I’m suspicious of decontextualization in the name of forming “either X or Y” absolutes. Either 8 character passwords are fine and secure, or bad and should be

I’m suspicious of decontextualization in the name of forming “either X or Y” absolutes. Either 8 character passwords are fine and secure, or bad and should be banned? With no context between “€x8;,O{w” and “password”? I suspect runway design has more variables than just distance to obstacles.