I think this works well with at least somewhat interested students (like in university), but I'm not so sure before. My experience when I was younger is that a

I think this works well with at least somewhat interested students (like in university), but I'm not so sure before. My experience when I was younger is that a significant proportion of students don't do anything outside of school. So you're trading not doing the homework with not reading the material. And then you'll essentially have to repeat the material during class hours, unless you're willing to leave half the class totally clueless. At least with the homework at home, the ones not doing anything are only penalising themselves. I totally agree though that homework at home is dying. It already wasn't great before for a variety of reasons, and now it's basically totally useless.