6 ms·
Muslim here. I never understood both sides and their actions. I mean I find both Islamic fundamentalism and American actions all round globe both equally dumb.
by kamaal 14y ago
Muslim here.
I never understood both sides and their actions. I mean I find both Islamic fundamentalism and American actions all round globe both equally dumb.
I don't think OBL ever had it as an explicit aim to pull down US militarily or culturally transform US into a Islamic state. That is impossible, and I assume somebody like him already understood that. I guess his aim was to drag US into a war and then reduce them to a state USSR, now russia was in 1990 post Afghanistan war. Long wars benefit nobody. They are a huge drain on man power, economy and morale of a nation. Its actually surprising that US fell for it. I was expecting more of a Intelligence based response where the CIA would hunt him down and kill him, instead of wasting trillions dollars.
On the other hand. Afghans seem to be very stubborn people. They don't give up easily no matter how shitty state they are in. Its just in their blood and culture to not accept foreign occupation over them. Even the British that had the entire Indian subcontinent under them couldn't conquer them. In the recent history alone, every body knows what has happened of USSR after going there. So no matter how bad the Taliban is, they still consider them as their own country men compared to Americans who actually released them from their bondage.
As a moderate muslim, I feel bad every time I'm pulled up for an ideology which I have nothing to do with. I've been a subject of religious discrimination many times since 911. I've been asked to come for extra rounds for job interviews, pulled up separately and checked at building security points, had troubles to open bank accounts, asked to delay visa filing for visiting abroad etc innumerable number of times. I feel having an arabicized name a huge liability to carry, a kind of burden for which you have to pay no matter even if you have nothing to do with their ideology.
On the other hand I see so much turmoil in the west, due to the war ordinary people like me having to pay for no mistake of theirs. Wars, economics crisis etc.
When I look at all this, I can't help but wonder that perpetrators of these crimes actually won.
- euroclydon 14y agoIts actually surprising that US fell for it. Yep. Bush would have been a hero if he hadn't fallen for it. Compassionate conservatism, expressed in Medicare Part C. Tax cuts combined with modest military expansion would have held the deficit in check. But remember the pundits saying, "this one calles for boots on the ground"? Even Jon Stewart showed a clip of Bush or someone making a compassionate statement, and commented "you're killing my blood lust." And he meant it! I don't guess Clinton wouldn't have fallen for it -- he didn't during all of OBL's significant attacks in the 90's.
- sigzero 14y agoClinton would have done the same. 9/11 was much different than the attacks in the 90s.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoClinton would have attacked Afghanistan, sure. But would he have stayed in Afghanistan and/or attacked Iraq? Those are the two items that have cost dearly.
- ams6110 14y agoThere were two big reasons reasons the US went into Iraq. One was Saddam Hussein and WMD. Everyone believed that he had them, and it's a matter of fact that he had used them in the past. Though they were never found, it's not illogical to believe that he was simply able to move them elsewhere or destroy them before they were discovered. And taking out his regime would remove a large destabilizing factor in that part of the world (in theory anyway). The other reason was to create a local distraction. To keep "the terrorists" occupied, their violence and attacks confined to that part of the world, and not in the US. In that sense, they "fell for it" too. If the public need for "revenge" had been satisfied by attacking Afghanistan, I think Clinton would have stopped there. He was not a risk-taker, and he was totally driven by polls.
- mangala 14y agoThis was the narrative toed by the Bush administration and Fox News, but many Americans and the international community by and large did not agree.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoI think that's largely a case of selective memory. People often have a rosy memory of what they believed. Bush said he had clear evidence of WMD's in Iraq, that he showed this to Blair and Blair confirmed. I think it would be fair to say that most people would agree that Hussein wanted WMD's. So I think it's fair to think that most Americans and most in the international community believed that Iraq had WMD's. The argument was mostly over whether an invasion was an appropriate response. It was only "crazies" who believed both that Bush lied and that he was able to either snooker Blair or convince him to join in the lie. Sometimes the crazies are right, though.
- ynniv 14y agoIts actually surprising that US fell for it. The US didn't fall for anything - 9/11 was an opportunity to advance military goals in the Middle East. We planned to invade Afghanistan before the event[1]. About three weeks afterward this plan was expanded to include seven countries in ten years ("Iraq, and then Syria, Lebanon, Libya, Somalia, Sudan and, finishing off, Iran")[2]. Some of those were accomplished by the "Arab Spring", but the State Department wasn't uninvolved in that and asked twitter to reschedule maintenance so that it would be "an effective communications tool" during the 2009 Iranian election[3]. The only confusing actor is Bin Laden, who attacked a superpower that had already expressed a desire to invade his people. [1 http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/1550366.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/1550366.stm] [2 http://www.salon.com/2007/10/12/wesley_clark/ http://www.salon.com/2007/10/12/wesley_clark/] [3 http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/06/16/us-iran-election-twitter-usa-idUSWBT01137420090616 http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/06/16/us-iran-election-t...]
- accountswu 14y agoI agree for the most part, with a minor disagreement on the following statement: >The only confusing actor is Bin Laden, who attacked a superpower that had already expressed a desire to invade his people. The superpower was already occupying much of his people through puppet dictators; the Saudi, Egyptian, Yemeni, Bahraini, Jordanian and Lebanese for example. Israel was created out as a "Jewish state" on 78% of Palestine while the population of Palestine was still only 34% Jewish after mass-migration campaign of the 1900s (1905 Jewish population of Palestine was 3%) but their bombings on Palestinian villagers successfully cleansed some 80% of the native population. The refugees still aren't allowed to return while any Jew (born Jewish or converted) can instantly migrate to Palestine and get a US-subsidized home in a Jewish only settlement. The US diplomatic, monetary and military support for this 60+ year old occupation and denial of injustice was a major motivation for Osama. Every year the US and Israel vote against this UNGA resolution while the rest of the whole world votes for a peaceful settlement (i.e. normalization of relations and recognition of Israel in return for a Palestinian state on 22% of original Palestine and a symbolic return of some refugees, some compensation for the rest of the refugees, which would give Israel the chance to preserve a Jewish majority rather than equal rights for all). https://www.google.com/search?q=peaceful+settlement+of+the+question+of+palestine https://www.google.com/search?q=peaceful+settlement+of+the+q... http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/997AAD7178DBFD66852579950056A99C http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/997AAD7178DBFD6685257995... A/RES/66/17 26 January 2012 http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2008/ga10791.doc.htm http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2008/ga10791.doc.htm "The Assembly also adopted by a recorded vote of 164 in favour to 7 against ( Australia, Israel, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Nauru, Palau, United States), with 3 abstentions ( Cameroon, Canada, Tonga) (Annex IV), the resolution on the “Peaceful settlement of the question of Palestine”." http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/cd358b22995a4b078525767e006ac786?OpenDocument http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/cd358b22995a4b078525767e... Peaceful settlement of the question of Palestine A/64/L.23 23 November 2009 http://www.normanfinkelstein.com/resolving-the-israel-palestine-conflict-what-we-can-learn-from-gandhi/ http://www.normanfinkelstein.com/resolving-the-israel-palest... Year Vote [Yes-No-Abstained] Negative votes cast by… 2005 156-6-9 Israel, United States , Australia, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Palau 2006 157-7-10 Israel, United States , Australia, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Nauru, Palau 2007 161-7-5 Israel, United States , Australia, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Nauru, Palau
- accountswu 14y agoResponding to update glanch that his profile is probably marked as a spammer and all comments made by him are greyed out (he probably is seeing them ok. Begin quote: glanch 35 minutes ago | link [dead] "Fell for it"? It's easy to "fall for it" when you are in the position to make a LOT of money for that fall. Cheney. Halliburton. Exclusive government contracts. Sickening.
- nowarninglabel 14y ago>I don't think OBL ever had it as an explicit aim to pull down US militarily or culturally transform US into a Islamic state Actually, if you read his letters, he did state some of these as his goals, but more importantly, his advisor, Ayman al-Zawahiri, had this goal in mind, as it was made explicit in "The Shade of the Quran" by Sayyid Qatb who was Zawahiri's mentor in Egypt after they spent time in prison together.
- geraldo 14y ago"I was expecting more of a Intelligence based response where the CIA would hunt him down and kill him, instead of wasting trillions dollars." You have to realize, while the money is wasted from the perspective of tax payers, it's a profit from the perspective of, say, weapons manufacturers (just taking those as an example). Sure, they "wasted" money, that wasn't theirs, on things that enhanced their control. The time and resources of common people actually do get wasted, but other than that, the whole thing was and continues to be a success. Just don't lump a whole nation, the citizens and the policy makers, together. That can only lead to confusion. War is a racket, so is the war on terror - and if these fundamentalists didn't conveniently exist, others would have to be created.