5 ms·
Is there a good reason for any country to have spies at all, especially for internal matters? I feel that spying on other countries (let alone on own citizens)
by mtgx 14y ago
Is there a good reason for any country to have spies at all, especially for internal matters?
I feel that spying on other countries (let alone on own citizens) shouldn't exist at all, but it has become accepted by societies as something that the Governments just have to do, to "make their job easier", just like even FBI said recently that they'd prefer if they didn't need to get warrants, because it would make their job easier. Having a democracy and rights for people must be really tough on authorities, or at least that's how they sound.
- kennon 14y agoI'm curious why you think international spying is unnecessary. Until countries cease to compete for limited resources, it seems to me like an inevitability.
- DanI-S 14y agoWhy should it be considered morally acceptable by those who vote? When have we had the opportunity to vote on it?
- kennon 14y agoI understood mtgx's question to be based on practical grounds, not moral ones. But in answer to your question, I think of espionage as something akin to the military. Perhaps in an ideal world neither would be necessary, but unfortunately the world is not a utopia. Thus, from a realistic standpoint, spying is sort of like doing market research for a startup. It allows you to make predictive decisions instead of reactive ones.
- KaoruAoiShiho 14y agoI agree with international spying. If the other countries don't allow you that information, you must spy to get that information. A scenario of nations having bad or inaccurate information about other countries, their status and their intentions can make the world a more dangerous place. However domestic spying seems kind of silly. You should just be able to collect the information you need voluntarily through census and and surveys, without resorting to spying. If they refuse to provide the information, get a warrant.
- sliverstorm 14y agoI think of espionage as something akin to the military. As far as I am concerned, the two are not simply akin but deeply intertwined. Espionage can greatly improve the effectiveness of your military.
- natermer 14y agode·moc·ra·cy /diˈmäkrəsē/ Noun: 1. A system of government by the whole population or all the eligible members of a state, typically through elected representatives. 2. A state governed in such a way. 3. The cake is a lie.
- davidhollander 14y agoThis seems rather mercantilist. There are many island nations with little natural resources and little capacity for offensive intelligence gathering which are quite wealthy through trade alone.
- irishcoffee 14y agoI think here you're assuming wealth was the limited resource referred to, were it might be other things.
- debacle 14y agoThe corporate/bureaucratic symbiosis means that spying on your citizens is seen as necessary to control the populace.
- pstuart 14y agoThen add in "terrorism", the war on drugs and child pornography (think of the children!) as excuses for these actions and the game is won.