4 ms·

It's immoral that you cannot turn off videos in a browser and/or that this isn't the default option on phones.

by pier25 2y ago

drukenemo 2y ago
I use Stopthemadness to stop video autoplay
- musicale 2y ago
  The fact that we need a "stop the madness" app for Safari is proof of Safari's insanity. If Stopthemadness actually works reliably, it is also an existence proof that blocking video autoplay is possible, and that Apple is simply not fixing the "never auto-play" setting in Safari. Perhaps Apple and Mozilla should just remove the "never auto-play" settings in Safari and Firefox and say that they are doing so in order to empower web sites and adtech companies (including Google/youtube, who pays them a lot of money) to force you to view unwanted video advertisements.
musicale 2y ago
I agree. It's insanely user-hostile that the "never auto-play" setting in Safari (for example) doesn't work and hasn't worked for years. To be honest, I have no recollection of it ever working reliably. Although it is an arms race and obnoxious web pages can have javascript/webassembly video players that render into a canvas, etc., I still blame Apple for not sorting this out, and even backtracking on click/tap-to-play. IIRC, at some point Apple did roll out default click/tap-to-play on iPhones, and there was a huge outcry from web developers (probably including Google/youtube) that it broke their sites. I expect the real complaint was that it interfered with pushing unwanted video advertisements.
carlosjobim 2y ago
You can do that easily on iOS.
catlikesshrimp 2y ago
You probably mean "iphones" Android firefox does have an option to turn off autoplay (video and sound) It can't be set as default because most people are used to spam ads. Heck, most people seek them on tictok
readthenotes1 2y ago
It's easy enough in some browsers
agilob 2y ago
> cannot turn off videos in a browser But ublock, VPN and DNS blockers are available on mobile

It's immoral that you cannot turn off videos in a browser and/or that this isn't the default option on phones.

by pier25 2y ago

It's immoral that you cannot turn off videos in a browser and/or that this isn't the default option on phones.

drukenemo 2y ago

I use Stopthemadness to stop video autoplay

musicale 2y ago
The fact that we need a "stop the madness" app for Safari is proof of Safari's insanity. If Stopthemadness actually works reliably, it is also an existence proof that blocking video autoplay is possible, and that Apple is simply not fixing the "never auto-play" setting in Safari. Perhaps Apple and Mozilla should just remove the "never auto-play" settings in Safari and Firefox and say that they are doing so in order to empower web sites and adtech companies (including Google/youtube, who pays them a lot of money) to force you to view unwanted video advertisements.

musicale 2y ago

I agree. It's insanely user-hostile that the "never auto-play" setting in Safari (for example) doesn't work and hasn't worked for years. To be honest, I have no recollection of it ever working reliably. Although it is an arms race and obnoxious web pages can have javascript/webassembly video players that render into a canvas, etc., I still blame Apple for not sorting this out, and even backtracking on click/tap-to-play. IIRC, at some point Apple did roll out default click/tap-to-play on iPhones, and there was a huge outcry from web developers (probably including Google/youtube) that it broke their sites. I expect the real complaint was that it interfered with pushing unwanted video advertisements.

carlosjobim 2y ago

You can do that easily on iOS.

catlikesshrimp 2y ago

You probably mean "iphones" Android firefox does have an option to turn off autoplay (video and sound) It can't be set as default because most people are used to spam ads. Heck, most people seek them on tictok

readthenotes1 2y ago

It's easy enough in some browsers

agilob 2y ago

> cannot turn off videos in a browser But ublock, VPN and DNS blockers are available on mobile