4 ms·
Why would the school admin go nuclear over a request to integrate with the registration system, a system that is clearly intended to be used by applications: >
by ryandrake 2y ago
Why would the school admin go nuclear over a request to integrate with the registration system, a system that is clearly intended to be used by applications:
> “The Student Web Service gives your application access to information in the Student database such as course data, registration data, section data, person data, and term data (general academic data).”
It doesn't make any sense. Was there something left out of the story? Do they offer this web service as a honeypot to find and expel ambitious software developers?
- widforss 2y agoEverybody knows you have to be a drop-out to become successful in tech. This is basically their way of identifying potential entrepreneurs and helping them to drop out.
- cpfohl 2y agoI laughed out loud. Thanks!
- robocat 2y agoIndependent self-starter types that respond creatively to strict rules don't like schooling. They often don't bother to start university so never drop out. A few of the smartest people I personally know left school at 15 - they reacted badly to school restrictions and just wanted to just do something (not study) and often left home early too.
- mbreese 2y agoMy guess is that those integration points are intended to be used by University owned and operated services. Having a service that the University doesn't control wanting to do this would be difficult to get approval. Student data is highly protected (legally), so access to it through another application (where the operators could see other students' data) is problematic.
- impendia 2y agoThere are strict privacy laws (e.g. FERPA) which university administrators are terrified of violating and getting sued over. Meanwhile, most university "enterprise" software is a festering pile of shit. I'm very surprised by the extortion attempt, but sadly a massive overreaction doesn't much surprise me.
- mingus88 2y agoSomething I have noticed about higher education admins is that they hire consultants to do every project I came to understand that this is because the career positions have such great benefits, often the last bastion of pensions, that these people literally go there to die. So they take no risks and don’t try anything. They hire a consultant and if it doesn’t work out the blame lies there. They also get big budgets to implement the consultant solution, which is bloated and terrible, so the department head gets more money every year to support it
- uwthrowaway 2y agoSee: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42639478 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42639478
- niftyBeaks 2y agoI mean, it still doesn't make any sense. From what I can tell, OP never acquired the API keys needed to actually interact with the system. So he literally just made a demo app and asked permission to make it live. Instead of just saying "No" they tried to coerce him into slave labor.
- hooverd 2y agoYea, I don't understand the response to him here. You can just tell the random student who wants the keys to the student database "no" and go about your day.
- ahahahahah 2y agoIt's almost like this one-sided story is leaving some things out.
- geraldwhen 2y agoNope. Universities are wild and their technology is weak. It’s always been this way.
- dns_snek 2y agoVictim blaming is not cool. These types of over-the-top legal threats in response to good-faith engagement are extremely common and it's why bug bounties have safe harbor protections.
- lupire 2y ago[flagged]
- hooverd 2y agoNo, I do. It was an informal usage; they were requesting access to an internal web service and universities don't give that out to every student who asks.
- dang 2y agoPlease don't cross into personal attack. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- bsder 2y agoThe British have a nice word: "jobsworth". No bureaucrat is going to say "yes" because the consequences of something going wrong costs them their job while the benefits of things going right are zero. (For example, a DDoS. The number of times I have accidentally fired a DDoS at an API endpoint is non-trivial. Or it could get so popular that it's a DDoS. etc.)
- rincebrain 2y agoImagine an entire institution where your goal is to minimize the ability for anyone to convince people you were negligent, and you hate your job because it doesn't matter how you do it, you have little control outside of whatever fiefdom and backroom channels you've assembled. The kind of person who doesn't leave that role tends to be either someone who enjoys accumulating or wielding power, or would have trouble in roles outside of an institution like that. Now imagine a person who has almost no power just made a public spectacle about something in your camp that you've been not doing for years even though it's been a well known problem because nobody could make you do anything about it. You're probably going to go into overdrive and try to kill this story, even if it's not because you'll be directly punished in any way from it (because that's very uncommon in academia), but because this person DARED to challenge you. ...at least, that's my perception from years of time around toxic parts of academia (and some less toxic parts, but.) I'm not saying the story is true, I don't have enough data to comment, but I have absolutely seen enough academics go off the handle from 0 to 11 to buy this as plausible.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]