2 ms·
I’m so fed up with “icons and cartoons” particle physics. It’s a waste of everyone’s time. It’s like trying to teach someone AI/ML and only ever showing them v
by jiggawatts 2y ago
I’m so fed up with “icons and cartoons” particle physics. It’s a waste of everyone’s time.
It’s like trying to teach someone AI/ML and only ever showing them vendor logos as illustrations and never the code or even pictorial representations of the models.
It’s absurd, yet 99% of such presentations for physics look like this — unnecessarily — because it is possible to show a rendering of fields, their various properties changing over time and space, etc…
You can’t learn anything from a thousand such videos that already exist, so what’s the point of a thousand and one? It adds nothing.
PS: To gauge if the content is meaningful or valueless, just ask yourself if anything would change about its educational value if you arbitrarily but consistently replaced the icons and/or their labels. If you’re still exactly as mystified as before, then their information content was zero. “The three quarks, rock, paper, and scissors have a three-way symmetry, blah blah blah”. Congratulations, you now know the quantum theory of roshambo!
- slt2021 2y agoits easy to critique, but have you produced a better educational content ?
- throwawayk7h 2y agoWhat educational materials would you recommend for someone dabbling?
- jiggawatts 2y agoSure, here’s an example that isn’t just “scribbles”: https://youtu.be/Sj_GSBaUE1o?si=TfqBYfpCYcy-OsL4 https://youtu.be/Sj_GSBaUE1o?si=TfqBYfpCYcy-OsL4
- agnivade 2y agoAs clearly stated in the video, you need to have prerequisite knowledge of quantum physics and special relativity. The quanta video can be understood by someone out of high school. Different audiences. Different goals. Just because something is all charts and animations, doesn't mean that it's bad.
- gitaarik 2y agoWell maybe meant for a different audience? You don't have to watch it if it doesn't appeal to you.