more money on the app you just bought. (This was some music streaming app, I think TuneIn radio or something) If your app is #2, your company is also #2 and someone should flush it down the toilet. If your app is #1, then people should be content that they are getting what they paid for.
- AnotherGoodName 2y agoA free but ad supported app with a button to pay to remove ads for some context.
- lelandfe 2y agoAnd don't forget, Lighthouse metrics are just a starting point. Add specific metrics to your application. Here's an easy one: how long does it take for your mobile navigation hamburger button to be clickable? > Are you going beyond measuring a high level p75 and looking at the detail beneath? Hear hear.
- crowcroft 2y agoI think focussing on Android vs iOS might belie the true point which is not everyone has a 'good' phone. Almost any currently in use iPhone has a 'pretty good' processor and probably has up to date software. Even the iPhone 8 still holds up pretty well. On the Android side you get a wider spread of devices. I imagine a Pixel 8 or S23 compare pretty well to 'iOS'. The problem is old, low powered budget phones. I wonder how much of the problem one those phones is specific to the tech we use to build sites, and how much is the crappy hardware. I also don't imagine the expected value of a potential customers on a flagship iPhone or Pixel device is the same as a potential customer using a Huawei P20.
- zitterbewegung 2y agoThe problem isn’t older phones FTA they show that there is a 60% difference in flagships. I agree with you that the latest pixel has a huge disadvantage to a Samsung phone . The bigger problem is how much money you can budget for supporting every phone and which platform is more profitable. This is a video game but, Warframe was ported to iOS and then to Android. If this isn’t an indicator that you will make more money than what is ?
- Rhapso 2y agoI still think it is crazy we assumed "everybody has a phone"
- lotsofpulp 2y ago“Everybody worth transacting with” is more accurate. Makes sense for business, but a shame when government (or an essential business that should be a government utility) does it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jolux 2y agoWell as software engineers there’s not as much we can do for people who don’t have computing devices, but it’s still important that information be accessible without them.
- scblock 2y agoThe premise of "you should test on slower devices and connections" 100%. The way the article is framed, 0%. This is absolutely not an "iOS vs Android" discussion, and the author completely misses this fact.
- wat10000 2y agoBad connections deserve more attention. Slower devices too, but at least they get some attention even if too many people ignore them. The amount of code that can’t handle brief transient network errors is crazy and I hardly see it discussed. You don’t have to be in the middle of nowhere, either. I’m in dense suburbs, with gigabit fiber and pretty fast 5G, and apps will still fall apart if I’m using them while I walk away from my house as the device tries to decide if the weakening WiFi signal justifies switching to cellular yet.
- Toutouxc 2y agoI don't understand, isn't one of the main points of the article that even older iPhones (like the four year old iPhone 12) are still vastly more powerful than what most Android users have? There are numbers and graphs that show that web pages load significantly faster for iPhone users than for Android users.
- whatever1 2y agoEvery user with cash owns an iPhone.
- xhkkffbf 2y agoWell, except for the extra cash that they spent on buying an iPhone instead of a perfectly usable $150 Android.
- nottorp 2y agoMight be a Vimes boots theory case. Considering iPhones tend to stay usable much longer than the $150 Androids, it may be cheaper in the long run. Of course, not for the early adopter types who change their phone yearly. But that's their own fault.
- zuhsetaqi 2y agoAnd exactly this is the reason behind Apple users are being more profitable on average. iPhone users contains a bigger percentage of people who don’t have the attitude „I only spent enough to get it usable“ and are willing to pay for getting better quality.
- whatever1 2y agoIf you are not willing to spend $1000 on a cellphone you will likely not spend $9.99/month for my subscription AI fart app.
- jerryspringster 2y agoBut just enough cash to only afford an iPhone. Sent from my Z Fold 6.
- zabzonk 2y agoOh really? It takes a few more seconds to add a can of beans to your cart - who cares? The thing that really winds me up is forcing you to use a mobile for 2FA, when it would be easy to support a landline as well, which thankfully my bank does.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoI assume any organization that requires SMS 2FA is using mobile phone companies as a proxy for betting a unique human is on the other side.
- smaudet 2y agoWhat if there are many cans of beans? "It's just a few seconds" is the sort of mind-rot the article is targeting... every second matters, even when it seems like it doesn't...
- shallichange 2y agoIt's much more accurate to assume "everybody has Whatsapp" as the baseline. Many countries with users with plans with no data but unlimited Whatsapp
- gschizas 2y agoThat's a bit misleading... Most users globally don't own an iPhone. IIRC, only US and Canada have more iPhone users than Android users.
- timbit42 2y agoNo, 29 countries had more iPhones than Android phones, as of 2022.
- pdyc 2y agoTrue but it is very difficult for app developers to make apps for such wide range of devices. With iphone you can just test on the oldest supported device and you are good with android there is so much variation that you can't be sure even if you are targeting latest version. What is worse is that apple has handicapped safari from taking full advantage of its HW and does not allows other browser-makers to do it either this results in inferior experience for ios owners using webapps and web app developers are forced to release their apps on iphone.
- scarface_74 2y agoThe article states that browsing on the top of the line Android phones are about the speed of a four year old phone. If other browser makers can’t make a performant browser on Android, what makes you think either Google or Firefox is going to make a faster one for IOS? The article states that the inferior experience is on Android. If anything you need to make an app for Android because of how bad browsers perform even on top end phones
- youngtaff 2y agoIt’s the hardware that’s the issue not the browser… so apps are slower on Android too Chrome on iOS will be faster than Chrome on Android for this reason
- scarface_74 2y agoHow does that help in this situation? The issue isn’t iOS performance
- youngtaff 2y ago> If other browser makers can’t make a performant browser on Android, what makes you think either Google or Firefox is going to make a faster one for IOS? I interpreted this as you saying that Chrome wouldn’t be faster on iOS whereas I’m pretty sure it will
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- MarkusWandel 2y agoIt's not the iPhone, it's just a recent, fancy phone versus an out-of-date or cheap one. I refuse to pay $1K (Canadabucks) for something that could be destroyed in an instant if I happen to drop it or sit on it. I get whatever low-end phone Costco is pushing at the moment. The current one is a Moto G Play 2023 that cost me all of CAD$140 on special. It works fine, but bloat can catch up to anything. I use an app called Flashfood. It was fine. Then they restyled it. And whatever else they did, on my phone it is now so glacially slow that I don't use it as much any more. They'll never know, because they test it on $1K phones where you can waste so much compute on a glorified screen refresh. The actual functionality could have been done with a 2010 vintage phone, if coded efficiently. They should be testing on low-end phones. Because a significant percentage of the user base has them. Somewhere in a fiction novel I read about a music industry executive who would listen to new material on a crappy little record player, not on super fancy studio monitor equipment. Because that's what it had to sound good on.
- whycome 2y ago> The current one is a Moto G Play 2023 Interestingly, Google uses and emulated Moto G (Power) for site speed testing in their pagesight/lighthouse tool. > Captured at Jan 9, 2025 at 11:23 AM EST Emulated Moto G Power with Lighthouse 12.2.3 Single page sessionThis data is taken from a single page session, as opposed to field data summarizing many sessions. Initial page load Slow 4G throttling Using HeadlessChromium 131.0.6778.139 with lr https://pagespeed.web.dev/ https://pagespeed.web.dev/
- scarface_74 2y ago> It's not the iPhone, it's just a recent, fancy phone versus an out-of-date or cheap one. The article states that the fastest Android phone is about the same speed as the 4 year old iPhone 12.
- jasonjmcghee 2y agoTotally understand your position. For what it's worth, a lot of the higher end phones these days are much more durable. I have a handful of years out of date iphone and am not careful with it. It's been through a lot. I have always had a hard silicon case on it (seems dumb to not use a case), but the phone itself genuinely still looks brand new. Also if you buy a few generations old refurbished, it's only a few hundred, not $1k. All this being said, of course apps should run on low-mid end hardware. They're still wildly powerful devices.
- itishappy 2y agoHow lightweight are the Real User Monitoring solutions the article suggests? I'd worry it might be somewhat counterproductive to fight software bloat by adding even more fingerprinting and tracking...
- youngtaff 2y agoMany of the RUM solutions don’t collect personal data or use fingerprinting Yes they see the visitors IP address (but often don’t store it), they’ll often drop a cookie so pages can be tied together as a session but generally they’re bot interested in tracking people across sites or long time periods
- scarface_74 2y agoSo while HN users talk about the value of PWAs, web performance on the flagship Android phones are about the same as a four year old iPhone. Isn’t the lesson just the opposite? If you want performance on an Android phone you have to write a native app - especially for low end Android phones
- whycome 2y agoIm sure some sites could use performance loading as a filter of sorts: if you want to keep a certain economic class out, make the website require a fairly high performant (read: modern and expensive) device. Irony here too is that the linked site features a weird display of the author’s image and bio that takes up the entire screen and more on iPhone. It took me a couple seconds to realize it wasn’t a focus of the page.
- ortusdux 2y agoTicketmaster now requires a smartphone for some tickets/venues: "Delivery - Mobile - Free - Your phone's your ticket. Locate your tickets in your account - or in your app. When you go mobile, your tickets will not be emailed to you or available for print." I occasionally help a coworker buy tickets as he has a flip phone and no computer. Yesterday, the above was the only delivery option, so I couldn't help him. He was able to buy the tickets at the venue, but that is slowly going away as well.
- settsu 2y agoOkay, first of all, distill this down to a 2 minute preso that's heavy on the ROI, because many organizations aren't going to let go of the eye candy and—usually the worse offenders—the legion of third-party assets. Not to mention decision makers are too often simply not empathetic to such real world details. Second, minimum reqs are/were a thing. I'm not necessarily arguing for or against anything, but at some point... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Lastly, people using badly performing devices (not always inherently a hardware issue) are probably accustomed to things not working smoothly. You can only do so much.