3 ms·
I am a huge fan of this type of incremental generative approach. Language isn’t precise enough to describe a final product, so generating intermediate steps is
by janalsncm 2y ago
I am a huge fan of this type of incremental generative approach. Language isn’t precise enough to describe a final product, so generating intermediate steps is very powerful.
I’d also like to see this in music generation. Tools like Suno are cool but I would much rather have something that generates MIDIs and instrument configurations instead.
Maybe this is a good lesson for generative tools. It’s possible to generate something that’s a good starting point. But what people actually want is long tail, so including the capability of precision modification is the difference between a canned demo and a powerful tool.
> Code coming soon
The examples are quite nice but I have no idea how reproducible they are.
- chaosprint 2y agogood point. few days ago I was thinking about restarting this project with Glicol https://github.com/chaosprint/RaveForce https://github.com/chaosprint/RaveForce RaveForce - An OpenAI Gym style toolkit for music generation experiments. Love suno but eventually I need midi or xml or some lossless samples to work with
- kadushka 2y agoI’d also like to see this in music generation. Tools like Suno are cool but I would much rather have something that generates MIDIs and instrument configurations instead. Sounds like you're looking for something like https://www.aiva.ai https://www.aiva.ai
- janalsncm 2y agoHonestly that site feels like they have a database of midis tagged by genre and pick them out randomly. It’s totally different from their demo song. I guess I’m hoping for something better. It’s also closed source, the web ui doesn’t have editing functionality, and the output is pretty disjointed. Maybe if I messed around with it enough the result would be decent.
- kadushka 2y agoFair enough. Still, for what you’ve described, Aiva is the best tool available.
- bufferoverflow 2y agoMIDI isn't enough. I want MIDI + filters, plus separate voice and custom sounds tracks.
- gexaha 2y agomicrotonal midi would be super awesome