5 ms·
There's some academic research to the contrary; banning /r/fatpeoplehate and /r/coontown on Reddit reduced incidents of hateful speech across the platform. htt
by ceejayoz 2y ago
There's some academic research to the contrary; banning /r/fatpeoplehate and /r/coontown on Reddit reduced incidents of hateful speech across the platform.
https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/6zg6w6/reddits_bans_of_rcoontown_and_rfatpeoplehate/ https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/6zg6w6/reddits_ban... / https://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf https://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf
"Sunlight is the best disinfectant" is a great pithy slogan, but modern society needs bleach and chlorhexidine sometimes.
- naasking 2y ago> There's some academic research to the contrary; banning /r/fatpeoplehate and /r/coontown on Reddit reduced incidents of hateful speech across the platform. That does not imply it reduced hateful speech overall, maybe the censorship just increased antipathy and drove that speech underground or to other platforms where it couldn't be seen.
- ceejayoz 2y ago"Off Reddit" is a win. Recruitment in neutral-ish venues like Reddit is critical for extremist groups; people aren't starting on Stormfront.
- naasking 2y agoThat's still just a conjecture of a meaningful effect. Recruiters are able to change tactics in response you know. You're just naively assuming that those old tactics worked better just because reddit itself changed, but it could very well be the case that the more extreme rhetoric only attracted people who were already extremist and turned off moderates, but a more moderate approach that's now required could funnel more moderate people into an extremist pipeline. "Off reddit" is just a win for reddit's PR, and that's why they did it, and no other reason and no other effects can be inferred.
- intended 2y agoThe claim you are addressing is a separate one from the fatpeople hate story. And that claim is evidenced, It’s not conjecture. I dont have it handy on me, but we have mapped out the ways people are recruited, and things like fatpeoplehate, coontown, are the funnels for groups to find new recruits. Here’s one - https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3447535.3462504 https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3447535.3462504 There’s several others on things from ISIS to hacktivists. The mechanism is the same, heck - “red pill” is the term for this, it’s actually quite known.
- Karrot_Kream 2y agoNot necessarily. If it drives the content off Reddit but onto another platform that's friendly to only these extremists and their views then you may just end up radicalizing the members of the original banned subs even more. I don't know if that's what happened and there's probably a lot more research to do here but I'm not convinced that deplatforming is actually a good outcome societally without more data.
- miramba 2y ago[flagged]
- ceejayoz 2y agoAgainst what, microbes? There’s a reason surgeons disinfect their hands with more than a skylight. Sunlight is a shitty disinfectant.
- miramba 2y agoI wasn‘t aware that society means surgery. Likewise that veiled means literal. By extension, ethnic cleansing probably means giving certain parts of a population a well deserved bath? Edit: I did not want to imply that you meant it that way. But in a different context, or coming from the wrong person, it may sound like a dog whistle.
- kcplate 2y agoSo your example is two places that were intentionally moderated to be hateful and also suppressed the non-hateful speech in those subreddits? So removing a censored platform eliminated the problem? Amazing how that works!
- Barrin92 2y agoNo, you should actually go and read the paper. It didn't just reduce the type of content posted in the subreddit, they tracked individual users that were active and their behavior overall changed, including in other subreddits compared to before. Essentially what it showed was that if you pull people out of a particular echo chamber, then that had a sustained effect on how they behaved. Which is evidence contrary to the often made claim that they'd just leave and go somewhere else. It's in line with the theory that the internet fosters extremism because it enables insular pathological communities that in the analog era you'd have been slapped out of long ago by people who aren't nuts.
- kcplate 2y ago> Essentially what it showed was that if you pull people out of a particular echo chamber, then that had a sustained effect on how they behaved. So…silos and echo chambers are bad. Seems to me that was part of my original point. I am suggesting that censorship of information leads people to the silos.
- intended 2y agoSo you are saying, that things got better when people were banned. Because when they got banned, many other communities saw improvements as well, not just those?
- kcplate 2y agoNo I am saying that when you censor/suppress debate in the public square you drive people underground where they land in echo chambers and develop extreme views because they don’t have public debate. You don’t need to ban people from echo chambers if they don’t land there in the first place. Your solution is reactive to a problem you caused. My solution is don’t create the problem in the first place.
- raxxor 2y agoMaybe it reduced hate on this single metric, but the complaint is more about the errors in fact checking. And single subreddits aren't really convincing about the reliability of fact checkers if their independence is in question. In the end they do rely on a truth-authority, which is problematic, especially for political content. And Meta reported that political demands increased.