4 ms·
18,500 feet is 3.5 miles. So is there a different between being 3.5 miles under a bomb vs being 3.5 miles away from a bomb?
by ars 14y ago
18,500 feet is 3.5 miles. So is there a different between being 3.5 miles under a bomb vs being 3.5 miles away from a bomb?
- cma 14y agoAverage air density between you and it would be higher or lower depending on exactly what you mean by 'away'.
- mc32 14y agoI think the main thing is that at that altitude there are few particles to rain radiation upon you. On the ground there is dust, debris, ash etc. which will carry the radiation and land on everything.
- smacktoward 14y agoYes. Studies of nuclear explosion impact effects distinguish between "ground burst" and "air burst" detonations. Ground bursts typically have a smaller overall radius of damage, but do more intense damage at or near ground zero. Air bursts spread their effects across a wider radius, but damage is relatively more evenly distributed. Ground bursts also produce more fallout, since they dig up and irradiate earth and scatter it to the winds.
- gcb 14y ago"Ground bursts also produce more fallout, since they dig up and irradiate earth and scatter it to the winds." don't the produce the same amount of fallout? but the one in the dust is measurable and the air is not as easy to quantify?
- ars 14y agoReply to 'gcb' who's account is hellbanned, so I can't reply to him directly. No: Ground bursts cause way more fallout. Air pretty much can not become radioactive no matter how powerful the bomb. But soil can, so it becomes radioactive, then is scattered by the wind. The fallout from the bomb itself is different and is the same for both - but it's a smaller component, since there isn't that much of it.
- lutorm 14y agoThe initial radiation and heat wave is likely more intense because there's no ground to shield between you and the blast but, as someone else said, most radioactivity is from induced activity in ground material sucked up in the blast, so from that perspective air bursts are much less "dirty" as the fission products rise into the stratosphere and are dispersed in the winds. Definitely it would be better than being 3.5mi downwind of a ground blast, but probably not compared to being upwind. The shock wave is probably also less damaging because it comes from straight above so it won't pick up objects and throw them at you.
- baby 14y ago3.5 miles is 5.6 km