4 ms·
The outcome of this case pushes power away from the executive, and towards the legislature.
by tptacek 2y ago
The outcome of this case pushes power away from the executive, and towards the legislature.
- wtallis 2y agoIt doesn't change the legislature's power; they were and still are free to write detailed regulations into law. It just shifted the power in cases of less-specific regulations away from the executive and to the courts. The courts are every bit as capable as the executive of making tortured interpretations of law, and to some extent are required to do so by stare decisis.
- tptacek 2y agoAllowing the executive branch to make new laws does, in fact, take power from the legislative branch!
- mmooss 2y agoIs the legislature more democratic than the executive? Also, what does that mean in reality? The 538 elected legislators can't regulate everything (or anything), of course. Whatever they do, it will require delegating power, as I said, to functionaries. And in any case, implementing laws and policy is an executive branch function - for the legislature to do it (beyond writing law) would be a violation of separation of powers.
- tptacek 2y agoYes, it is.
- mmooss 2y agoI am so much wiser after reading your comment!
- tptacek 2y agoNobody elected the FCC commissioners and staff making these rules. Virtually every legislator is elected.
- mmooss 2y agoThat was addressed earlier in the conversation, multiple times.
- tptacek 2y agoI don't know if it was "addressed", but it couldn't have been "rebutted", because this is basically axiomatic. Loper doesn't overturn specific delegations of power to regulators; doing so would basically neuter the entire executive branch. What it says is that when there's ambiguity about a statute --- such as when a telecommunications bill that barely mentions the Internet and appears to view it in approximately the same light as TMBG's "Dial-a-Song" is used as the basis for sweeping Internet regulation --- the courts are no longer required to take the regulator's word for it. There's nothing wrong with delegations of power. They just need to be specific; they should represent a legibly expressed intent of the democratically elected legislative branch, which is the branch that the framers created specifically to craft legislation.
- mmooss 2y ago> this is basically axiomatic And what I said is 'self-evident' to me! Why even bother telling it to anyone else?
- idlewords 2y agoThe legislature, and in particular the House, being more democratic than the executive is a bedrock principle of American democracy. Read the Federalist Papers if you want a full theoretical grounding and justification of why from the framers' perspective.
- 2y ago