3 ms·
So it doesn’t seem to be mentioned here, but has there been some major recent change in the economics of the _scale_ of the tunnels? Dublin’s beleaguered metro
by rsynnott 2y ago
So it doesn’t seem to be mentioned here, but has there been some major recent change in the economics of the _scale_ of the tunnels? Dublin’s beleaguered metro project recently put out its new design; there are a bunch of changes from the previous early-noughties design, but one of the more eyebrow-raising ones is that the bored sections will now be a single _9.5 meter diameter_ tunnel; it is claimed that this is less disruptive and cheaper than the two-narrow-tunnel approach used in conventional bored metros. Recent metro lines is Barcelona and Madrid have also used the single-giant-tunnel approach.
Anyone know what’s going on here? Intuitively you’d expect two small tunnels to be cheaper; you’re moving a lot less material.
- timschmidt 2y agoI suspect the cost is not in volume of material removed, but in operation and maintenance of the machine and it's crew. One tunnel instead of two is half as much machine and crew time.
- freeopinion 2y agoPlease explain how you reasoned this out. If one 9.5m tunnel requires 70 m³ of removal for every meter of forward progress, and two 5m tunnels requires 40 m³ of removal for every meter of forward progress, won't it take nearly twice as long to dig the single larger tunnel? Won't that require twice the machine hours and twice the crew hours? How does the volume of material removed not directly impact machine and crew costs?
- jcgrillo 2y agoTwo dump trucks can't pass eachother in a 5m tunnel. That'll put a restrictive upper bound on material removal rate which isn't present in the larger tunnel.
- Symbiote 2y agoNote they use railway trucks to remove spoil (and transport everything else) from a TBM. A narrow gauge temporary track behind the TBM as it advances.
- timschmidt 2y agoSeems like larger machines are likely to have larger material removal rates. Dependent on the surface of the digging tool and it's feed rate.
- Hilift 2y agoOne of the references in the article mentions using better alloys ("modified tool steel") and 20" discs produces better results and lower overall costs due to time between disc replacement. This could be A8 "chipper knife" steel. https://www.robbinstbm.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Smading_20InchCutters_RETC2017.pdf https://www.robbinstbm.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Smadin... https://www.litechtools.com/products/tbm-disc-cutter/ https://www.litechtools.com/products/tbm-disc-cutter/
- timschmidt 2y agoMakes sense. I was thinking more about the face of the machine itself being larger, likely the size of the tunnel, and would contain many such 20" discs. In other words, given that the material removal rate of each disc is likely fairly similar from machine to machine, the machine with more of them removes more material at once.
- freeopinion 2y agoIt seems self-evident that all additional material removed has 0 additional value. In fact it has negative value because it increases the requirements for any support or finish materials. So energizing and consuming 7/4 more discs is just pure waste. It also adds disposal costs. The most obvious argument I can think of to support this approach is if the excess material could be sold at a profit. But that seems dubious.
- timschmidt 2y ago> So energizing and consuming 7/4 more discs is just pure waste. That is and assumption and not self evident. There are lots of reasons one might want to use many cutters. It is a common practice in wood and metal machining, for instance[1]. Having additional cutting surfaces reduces the rate of wear, provides redundancy in case of chipping, increases the mean time between required services, allows cutters to run cooler, reduces chatter, improves surface finish, and a host of other reasons. Seems like you could research it. 1: https://www.advancedmachinery.co.uk/content/product/8500_0_z.jpg https://www.advancedmachinery.co.uk/content/product/8500_0_z...
- metalman 2y agoTwo of everything, ventilation, electrical, water, telecoms,you name a system, and then name it again. Chances are that set backs required for engineering and existing infrastructure will be challenging, with two parallel sytems. edit: there is an assumption that the space required undergroud is free and infinite, when in fact two tunnels with set backs and spacing will require more total space than one larger tunnel and will then limit the availible area for deep building foundations and anything else. Then we get to interchandes, and emergency access. And there is a ready market for any material removed from the dig, which will be a very routine operation. And while the volume of fill removed will be greater, the internal volume per cubic foot of tunnel wall will also be greater, allowing for more generous alotment of space for future systems and untilities, bigger wider lanes, etc. Somewhere I came across a journal, just for tunnel makers, and there equipment. And recent reports have tunnels bieng completed ahead of schedule and on budget, so they are infact, taking care of business.
- rsynnott 2y agoOh, yep, I’ve no doubt that if they can ever actually get planning through for the damn thing, they’ll be able to build it. In Ireland it’s generally the planning that’s the problem. What I’m curious about, though, is what, if anything, changed to make this single-bore approach suddenly popular. A lot of new metro lines seem to be built that way, but old (and not, like, 19th century, even most 20th century stuff) always seem to be double-bore.
- ianburrell 2y agoOne big factor for single-bore subway is that can fit the stations inside the tunnel. That saves a lot of money digging out the stations. I think Barcelone Line 9 is the one that popularized it. I suspect the other factor is that they figured out how to make large TBM.