5 ms·
Battle Scenes depicted in moving pictures before CGI
- magicbuzz 2y agoThe most marked comparison I’ve seen is between the B-25’s in Catch 22 and the aircraft in Masters of the Air. The real B-25s struggle and climb into the air on takeoff and it’s evidently real. Masters of the Air just had shot after shot of aircraft sitting dully in the sky - so eminently artificial.
- mikhailfranco 2y agoPerhaps expecting at least an honorable mention for Kurosawa: from solo combat, through small group engagements (there were only 7 + a village :) up to the sweeping mass banner-men battles of Kagemusha and Ran.
- daseiner1 2y ago[flagged]
- misnome 2y agoWould you object as strongly if it had said that he was a really nice guy? Would it be more or less honest a retelling of history if this was ignored or left out? TFA is clearly not discounting the work because of it, and probably nobody would good-faith argue that personality was always decoupled from work? In which case how much you care is just a POV?
- daseiner1 2y agoI would. I'm not advocating white-washing here. My point is that this piece is not about artist biographies. For this sort of piece, I don't care if he was a serial adulterer, a volunteer fireman, or a local hero, and think that inserting those details is an unnecessary thumb on the scale.
- ssklash 2y agoI'm not sure why you think your personal opinions about mentioning that a well-known racist was in fact a well-known racist matter, and why you think you have some sort of say in another person's blog post. This "scale" that you think the author is putting their thumb on does not exist. They are writing on their own personal website.
- daseiner1 2y agoThis is a discussion site, which has a comment section. My initial comment, which I think was quite even-handed, has generated discussion. My personal opinions matter just as much as yours or any other user on this site, which in the grand scheme of things is "not at all". I have just as much of a right to comment on this post. Ignore me if you'd like. But fine, I'll bite. To temporarily eschew the equanimity that I think I've thus far demonstrated, I'm not at all surprised to find that you have chosen the "shut the fuck up" response to commentary you find distasteful. Folks of your temperament, left/right/& center, invariably land there when one of their sacred cows is held up for examination.
- dotancohen 2y agoI came to the comments just to post this. Ironic coming from film buff, the idea that we should judge historical figures through a modern lens.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 2y ago... but D.W. Griffith was considered racist by his contemporaries, and Birth of a Nation was controversial from the moment it was released.
- 1832 2y ago>The film was controversial even before its release and it has remained so ever since; it has been called "the most controversial film ever made in the United States" and "the most reprehensibly racist film in Hollywood history." The film has been denounced for its racist depiction of African Americans. The film portrays its black characters (many of whom are played by white actors in blackface) as unintelligent and sexually aggressive toward white women. The Ku Klux Klan (KKK), a white supremacist far-right hate group, is portrayed as a heroic force that protects white women and maintains white supremacy. (from Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Birth_of_a_Nation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Birth_of_a_Nation)
- WillPostForFood 2y agoThe quotes in the Wiki page are modern, not from the time of the release. It was controversial at release, but not so much that there wasn't a White House screening. It was the first motion picture to be screened inside the White House, viewed there by President Woodrow Wilson, his family, and members of his cabinet.
- notahacker 2y agoI'm not sure the fact that his film glorifying the Ku Kux Klan was watched by a president also noted for being racist even by the standards of his time (who later condemned the film and claimed to have been unaware of its contents) somehow innoculates it against charges of racism
- Finnucane 2y agoThe movie's title cards include pro-Klan statements from Woodrow Wilson.
- a_cardboard_box 2y agoHe wasn't just a product of his time. He was so racist his works were controversial when released. Is a single sentence about that really too much?
- idontwantthis 2y agoIMO, not a good choice by the writer to not make clear (especially to non americans) how incredibly racist the film was, even being released at the most racist time since slavery, and instead say it about the director.
- WillPostForFood 2y agoHe was a mainstream Hollywood director, working with the biggest stars of the day, and co-founded the studio United Artists with Charlie Chaplin, Mary Pickford, and Douglas Fairbanks. The film was some controversial, but much less than you would hope. Most of the controversy is retrospective. https://static01.nyt.com/images/2016/02/05/arts/05FRIDAYFILE/05FRIDAYFILE-superJumbo.jpg?quality=75&auto=webp https://static01.nyt.com/images/2016/02/05/arts/05FRIDAYFILE...
- pavlov 2y agoSurely you have to draw a line somewhere, though? Adolf Hitler was a painter and Kim Il-Jong directed movies. Neither of them was any good, but if they had been, would it really make sense to judge their art in isolation, without the slightest mention of the authors’ tyranny and mass murder? Griffith made movies that he fully intended as Ku Klux Klan propaganda. That is not in doubt. At the same time these movies are also important technical achievements and milestones of cinema. It’s not “loathsome and cowardly” to point out his racist message. A similar problem exists with Leni Riefenstahl, the photographer and director who exulted Hitler, as well as many 1960s European leftist directors who uncritically worshipped Mao. They all should be seen and criticized in context.
- cliftonpowell 2y agoAs a joke I'll sometimes show images of Hitler's art to people. They're always received with high praise, and rarely is the praise retracted when they learn who the artist was. It's usually "oh that's funny, well he was pretty good. Wow. Didn't know that." Yeah I think art and artist can be evaluated on separate criteria.
- pavlov 2y agoNobody thinks Hitler’s art is museum-quality or art historically important in the same way that Griffith’s and Riefenstahl’s movies are. And even if Hitler’s paintings really had been particularly good, I still don’t think museums in Germany and elsewhere would exhibit them. Enough people feel that would be highly disrespectful of the victims of the Holocaust (probably most museum curators would think that). You can of course believe this kind of red line shouldn’t exist in society, but it’s there.
- dotancohen 2y agoMy grandfather was a slave in Hitler's work camps. His parents and brothers perished in Hitler's death camps. And the story of his wife's family, my grandmother, would leave you shivering. I would most certainly visit a museum exhibit of Hitler's paintings.
- trickyager 2y agoIf anything, leaving this information out would flatten the complexities to an even greater degree. Understanding and sharing a well-rounded perspective of a person (e.g. that this person held objectively incorrect beliefs that were despised among his contemporaries) is quite literally why people study history.
- dotancohen 2y ago> objectively incorrect beliefs Do you honestly not see the irony in declaring your own culture "objectively correct"? Do you eat meat? Burn carbon? These are things that conceivably may one day be considered even worse than we consider racism today. Don't be so quick to judge the past by today's values.
- trickyager 2y agoYou're bringing up subjective beliefs as a straw man. The idea that it's morally wrong to eat meat or burn carbon are subjective. I specifically said objectively incorrect beliefs. The idea that there exist races of humans who are uniquely "superior" or "inferior" is an objectively incorrect belief. It is not true now, and it has never been true.
- dotancohen 2y agoThe idea that there exist species who are uniquely "superior" or "inferior" is an objectively incorrect belief. It is not true now, and it has never been true. Every species on Earth fulfills a purpose, and humans have no right to farm any of them. It is objectively better for humans to return to pre-agricultural levels of population and eat only what we catch with our bare hands. Of course, I don't believe that statement. But it is as "objectively true" as yours. I just don't want to dispute yours, because I personally agree with it. But I can not call it an objectively better statement.
- ssklash 2y agoCan you take your very thinly-veiled racism apology elsewhere?
- lupusreal 2y agoNothing tops Waterloo, critics are imbeciles. About as close to a perfect movie as it gets.
- cliftonpowell 2y agoTotally agree. And you never even hear about the movie anymore. Total shame. I watch it every year with newfound awe.
- edgarvaldes 2y agoWatched it some days ago for the first time, incredible battle scenes.
- emmelaich 2y agoOdd little mistake on the Kubrick film. It's "Barry Lyndon" not "Barry Lindon". Definitely worth watching if you haven't seen it already.
- marcellus23 2y agoMy favorite Kubrick movie. I never get tired of watching it. Absolutely beautiful.
- emmelaich 2y agofrom May 2020
- zcrossing 2y ago[dead]
- buildsjets 2y agoHow about a space battle scene with and without CGI? Compare "The Dam Busters" from 1955 with propeller airplanes to "A New Hope" with X-wings, title says 1977 but I think this is one of the enhanced editions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lNdb03Hw18M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lNdb03Hw18M
- cybercity 2y agoWW2 fighters in space has always seemed really weird scifi to me. If we ever fight wars in space it will be done by computers trying to out maneuver eachother over millions of miles.
- krapp 2y ago> If we ever fight wars in space it will be done by computers trying to out maneuver eachother over millions of miles. It's entertainment. Dogfights in space with pew-pew lasers are entertaining and make intuitive, if not technical, sense to people who understand how aircraft work. Drones making slight corrective maneuvers and sniping each other at light-second distances isn't entertaining.
- 542354234235 2y agoYou might find this interesting. Detailed breakdown how the physics shape space combat in the highly realistic “Children of a Dead Earth” game. Everything from orbital mechanics to dissipating heat from rail guns. https://childrenofadeadearth.wordpress.com/ https://childrenofadeadearth.wordpress.com/
- ashoeafoot 2y agoIts near c projectile wepons and knowing which pillar volume will be a deadzone next. The floor is lava and all that shields is shooters leashed to proxies leashed to proxies..
- anon432986 2y agoMissing Gallipoli (Peter Weir - 1981) I went to Uni with a mature age guy who was one of the extras for the army. If I remember correctly he was ADF reserves at the time.
- cybercity 2y agoDuring the cold war countries had vast standing armies. The Netherlands had 1000 tanks! Without the draft getting 5000 extras for your film would be way too expensive.